Understeer in S1 in the wet
Understeer in S1 in the wet
Author
Discussion

NathanK

Original Poster:

80 posts

253 months

Saturday 23rd September 2006
quotequote all
I was on my first wet trackday at Abingdon on 15th. I have fitted a new spare set of wheels with 225 Pzeros on the back for the first time.

No matter what speed I went into one particular fast 2nd/3rd gear corner (with loads of tarmac runoff) it would understeer. I was expecting it to oversteer when too fast in the wet. I'm no hero on the roads so am always well within the limits on normal roads so have no experience before.

In some ways I was disappointed that it wasn't as exciting as I had expected!

Chatting with a friend we reckon it is probably because of the wider rear track than standard, and the fact that the rears were brand new, and the fronts closer to wearing out, so rain disappation was better at the rear and they held better.

Does this sound like a reasonable explanation of what might have happened?

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Saturday 23rd September 2006
quotequote all
Yep, sounds reasonable to me.

In any case, understeer in the wet is to be expected, due to the lack of weight over the front end.

Trust me, it's a whole lot better than having oversteer!

NathanK

Original Poster:

80 posts

253 months

Saturday 23rd September 2006
quotequote all
I wanted to catch the oversteer bring it back, and be an official driving god...

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Saturday 23rd September 2006
quotequote all
May I suggest that the P-Zeros aren't helping your cause Nat, certainly not in terms of understeer anyway.
Had them on my car when I bought it but have now changed to Bf Goodrich G force Profilers all round. Sorted out the understeer problem and have made the car much less snappy in the wet. Also you could look at the Toyo Proxes TR-1 or the official Lotus Yokohama Advan LTS (reckoned the best choice).

NathanK

Original Poster:

80 posts

253 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
Tipper... These were attached to the new wheels I just bought.. Have T1-R's as my daily wheels. Once I've killed these tyres I'm tempted with something track specific so I can compare and contrast.

richyboy

3,749 posts

248 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
Totally unrelated sorry and probably been covered before but maybe someone searching for understeer issues will find it helpful if the future. In the topgear clip showing the s2 111s, Gavin Kershaw says to get rid of some the understeer you fit bigger front tyres, does anyone know the sizes for this?

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
NathanK said:
I wanted to catch the oversteer bring it back, and be an official driving god...


If you are an official Driving God (see Gavan Kershaw in the Top Gear clip referred to above ^^^^^^^^^), then you provoke the oversteer by lifting off as you turn in, then ride the resultant oversteer slide.

Usual disclaimers apply: if you pick up some scenery or a fellow track day participant whilst practicing this, it's nobody's fault but your own!

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
richyboy said:
In the topgear clip showing the s2 111s, Gavin Kershaw says to get rid of some the understeer you fit bigger front tyres, does anyone know the sizes for this?


Straight from the horse's mouth

Mark B

1,671 posts

296 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
Mate, no offence, but going on a track day with a set of unknown tyres is probably the fastest way to needing a new clam, front, rear or both if you ask me. I wouldn't drive the Elise on the road with a set of unknown tyres let alone driving it hard and trying to be a driving god on a track day!! When I bought my Elise, the first job I did was new tyres all round.

And it was a wet day.... You'd have been better with the Toyo's..

And, as for chassis balance, knackered fronts and new rears will be your clear indicator towards understeer..... No grip on the front and more on the rear... The 225 width is irrelevant...

No doubt someone will be along in a minute advising a Walshy Day, seems that's what everyone advises.... I'm not so sure, but an activity day at North Weald run by LOT would be a great way to practice the understeer oversteer balance..



TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
Nat, I'm a bit confused??
What tyres were you running on track and how worn were they?

NathanK

Original Poster:

80 posts

253 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
Mark B said:
Mate, no offence, but going on a track day with a set of unknown tyres is probably the fastest way to needing a new clam, front, rear or both if you ask me. I wouldn't drive the Elise on the road with a set of unknown tyres let alone driving it hard and trying to be a driving god on a track day!! When I bought my Elise, the first job I did was new tyres all round.

And it was a wet day.... You'd have been better with the Toyo's..

And, as for chassis balance, knackered fronts and new rears will be your clear indicator towards understeer..... No grip on the front and more on the rear... The 225 width is irrelevant...

No doubt someone will be along in a minute advising a Walshy Day, seems that's what everyone advises.... I'm not so sure, but an activity day at North Weald run by LOT would be a great way to practice the understeer oversteer balance..


Mark - I think you set your assumption volume to 11 there...

You have to get to know a set of tyres somehow, driving them for a couple of weeks on the road, then on a track seems sensible to me. The particular corner I was experimenting with had about 50 metres of tarmac run off too, so no clam crunching objects were within view! Also given my OP comment of being a cautious road driver, my driving god comment was not serious!

The tyres were PZeros, 185's with 2-4 mm on the front and 225's with 7ish at the back, by no means knackered as I had to drive there and back.


hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
You could simply have been going into the corner too fast and if your setup is understeer bias just snap off the throttle whilst turning in. I drive with an understeer bias and tend to boot the throttle before the apex to get some oversteer like this (vulume up and listen for the revs then the rubber chirping) http://media.putfile.com/Abbeville-10

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
Nat, all respect and all that but with 2-4 mm on the fronts the're pretty close to legal minimum and tyres are really past their best before that. On a wet track you'd have not had much grip from the fronts and a whole lot more from your new rears (especially bearing in mind the liz was originally designed for a 185 front/205 rears)
The P Zeros where fine tyres ten years ago but there are better options for the S1 Elise today. I reckon you'd have been better off on your Toyos (I assume you're using these all tound on the road?).
Also driving technique will influence how much understeer you experience but I won't presume on your driving ablilites.
One further thought. When did you last have the car geod. A chat with a good specialist can help set the car up to your driving style and preferences.

NathanK

Original Poster:

80 posts

253 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
Agreed that they were a bit close, the forecast was a dry day, but it rained a bit and was wet for the first hour. If I had been expecting water I would have used my new Toyos.
Thoroughly agree the PZeros are passed their prime, but they were already on the spare set of wheels I bought, and safely gave me a day having fun. It seems a bit over the top to ditch them, but perhaps there are some risks that I haven't thought of.

My OP was more about the fact that I got a bit of understeer and no dramatics in the wet, and I wasn't expecting that.

I've never had the car geod, it's still on the orginal Koni's and it's now done 25K so I am assuming they will need replacing soonish anyway. I hadn't thought I have sufficent experience or skill to benefit from it being done. May be it would make the car faster, but will it help me learn to drive on a track? I'm happy to drive as fast as I can in the car, rather than make the car go as fast as it can... if you see what I mean.

If a geo would help the car be more predictable at the limit then there is clearly a benefit. So far on the track I've only had a few proper 'moments' and they have all been driver induced.. if not intentionally!

Net of all this is, I seriously don't want to spanner my car into something hard... but I do want to use it on track without the need for spending too much extra cash, and lots of trips to North Weald!

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
You can get your geo checked for £15, checkout my tech wiki at http://wiki.seloc.org/index.php/Geo_S to learn more.

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
I had the P-zeros on mine and almost killed myself in the wet. They were so bad that I changed them before they had even worn out! I now have Toyo T1R's and they are fantastic, upgrade your front size to 195's and keep the backs at 225. Massive grip, dry or wet... The P-zeros are a good tyre but not for the elise as its too light. its hard to get enough heat into them... try mytyres.co.uk, fronts for less than £40 each, cant be bad! a set for under £200.

Bill K 111

134 posts

244 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
Thanks for that geo link. Very useful. Having just sold our front wheel drive race car, we 'have all the geo gear but no idea' with regards to the Elise. Part of the fun of getting the Elise is to make the adjustments ourselves and find what is the most fun for giving passenger/client rides on track days etc. (I'd probably leave it standard but the damn thing came with new Nitrons...what can you do eh?)

Thanks again.

Nick J

1,084 posts

255 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
I had worn out Pirelli PZeros on the front and an unknown budget tyre on the back when I bought mine. After a hairy oversteer moment going round the evo triangle I decided to go for Toyo proxes TR-1, the difference is amazing.

Mark B

1,671 posts

296 months

Tuesday 26th September 2006
quotequote all
Hi Nathan, you would be amazed at tyre degradation as they approach the minimum levels. Having been on a tyre behaviour course run by Dunlop a few years back, they have graphs that show the tyre performance as the tyre tread depth reduces, the degradation is pretty linear over the first 60 - 70% of the tyre wear, from this point on the tyre behaviour and performace, particularly in the wet deteriorates dramatically. The Police and Special MOD cars will always have tyre changed well ahead of the minimum level as a matter of safety..

Having said all, going to an air field with older tyres makes sense as the surface will generally wear the tyres very quickly... But your original question was aimed at the community to answer what seems a fairly obvious question....

No offence meant though

david@mediacopy

173 posts

252 months

Tuesday 26th September 2006
quotequote all
NathanK said:
I wanted to catch the oversteer bring it back, and be an official driving god...


I 'modified' my rear suspension by driving into the step in fount of my house. Then I forgot all about it only to find I had planty of oversteer on my first track day at Donington. I watched the marshal at the Melborne loop reach for his flag each time I went round sideways. Good fun, but I had the geo done at the next service.