S1 v S2 build quality
S1 v S2 build quality
Author
Discussion

rob-ix

Original Poster:

27 posts

235 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
I had a slight hoon in a rover engined S2 over the weekend. I was utterly shocked at how different it was to my S1. The S1 seems much more solidly built than the S2, even though the S1 has done nearly 3x as many miles and is a good few years older.

Has anyone else noticed the difference in the build quality between the S1's and early S2's or am I perhaps comparing a rickety S2 with a solid S1?

bogie

17,109 posts

303 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
I think so...ive been in and driven a fair few Elises over 5 years and i can say every time I get in a bogg early S1 they feel like a kit car compared to a late S2 /111R ...of course that may float your boat either way...depends on what you prefer

bennno

15,329 posts

300 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
rob-ix said:
I had a slight hoon in a rover engined S2 over the weekend. I was utterly shocked at how different it was to my S1. The S1 seems much more solidly built than the S2, even though the S1 has done nearly 3x as many miles and is a good few years older.

Has anyone else noticed the difference in the build quality between the S1's and early S2's or am I perhaps comparing a rickety S2 with a solid S1?


I think i must have been in the opposite pair of cars, with a s2 which made a s1 seem exceptionally rickety

dont forget that the vx220 paycheck funded a massive amount of development which resulted in the S2 with a vast array of production improvements, even in terms of hood and panel moulding processes.

Bennno

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
Hard to say for me as I have only ever driven an S1, but you do tend to find that the first models of a niche company like Lotus, are over engineered. They have to be, as Lotus cannot afford a bad press or reputation with the birth of a new car.

Having said that, Lotus can only get real world feedback from the customers who drive the cars, the warranty claims etc, and then the idea is they improve what needs to be done immediately, and certainly with the replacement model.

Well, in theory at least. How Lotus ignored the red clutch hose syndrome as a recall is beyond me!

I have read from bodyshop experts that the S2 clams and fibreglass is much thinner and more flimsy, apparently.

Not that my S1 puts up a good fight against stone chips.

showcar56

11 posts

235 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
i've had thoughts on this for ages but hadn't spoken with anybody about it just incase i made myself look a bit of an arse.

Text drove a late S1 4 years ago, ended up buying a low mileage 51 plate 120 tourer. They felt the same, but as you say, the S1 more solid somehow, didn't make sense @ the time ? The S2 had rattles from , well, everywhere really....

Kept that for 15 moths then bought a spanking new 11S, what a difference, solid, nice panel gaps, quicker, no rattles @ all, almost like a car from a different maker ?

The after a year test drove a 111R, had to have it. Again the build quailty had gone up again, with the obvious changes in engine & alike, solid as a rock.

Bought the motorshow Exige S back end of last year, the rest is history..

All in all,improvements @ every step of the way, all positive, never had a single thing go wrong or let me down.
Marks out of 10 for being an arse please ?

rob-ix

Original Poster:

27 posts

235 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
I think as with most things the building process seems to have become more refined over the years. The S2 was an early model, so I doubt they had refined the production as much compared to a late model S1.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Given that they are hand-built the quality varies. I've seen many cars and owned 3 (2x S1, 1x S2) and the later ones are superbly put together compared to the earlier ones. And then you get in an Audi...

crackthatoff

3,314 posts

244 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
mine seems well solid (04 s2) the only noise or rattle comes from the windows when wound down into the door !

toxic frog

3,227 posts

298 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
guy i know who is quite high up with lotus advised me to buy the newest elise i could, as the quality has improved drastically from S1 to S2 and onwards from there... but whatever i did, do not buy an SVA Sport 160 (friday afternoon fun project with bits lying around the workshop)

i went out and bought a SVA Sport 160...

always been one to take advice me!

don't regret it for one second... although if i wanted a daily driver, my money would be going into a S2 111R every time.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
toxic frog said:
guy i know who is quite high up with lotus advised me to buy the newest elise i could, as the quality has improved drastically from S1 to S2 and onwards from there... but whatever i did, do not buy an SVA Sport 160 (friday afternoon fun project with bits lying around the workshop)

i went out and bought a SVA Sport 160...

always been one to take advice me!

don't regret it for one second... although if i wanted a daily driver, my money would be going into a S2 111R every time.



But that is the proper way to buy a Lotus, Tox! Mad and impulsive, not following the crowd. Good one thumbup

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Having been in a few S2's I must say that they are like Rolls Royces compared to my S1, which bangs rattles and squeeks everywhere.

clanger

1,087 posts

289 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
My S1 is equal to early S2's - later S2's build quality is def better - but pay the weight penalty - I'll take a late S1 anytime...