Cooper S to Elise... possibly
Cooper S to Elise... possibly
Author
Discussion

Iceman82

Original Poster:

1,311 posts

267 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Guys, I will keep it short and snappy. I bought a Cooper S but a few months ago, now it's a good fun car but it's not an elise. I have wanted one for ages and suddenly now, it looks like I can get one. I am going for a test drive on Saturday with Adrian Blyth and just need a little advice.

It's going to be an S2, so anything specific to look for. I have looked at the buyer's guides in the sticky post but anything beyond that? It's an 02 plate Sports Tourer, bog standard to my knowledge.

Am I making a massive error? Is it going to be too much jumping from a Cooper S to an Elise? Will I be dead within a week?

Is it true about the excellent fuel economy? My Cooper S drinks like an Irishman and I am not impressed by that at all!

Oh, and any notes about Adrian Blyth. To be honest he seemed like a top guy and really knew his stuff, so I am guessing he won't be doing a number on me!!

Many thanks

Jos

deepseatiger

543 posts

236 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Hi had three cars from him both Adrian and Peter excellent after sales service

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
I had a Cooper S as a courtesy car last year, loved the thing, great fun, and that supercharger whine is totally addictive isn't it?!

The Elise handling isn't half as twitchy as people make out......in the wet YES......but in the dry it's fine. I think you have to push very hard indeed to lose it in the dry. Get along to a www.carlimits.com day anyway, it's a kind of right of passage for any new Elise owner!

The buyers guide pretty much has it all. I've heard good things about Adrian Blyth, but from a main dealer like that you'll get some piece of mind, and I should imagine a decent warranty to look after things for a year. It will be quite a bit more expensive than a private car though. The biggest problem with getting an Elise is the terrible affliction of 'upgradeitus' which affects most owners very quickly. Get that chequebook ready....

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Big thumbs up for AB from me for aftersales.

Iceman82

Original Poster:

1,311 posts

267 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice guys and the solid recomendations for A.B. I have just read the thread from the chap asking about the number of crashed Elises, sound advice regarding the handling so I shall be very careful until I am feeling 100% sure in the car

jamiebae

6,245 posts

242 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
I went from a Mini One to an S1 Elise about 4 weeks ago, I've now done 2k miles in it, including a trip to St Tropez and around the South of France and through the Alps - and I'm still alive

The ride is equally dire in the Lotus as the Mini, the Elise will be noisier and less practical and obviously you don't get rear seats in the Lotus. I wanted an S2 but decided it wasn't a viable daily driver so went for a really tidy T plate S1 for fun, and a Clio 1.4 as a daily driver and effectively that's now my company car for long journeys and stuff.

Just do it, you only live once and there's no better feeling than driving along a fantastic road, aviators on, roof off and the sun shining

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Iceman82 said:
Thanks for the advice guys and the solid recomendations for A.B. I have just read the thread from the chap asking about the number of crashed Elises, sound advice regarding the handling so I shall be very careful until I am feeling 100% sure in the car

You'll be fine. AB are a nice bunch with good quality stock. They'll look after you I'm sure. If you get one, invest £170 in a carlimits day as posted above. You'll be amazed at how good the car is, and how much you have to learn thumbup

Then join SELOC too to meet other Lotus nerds in your area.

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Re fuel economy: it depends entirely on how you drive it (and the elise is not a car that really lends itself to being driven gently). I get ~45mpg out of mine (an S2 111S) when commuting because there's nowhere worth using more than about 1/4 throttle but if you start really pushing on that can drop into single figures.

L888DER

523 posts

243 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Both great cars and v differant. main diff that you will notice.......
Mini is wrong wheel drive - elise is correct wheel drive! i have had an elise and the missus has a cooper. so my opinion is from owning both cars!

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
I found the Cooper S quite twitchy (still loved it) To give a sporty feel, the hardened up the suspension wayyy too much. With the really stiff chassis, I found it was a bit random what direction you were facing when you left a pot hole. Great car though, I suggest you try an R or if the supercharger appeals and you have big balls the exige S.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
kambites said:
Re fuel economy: it depends entirely on how you drive it (and the elise is not a car that really lends itself to being driven gently). I get ~45mpg out of mine (an S2 111S) when commuting because there's nowhere worth using more than about 1/4 throttle but if you start really pushing on that can drop into single figures.


Single figures? I get 16-18mpg on track and couldn't imagine getting <10!

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
shangani said:
kambites said:
Re fuel economy: it depends entirely on how you drive it (and the elise is not a car that really lends itself to being driven gently). I get ~45mpg out of mine (an S2 111S) when commuting because there's nowhere worth using more than about 1/4 throttle but if you start really pushing on that can drop into single figures.


Single figures? I get 16-18mpg on track and couldn't imagine getting <10!



Agreed

jamiebae

6,245 posts

242 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Oh, on the subject of economy, I reckon the Elise is only marginally less economical than my Mini One was, the tanks are similar size and I get about 300 miles to a tank in the Lotus, I got about 330 in the Mini so I'd expect an Elise to be a lot better than the Cooper S

subaqua

892 posts

243 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Sub ten??? Given the size of the fuel tank, that would mean the thing running dry in around 70 miles. The worst I have had onn track in my R (I think its agreed the yota isn't as miserly as a K especially on the second cam) is low teens area.

(The average I got from my Maserati never budged from 14 unless I was caning it, when it got lots lots worse - so I'm pretty chuffed with that kind of consumption on track)


Edited by subaqua on Wednesday 18th April 09:50

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
OK, maybe single figures was a bit pessimistic. A lot less than 45 though.

stitch

933 posts

248 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Previously owned a Cooper S and now have an S2 as a weekend car.

Personally, I could not live with the Elise on a day to day basis, some of the things that make the car special are the same as those that would become niggles if having to deal with on a daily basis (chief amongst these being simply getting in and out without looking like a complete t*t).

In my opinion, the Elise is only a daily driver for the most committed (or is that those who should be committed?).

Sure people go on mammoth tours in them and my wife and I will be going to France in mine in June but this does not take away from the fact that doing the day to day things such as the weekly shop or going to the gym are a pain in the Elise.

Looking at the profiles of most of the people on here they seem to have access to another vehicle even if they use their Elise's a lot.

On the right day, on the right road the Elise is King - for the other 330 days in the year the Cooper S is the better car.

If you can live with it fine - if not follow the other contributor on here and get a tidy S1 and a small hatch.

In relation to fuel consumption - Cooper S mid 20's (could never get over 29) - Elise mid-30s. Other thing to consider is servicing - MINI's TLC package quickly lulls you into forgetting how much servicing actually costs

vx 220

47 posts

247 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Not quite an Elise, but i am driving a VX220. I came from a Cooper S Works. The fuel economy in the Mini was appauling. It would cost me near enough £40 to fill up and would only get 200 miles! That is a combination of driving.

I have the VX220 as an everday car and it isn't a problem.

Cheers
Chris

jtbush

629 posts

239 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
stitch said:
Previously owned a Cooper S and now have an S2 as a weekend car.

Personally, I could not live with the Elise on a day to day basis, some of the things that make the car special are the same as those that would become niggles if having to deal with on a daily basis (chief amongst these being simply getting in and out without looking like a complete t*t).

In my opinion, the Elise is only a daily driver for the most committed (or is that those who should be committed?).

Sure people go on mammoth tours in them and my wife and I will be going to France in mine in June but this does not take away from the fact that doing the day to day things such as the weekly shop or going to the gym are a pain in the Elise.

Looking at the profiles of most of the people on here they seem to have access to another vehicle even if they use their Elise's a lot.

On the right day, on the right road the Elise is King - for the other 330 days in the year the Cooper S is the better car.

If you can live with it fine - if not follow the other contributor on here and get a tidy S1 and a small hatch.

In relation to fuel consumption - Cooper S mid 20's (could never get over 29) - Elise mid-30s. Other thing to consider is servicing - MINI's TLC package quickly lulls you into forgetting how much servicing actually costs



I dont particularly agree with a word of this. I have gone from a very comfy Audi A3 Turbo Sport, into an Elise. I have left behind climate control, comfy seats, fantastic ICE, the turbo wooshy feeling, being able to lug loads around etc, into an S2 Elise, and havent looked back once. I use mine everyday for work, and actually look forward to the drive to and from work. We also have a Passat Tdi for shopping trips and lugging our friendly Dobermann around, but I resent driving it to the shops, taking the dog places, as I would much rather drive everywhere in the Lotus. If we didnt have a big dog, then the Mrs wouldnt need a big second car. If I was single, then I wouldnt think twice about having an Elise as my only car!

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Why is going to the gym a pain in the Elise?

rosso rebel

303 posts

285 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
I sold my Cooper S in February for a VX220T, and haven't looked back once!

On the practabiliy side as long as your main food shop is over the internet, you'll be fine!! I just find if there's two of us in the car I use the boot more.

Fuel economy on the VXT is better than my Cooper S, and Pied Piper also had a Cooper S and his S2 has better fuel economy.

Depending on the set up of the car you'll notice a difference on the comfort factor, and dependant on the exhaust a real difference on the noise factor!! but the VXT is, I think, set up softer than the Elise and I find it really comfortable (Driven it for 4000 miles in the last 7 weeks)

For me it was definately the right move - I haven't missed any of the creature comforts, but that said haven't had a prolonged winter yet, just a couple of snow flurries.