Discussion
I've just got an S2 111S and I'm a bit concerned about the brakes. The pedal feel is nice and progressive up to what I would guess is about a third (in the dry) of full braking force but beyond that point there is simply no feel and the car seems VERY reluctant to slow down any faster. I think I could probably lock the wheels up but I haven't tried and I'm not at all certain.
I haven't taken the wheels off to look at the brakes so I don't know exactly what pads and disks are on the car. The rear pads seem to be lime green (greenstuff?); the front pads are black.
The overall braking performance is certainly nowhere near as confidence inspiring as the standard S1 I've driven before.
Any suggestions?
I haven't taken the wheels off to look at the brakes so I don't know exactly what pads and disks are on the car. The rear pads seem to be lime green (greenstuff?); the front pads are black.
The overall braking performance is certainly nowhere near as confidence inspiring as the standard S1 I've driven before.
Any suggestions?
Sounds like OEM fronts and Green stuff rears....odd.
You don't want to mix pads, different makes inevitably have different coefficients of friction and you upset the brake balance.
Mates car had problems with the rear brakes and sorting them made a huge differance so I'd say yes it could.
Swap the lot for Mintex I'd say.
You don't want to mix pads, different makes inevitably have different coefficients of friction and you upset the brake balance.
Mates car had problems with the rear brakes and sorting them made a huge differance so I'd say yes it could.
Swap the lot for Mintex I'd say.
Do the disks look warn? Is there a lip around the edge? Do you know when the brake fluid was last changed, any paper work detailing such in the history file? A fluid change can help a great deal.
Pads should be fine, Eliseparts offer good service, I got my 1144's from them, and they are excellent pads for the money....
Pads should be fine, Eliseparts offer good service, I got my 1144's from them, and they are excellent pads for the money....
kambites said:
Hmm, 100 quid plus VAT for the Mintex 1144s from Elise Parts... is that good? Will I need to replace the disks too or is it OK to just change pads?
Yes, Eliseparts are your best bet and very good.
No, you can just change pads and it's a dead easy job, took me just under an hour to do all of mine.
Davislove said:
its all about learning to live with them IMO, personally I like the feel, I wouldn't go anywhere near aftermarket pads, Lotus spent months and £££ developing a suitable compromise for road / track use
You clearly haven't tried Mintex or Pagids, they are much better than OEM.
And the OEMs aren't a Lotus specific anyway, they're a generic, sorry.
All IMHO etc
Davislove said:
its all about learning to live with them IMO, personally I like the feel, I wouldn't go anywhere near aftermarket pads, Lotus spent months and £££ developing a suitable compromise for road / track use
Not true. The OE pads are cheap off the shelf items not developed specifically for the elise. I have seen the same pads at a motor factor for £30 for the full set! Have you actually tried the aftermarket options? The OE ones are garbage by comparison, with very poor initial bite - and I have actually tried them back to back on both road and track. I would not use OE pads on track - they wear out far too fast (killed 1/2 worn pads down to metal in less than a day)
I would add that on performance versions of the exige - 240 cup etc, the pagid RS14 (what you refer to as aftermarket) is standard fitment.
Edited by shangani on Wednesday 11th April 17:39
Davislove said:
its all about learning to live with them IMO, personally I like the feel, I wouldn't go anywhere near aftermarket pads, Lotus spent months and £££ developing a suitable compromise for road / track use
Whether this is true or not, I have no complaints about the standard pads - at least on the S1 I drove. However my car brakes far less positively than an S1 on standard pads.
shangani said:
Davislove said:
its all about learning to live with them IMO, personally I like the feel, I wouldn't go anywhere near aftermarket pads, Lotus spent months and £££ developing a suitable compromise for road / track use
Not true. The OE pads are cheap off the shelf items not developed specifically for the elise. I have seen the same pads at a motor factor for £30 for the full set! Have you actually tried the aftermarket options? The OE ones are garbage by comparison, with very poor initial bite - and I have actually tried them back to back on both road and track. I would not use OE pads on track - they wear out far too fast (killed 1/2 worn pads down to metal in less than a day)
I would add that on performance versions of the exige - 240 cup etc, the pagid RS14 (what you refer to as aftermarket) is standard fitment.
Edited by shangani on Wednesday 11th April 17:39
have tried Mintex et al in previous cars for daily use and had bad experience (squelling, poor cold use, rapidly wearing discs), however, I expect Pagid are great for regular track use as you have described and the more track focussed models
personally i'm of the opinion that cars like the Elise are developed as a balanced 'package' by engineers, I see the amount of development work that goes into OE automotive components in my job and like my cars as the manufacturer intended
not trying to change anyones mind, just how I see it
Not denying the effort lotus put into ride / handling / chassis, but a heck of a lot of elise parts are the result of raiding other manufacturers parts bins. A pad that has worked well or badly on another car will not necessarily behave the same way on an elise. Try a car with mintex 1144's or better still pagid rs42's and you will not think your OE pads are particularly good thereafter.
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


