Advice required. Exige from Boxster
Advice required. Exige from Boxster
Author
Discussion

scotia_steve74

Original Poster:

653 posts

258 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
I've been driving a 2.7 new style Boxster for a couple of years but to be honest although it is a fun car to drive I'm starting to feel it isn't quite enough for what I'd like to do, and now that I've bought a Honda CBR600F sports bike, it won't fit in my garage (5m)!

I've been toying with the idea of a Lotus Exige for a year or so, had a GT3 briefly (long story - but had to go back to the dealer due to undisclosed history) but the Lotus was the most exciting to drive )test drove an 05 Exige).

I've just started doing a few proper track days and have booked Knockhill (local track) for April and have a Ring/ SPA trip booked for July with the Boxster.

Basically it would be great if someone can advise on whether the Exige is a great car for a mix of road and track use. I have a day to day car and the bike which share the commuting role so no need there.

Also, my new house has enormous speedbumps outside - in the GT3 I just took them sideways. Same with the Exige?

Anyway, my local dealer is pretty good. There is a nice low mileage 04 Exige for 24k. Very tempted...

L888DER

523 posts

243 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
i have gone the other way went from exige to Boxster. I know this is very obvious but you are buying a very differant car. The only simularity with these two cars is the price bracket!

simonk

908 posts

256 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
I dont think you will find a better car for a mixture of road and track use. But that requirement itself is a hell of a compromise - theres plenty of better road cars around, and plenty of better track cars around.

HTH?!

Simon

edp190

336 posts

240 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
Thats alot of money for an 04 car, you need to push Graham a bit harder!

I used to have an s2 exige and its was fine for cobbles aand speedbumbs. However my s1 exige is much lower and i have to take speed bumbs very slowly or at 45 degrees.

The s2 exige is a great overall package for fast road and track. I would get one with performance pack if you are going to do track work especially in an 04 car as standard/touring spec cars do not have oil coolers iirc. You will find lots more local help @ www.scottishelises.com.

HTH cheers Ed

Phil-Ch

1,132 posts

295 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
Can't go wrong with an Exige IMO. I would also prefer a low mileage 04 Exige to a newer one (MY06 or newer): The older ones should be a bit lighter and more dedicated (no drive-by-wire, traction, less sound proofing) and you don't get the drive-by-wire stuff!

Performance pack is definately something it should have though.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
You'll love it. Buy Jamie's (jamwill79) Exige S if you can. Very nice car.

scotia_steve74

Original Poster:

653 posts

258 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
Ah, need to trade my Box so private sales are out! Too much risk for me I'm afraid!

It's also the perfect sized car - 3.5m yes? Having a 5m garage and a motorbike does limit the choice of car!!


I spotted one at Edinburgh airport in one of those prize draw things - red Exige - stunning!

If I can trade my Box for one and get some cash back I'd be a very happy man!

If anyone is looking for a 987 2.7.... to swap for an Exige




Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
I'm just in the process of swapping my Boxster S back to a 111S. I've had the boxster a year now and I just don't rate it. Yes it's comfy and rattle free but it really doesn't cut it in driving enjoyment. Boxster S is more powerful than the Exige (I've driven both the standard and the supercharged) but is much heavier and less interesting

I had a sports tourer before the boxster and thought getting the boxster would be a step up, I was wrong. I can't wait to get back into a Lotus again, MUCH better to drive than a boxster IMO. Plus the fact that the porsche ('03 car 20k miles) cost a small fortune in repair bills and needs an oil tanker to refuel every other day!

Porsche good, Lotus Better.

I'd have an Exige over a Boxster any day of the week.

scotia_steve74

Original Poster:

653 posts

258 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
Yes, that's a good point - the car will cost a fortune when it's due stuff.

Had the roof replaced for rattles under warranty! Cost the dealer 11k!!!

I'm using the Boxster less and less - I find it slightly ostentatious and since moving to bikes like the fact that there are not many of you. I would hope the Lotus would be like that!

If anybody knows the Strada in Edinburgh, my only issue is those speedbumps as I've just bought a house there! Maybe a testdrive to them would be a good idea!

Also got two days at SPA booked for June! Would love the car for then....

edp190

336 posts

240 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
I know the Strada and they have given you monster speedbumbs in there!

An s2 with standard ride height would be fine i reckon but any less and you would struggle.
cheers

scotia_steve74

Original Poster:

653 posts

258 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
They are supposed to be reducing them soon! The Boxster gets over them fine and in the GT3 I had to take things easy downhill and on ramps.

If anyone has any experience that would be great!

Cheers

Steve

Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
If it helps, My boxster will sometimes ground the nose on some speedbumps where my elise wouldn't. I don;t theink the ride height between the exige and elise is much different so you should be okay. The boxster has a longer nose which is the thing that really matters, not it's distance from the ground.

scotia_steve74

Original Poster:

653 posts

258 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
Cool! Will have to arrange a visit to see the chap at Murray Motors - seems like a nice bloke to buy a car from.

So what do you think, Exige 2004 or a later car?

Budget £20-£25K....

Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Wednesday 4th April 2007
quotequote all
You should just go and drive one! Then decide which year to go for. Always go for condition of the car rather than the year/milage.

scotia_steve74

Original Poster:

653 posts

258 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
One more thing.... Elise S/ R better? Just read Evo 1996 COTY....

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
Much of a muchness. Exige you can still get a soft top kit for. The one consideration will be tyres. You've less choice on Exige rims.

mcdude

12 posts

249 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
scotia_steve74 said:
One more thing.... Elise S/ R better? Just read Evo 1996 COTY....

Elise R is better than Elise S. Though there are two different Elise S models: the Rover K-Series on and the new Toyota engined one. The R is still the one to go for if you are talking £20-25k budget.

Elise vs. Exige is a debate that will never end and one I am not prepared to enter in - all that do die in mysterious circumstances.

Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
IMO doesn't matter what you get, Exige, Elise S, R whatever. It'll always put a bigger smile on your face than any boxster will, believe me I know from experience!

scotia_steve74

Original Poster:

653 posts

258 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
Cheers guys!

Spoke with the dealer today who was very helpful. As long as the Lotus and the bike fit in the garage I'm onto a winner!

jez o

353 posts

257 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
"Also, my new house has enormous speedbumps outside - in the GT3 I just took them sideways."

A very good effort sir- it would make my day to see that and a complete mockery of the 'speedbumps'. They're supposed to slow you down, not for drift practice!! Do you go for front wheels to the right and rear wheels to the left of the hump?!!