Bad Handling
Author
Discussion

deep purple

Original Poster:

35 posts

236 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
Recently had fitted a pair of Toyo TI-R's to the rear of my S1, based on some good comments from the PH fraternity. Took it out yesterday on a good driving road in Norfolk with lots of flowing bends and it was wallowing around like a clapped out citroen.I have a feeling I know what the answer is cause I've only changed one thing very recently and I guess you guys will say 'told you so' - I still have the original pirelli's on the front!!! Taking it out again today just to make sure my mind isn't playing tricks, but will be careful. Looks like I might have to fork out for some new front Toyos, pirellis still have plenty of tread on them. Comments please guys, but be easy on me.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
Three issues really:

1) The pirellis are probably hard as nails now, so will have very little grip even with plenty of tread.
2) Don't run different tyres front and rear on an elise - they grip and displace water very differently. This can cause problems during cornering - understeer or oversteer, as well as lockup of either front or rear wheels under braking. If your rear weheels lock 1st under braking, it gets very scary.
3) Toyo T1R's take a long time to bed in. The grip gets a lot better after 500-1000 miles.

In summary, change the fronts before you have problems.

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
If you did not get the tyres from a knowledgable Lotus specialist, the tyre pressure is probaly way too high.
Mixing tyres? BAD idea...

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
Shangani's points are on the money, after 500 miles or so they'll feel a lot better and won't squirm on the treadblocks so badly. If you can find a carpark to do donuts in that helps! And in fact with the T1R's you want to be running them at a higher pressure than Yoko's or Pirelli's. I was recommended this by a very good LoT instructor (Malcolm). Try running 28/29 or even upto 30/31.

deep purple

Original Poster:

35 posts

236 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice, lets hope the Easter Bunny brings me a new set of Toyo fronts.

Davislove

2,295 posts

277 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
the reason they feel shite is because the car wasn't developed with them!

Lotus engineers spent months perfectly the handling of the elise and none of it involved using Toyo tyres!

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
They do feel quite sort of 'springy' for the first few hundred miles.
Definately bin those P-zeros though - mixing tyres on the Elise is a big No-no. You'll notice a change in the steering feel (less of it)when you get the new tyres fitted so give yourself a chance to re-learn the car.
S-Works post has just reminded me to pop a bit more air into my Toyos. I recently fitted a set and I'm not getting on with them (been running them at 24/26 though).

walker2686

52 posts

240 months

Saturday 7th April 2007
quotequote all
Davislove said:
the reason they feel shite is because the car wasn't developed with them!

Lotus engineers spent months perfectly the handling of the elise and none of it involved using Toyo tyres!


So..... only one type of tyre can be used then or the handling is shite? I think not.

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Saturday 7th April 2007
quotequote all
This is very interesting as I have been recomended that I use TR1's on my 111R. I have been told cheaper and better. Has anyone put TR1 on a 111R? Does it work?

shnozz

30,696 posts

302 months

Saturday 7th April 2007
quotequote all
I would never use Toyos ever on any car after my experience with them on one of my TVRs.

cej

961 posts

253 months

Saturday 7th April 2007
quotequote all
shnozz said:
I would never use Toyos ever on any car after my experience with them on one of my TVRs.


Please explain. What problems ?

Haven't had any problems with the T1Rs on my elise.

shnozz

30,696 posts

302 months

Saturday 7th April 2007
quotequote all
Awful handling from day 1. You have to scrub the release agent from any tyre, but never before have I had to do 700 miles before there was any sign of improvement (and then it was minimal). You're a quarter of the way into the tyres life and only just got rid of the release agent.

Even once they were scrubbed in the sidewalls were so flimsy that I drove the car with sweaty palms for fear of the back end constantly feeling as though it was going to swap ends at any time.

The design of the tyre, I understand, has changed since then but on the basis of my experience, I'd never buy anything from them again. Truly shocking.

The funny part being that I listened to a whole load of opinion from PH before choosing them and it was only after I had posted my experiences that other people dared joining me in going against the grain. I think a lot of sunday polishers had fitted them with no problems but at 30 mph you could run nankanjubieles with 50 psi at each corner and probably not notice.

mft

1,752 posts

253 months

Saturday 7th April 2007
quotequote all
I had a very similar experience with Toyos on my old 200sx. I found that the grip level was reasonable, especially in the wet, but the sidewall flex was instantly noticable, and never ceased to be a problem. Admittedly it was a heavier car with very stiff suspension, which might have exacerbated things, but it constantly felt like the rear subframe bushes were flexing.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Saturday 7th April 2007
quotequote all
Snozz. Were you running T1-Ss? The T1-Rs are better from the sidewall issue point of view but I can believe that the're still relatively squishy.
These tyres have only just been discussed on another thread where I stated my dislike for them on the Elise (Only tyres I could get at short notice to replace worn out BFGs). I have to agree that they take a time to bed in but even then they don't work very well on the car. I've lost a bit of steering feel, find that my steering isn't as quick and accurate as it used to be and I still get a bit of a floaty sensation on them (About 1,500 miles use). I've also experienced a couple of opposite lock moments in situations where I couldn't have imagined it happening on the BFGs. I'm running at 24/26 and will give Tim's suggestion of higher pressures a try.
I won't condemn the tyres out of hand though as I found they worked very well on my MG ZT (fwd). They seemed to suite the ZTs handling characteristics and improved the ride on the oe fit tyres. All in all I'd fit them again on that car (now sold though), but wouldn't have them again on the Elise.
A further thought. Bear in mind that spring rates, dampers and bushing will have an effect on how different tyres work on the same type of car. A lot of Elises aren't standard (although mine is a standard S1).

redlake27

2,255 posts

275 months

Sunday 8th April 2007
quotequote all
I run my S1 on 195/50R15 and 225/45R16 Dunlop SP9000

They are not as track-focused as the Advans, but far more predicatable in wet and dry than the P Zeros.

I also found the slightly wide front than standard got rid of the irritating understeer that plagued the car originally.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Sunday 8th April 2007
quotequote all
Seen these recommended before. My local tyre place said the're a harder compound than BFGs and Toyos. Thought I'd take the recommendations I'd been given on trust but the rears are on back order with no dates,

MJK 24

5,680 posts

267 months

Sunday 8th April 2007
quotequote all
redlake27 said:
I run my S1 on 195/50R15 and 225/45R16 Dunlop SP9000

They are not as track-focused as the Advans, but far more predicatable in wet and dry than the P Zeros.

I also found the slightly wide front than standard got rid of the irritating understeer that plagued the car originally.


I run these on my S2 and agree with your thoughts. More people should give them a try. They're also very long lasting. Done 17k on mine and the rears are only about 40% worn, the fronts look like new.


redlake27

2,255 posts

275 months

Monday 9th April 2007
quotequote all
On the SP9000's, I have done 13000 miles, including three track events and they look less than 50% worn.

And still quicker than two S2s on Bridgestones and one Exige on Yokos at Donington on Friday...............

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Monday 9th April 2007
quotequote all
deep purple said:
Recently had fitted a pair of Toyo TI-R's to the rear of my S1, based on some good comments from the PH fraternity. Took it out yesterday on a good driving road in Norfolk with lots of flowing bends and it was wallowing around like a clapped out citroen.I have a feeling I know what the answer is cause I've only changed one thing very recently and I guess you guys will say 'told you so' - I still have the original pirelli's on the front!!! Taking it out again today just to make sure my mind isn't playing tricks, but will be careful. Looks like I might have to fork out for some new front Toyos, pirellis still have plenty of tread on them. Comments please guys, but be easy on me.



It took a fair few miles to run my rear T1R's in. The back end felt like is was floating for a while until they bedded in! Scared the hell out of me, but a few wheelspins sorted that out and all faith is restored. Do get the fronts done though. I managed to get my fronts for £35 each !! too cheap not to change .