111S or 111R?
Author
Discussion

sjm18

Original Poster:

282 posts

250 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
I'm thinking of getting a 111R in the next few weeks, but have heard that the 111S may in fact be a better option as you're not forever trying to spin the nuts off it! The car will be used for mostly local driving and a bit of weekend fun - may even do he very occasional track day, but would not base my buying-decision on this part of it. Any thoughts please, pref from people who have driven both? confused

emenel

891 posts

250 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
Do you know what you have just started?

Here it comes ...

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
The R if you can afford it.

pasthim

19,436 posts

265 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
111S. I have a 111R and they are known for very weak clutches so you'd need to expect a new clutch after 10,000m. Great though it is you do need to seriously rev it get it really moving but I have heard that it is just as fast as a 111S up to the point that the second cam kicks in anyway. The Toyota greabox is not that slick either so check that out on a 111S, its probably better. Apart from that they are virtually identical. Bear in mind what I have said and then try both.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
As above, the best answer to your question is to try both, as they are very different in the way the engine delivers the goods.

boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
pasthim said:
111S. I have a 111R and they are known for very weak clutches so you'd need to expect a new clutch after 10,000m. Great though it is you do need to seriously rev it get it really moving but I have heard that it is just as fast as a 111S up to the point that the second cam kicks in anyway. The Toyota greabox is not that slick either so check that out on a 111S, its probably better. Apart from that they are virtually identical. Bear in mind what I have said and then try both.


I'm sorry you've had issues with your Clutch but this is very new news to meconfused I've only seen a few people on Seleoc with clutch issues? Do you think it's because of the previous owner slipping the clutch to get the car into the power band? Sound's far more likely to me than dodge clutches in all 111R's/Exige's

Also worth looking at a New Elise S cracking deal's and with the newer better Toyota engine

Boggy


Edited by boggy on Tuesday 13th March 13:19

21TonyK

13,414 posts

240 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
You really have to drive both. For me the R suited my driving style and the use of the car better than an S would.

Tina K

22,031 posts

243 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
I've driven both and I bought the 111R. The lairy second cam moments were what really sold the car to me.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
And to add some balance I didn't want to be chasing the cam and so bought a 111S.

Other considerations:

VED - £75 cheaper for the K series
Fuel consumption 10 mpg better

I reckon for me it adds up to a saving of around £750 a year...enough to fix the head gasket hehe

Try 'em all, see what you think, getting an Elise regardless of engine type is 90% of the equation and whatever you buy someone will always overtake you on track

Garipie

40 posts

239 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
I test drove both and bought a very late 111S - mainly because i dont drive that high in the rev range (too stingey on fuel on my comute to work) so the 111S was more fun at lower revs. Hope that helps

Grinzzz

566 posts

248 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
pasthim said:
The Toyota greabox is not that slick either so check that out on a 111S, its probably better.

If the gearchange on a toyota isnt like slotting the bolt into a well oiled rifle then theres something wrong. Mines absolutely superb despite my frequent attempts to make it otherwise. I found the 111S like stirring a spoon in a marshmallow pudding in comparison. (I did have some better metaphors but had second thoughts)

Either are great, for low day to day cost or lots of driving in traffic I'd go the 111S. For reliability and the mad 2nd cam go for the 111R. In the real world they're about the same speed.


EDITED TO SAY....make sure the 111R is warmed up, if you base your experience on a ten minute test drive its VERY misleading on gearchanges - mine is a pig on 1st and 2nd for the first couple of minutes.

Edited by Grinzzz on Tuesday 13th March 16:32

21TonyK

13,414 posts

240 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
Grinzzz said:
pasthim said:
The Toyota greabox is not that slick either so check that out on a 111S, its probably better.

If the gearchange on a toyota isnt like slotting the bolt into a well oiled rifle then theres something wrong. Mines absolutely superb despite my frequent attempts to make it otherwise. I found the 111S like stirring a spoon in a marshmallow pudding in comparison.


Ditto. Gearbox was one of the reasons I opted for the R although I think I did drive a particularly bad S.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
Gearchange action is definitely better on the R, I've sworn at the 'box on mine enough on trackdays, think a Geary shift is on the cards. However it's still nowhere near a decent mechanical shift, I guess I've been spoilt by having owned a Puma.


Edited by kevin ritson on Tuesday 13th March 16:05

mahju

407 posts

242 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
kevin ritson said:
And to add some balance I didn't want to be chasing the cam and so bought a 111S.

Other considerations:
VED - £75 cheaper for the K series
Fuel consumption 10 mpg better


Ding to that... also when I was looking, and wanting a hard top, the 111R was about £3-5K more expensive for a similar spec / year / milage

bing

1,946 posts

269 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
Grinzzz said:



EDITED TO SAY....make sure the 111R is warmed up, if you base your experience on a ten minute test drive its VERY misleading on gearchanges - mine is a pig on 1st and 2nd for the first couple of minutes.


Yep mine is the same for the first few mins!!!!

pasthim

19,436 posts

265 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
Grinzzz said:
pasthim said:
The Toyota greabox is not that slick either so check that out on a 111S, its probably better.

If the gearchange on a toyota isnt like slotting the bolt into a well oiled rifle then theres something wrong. Mines absolutely superb despite my frequent attempts to make it otherwise. I found the 111S like stirring a spoon in a marshmallow pudding in comparison. (I did have some better metaphors but had second thoughts)

Either are great, for low day to day cost or lots of driving in traffic I'd go the 111S. For reliability and the mad 2nd cam go for the 111R. In the real world they're about the same speed.


EDITED TO SAY....make sure the 111R is warmed up, if you base your experience on a ten minute test drive its VERY misleading on gearchanges - mine is a pig on 1st and 2nd for the first couple of minutes.

Edited by Grinzzz on Tuesday 13th March 16:32


It is good but just not THAT good I find. It doesn't feel as easy to swap from say 3rd to 2nd as you go across the gate. It is good but not having tried the 111S I can't say it is worse or better than that gearbox although people here seem to know and say 111R is better.


pasthim

19,436 posts

265 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
boggy said:
pasthim said:
111S. I have a 111R and they are known for very weak clutches so you'd need to expect a new clutch after 10,000m. Great though it is you do need to seriously rev it get it really moving but I have heard that it is just as fast as a 111S up to the point that the second cam kicks in anyway. The Toyota greabox is not that slick either so check that out on a 111S, its probably better. Apart from that they are virtually identical. Bear in mind what I have said and then try both.


I'm sorry you've had issues with your Clutch but this is very new news to meconfused I've only seen a few people on Seleoc with clutch issues? Do you think it's because of the previous owner slipping the clutch to get the car into the power band? Sound's far more likely to me than dodge clutches in all 111R's/Exige's

Also worth looking at a New Elise S cracking deal's and with the newer better Toyota engine

Boggy


Edited by boggy on Tuesday 13th March 13:19


Well there are a few on SELOC who have had issues at very low mileages. Mine has covered 10K and the clutch is high. I just don't imagine Celica's have the same problem so I am mystified as to why it should be on its way out or has failed on other people's cars so early. I have never ever needed a new clutch on any car I have had and so looking for one already is not impressing me! Even Evos clutches last 40,000+ I understand. it could be previous driver abuse but still....10,000m!!!!

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
pasthim said:
boggy said:
pasthim said:
111S. I have a 111R and they are known for very weak clutches so you'd need to expect a new clutch after 10,000m. Great though it is you do need to seriously rev it get it really moving but I have heard that it is just as fast as a 111S up to the point that the second cam kicks in anyway. The Toyota greabox is not that slick either so check that out on a 111S, its probably better. Apart from that they are virtually identical. Bear in mind what I have said and then try both.


I'm sorry you've had issues with your Clutch but this is very new news to meconfused I've only seen a few people on Seleoc with clutch issues? Do you think it's because of the previous owner slipping the clutch to get the car into the power band? Sound's far more likely to me than dodge clutches in all 111R's/Exige's

Also worth looking at a New Elise S cracking deal's and with the newer better Toyota engine

Boggy


Edited by boggy on Tuesday 13th March 13:19


Well there are a few on SELOC who have had issues at very low mileages. Mine has covered 10K and the clutch is high. I just don't imagine Celica's have the same problem so I am mystified as to why it should be on its way out or has failed on other people's cars so early. I have never ever needed a new clutch on any car I have had and so looking for one already is not impressing me! Even Evos clutches last 40,000+ I understand. it could be previous driver abuse but still....10,000m!!!!


Heading towards an 18k service in just over a year - absolutely no clutch issues.

Grinzzz

566 posts

248 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
I think the clutch is a tad on the weak side. I've only done one racing start but it didnt impress me one jot, judging from the cheese-on-toast smell it wasnt too happy either. I can see how repeated 4k rpm traffic light launches could easily wear it out in double quick time.

I'm an inveterate "rower" with the box - I always change down on the move, quite often fluffing heal and toe. Mines clutch is ok so far (14k miles) ; I think it just needs treating sympathetically. Gooby has loads of miles on his - perhaps he should comment how long his has lasted.

I have no problem with going from any gear (apart from 6th which I dont think I've tried) to second - the detents in the box are very well thought out and its a very positive action to move across the box. Works for me.

Stephanie Plum

2,797 posts

242 months

Tuesday 13th March 2007
quotequote all
The 111S works for me. I did however get a short shift fitted - hated the oroginal gearchange when I test drove it! Makes a huge difference and not expensive. Had the new 111S as a courtesy car the other day and didn't like the gearbox in that at all - found it a long throw and it felt really clunky (technical term you understand rolleyes)