I hate convertibles!
Discussion
This might sound like I'm flaming, but before we start, I'm going to preface this by saying I absolutely LOVE my Elise and none of these comments are directed at the Elise/Exige specifically.
However, I HATE convertibles and I just can't understand why people are so attracted to the concept of open-top motoring.
I've owned the Elise for about nine months now and I've only driven roof-off on two or three days. I just can't see the appeal from:
(1) wind noise and buffeting at 90mph+ (My Sonny Burnett mullet probably has a lot to do with this!);
(2) dried-out (or at the other extreme, excessively watery) eyes from said buffeting;
(3) increased fuel consumption from greater drag (or reduced SC airflow with Exige S);
(4) exposure to airborne cr@p from the exhausts of trucks and other vehicles whose owners collectively need to purchase the developing world's share of carbon credits;
(5) looking like a c**k while driving roof-off through city en-route to B-roads (less a problem with Elise/Exige; certainly a problem with convertible BMWs/Porkers/Fezzas), and
(6) the "broken arrow" threat from low-flying pheasants and other airborne organic projectiles when you eventually reach those roads!
I bought a hardtop for the car back in November and it hasn't been removed since, and I can honestly say I have no regrets whatsoever. I also intend to leave it on on over summer.
HARDTOPS AND BERLINETTA'S ALL THE WAY I SAY!!!
However, I HATE convertibles and I just can't understand why people are so attracted to the concept of open-top motoring.
I've owned the Elise for about nine months now and I've only driven roof-off on two or three days. I just can't see the appeal from:
(1) wind noise and buffeting at 90mph+ (My Sonny Burnett mullet probably has a lot to do with this!);
(2) dried-out (or at the other extreme, excessively watery) eyes from said buffeting;
(3) increased fuel consumption from greater drag (or reduced SC airflow with Exige S);
(4) exposure to airborne cr@p from the exhausts of trucks and other vehicles whose owners collectively need to purchase the developing world's share of carbon credits;
(5) looking like a c**k while driving roof-off through city en-route to B-roads (less a problem with Elise/Exige; certainly a problem with convertible BMWs/Porkers/Fezzas), and
(6) the "broken arrow" threat from low-flying pheasants and other airborne organic projectiles when you eventually reach those roads!
I bought a hardtop for the car back in November and it hasn't been removed since, and I can honestly say I have no regrets whatsoever. I also intend to leave it on on over summer.
HARDTOPS AND BERLINETTA'S ALL THE WAY I SAY!!!

I put the hardtop back on when the proper hot weather arrives, and drive around with the windows down. It's a lot cooler, and I don't get frazzled. As the weather cools, the hardtop goes back into bubble-wrap, where it stays for the winter. The car is deafening with the roof on, but windows down it's not too bad......
kevin ritson said:
Fool
(1) Get a hair cut mullet boy
(2) Wear shades
(3) Windows open or roof off, so what, the aero isn't great anyway
(4) Air-vents chuck everything in regardless
(5) You may do, I don't
(6) Mmmmmm, rare meat
(1) Get a hair cut mullet boy
(2) Wear shades
(3) Windows open or roof off, so what, the aero isn't great anyway
(4) Air-vents chuck everything in regardless
(5) You may do, I don't
(6) Mmmmmm, rare meat

(1) Haircut will fix it for me, but what about remaining 99.9999% convertible owners?
(2) More like goggles, but I can't pull off the Tazio look!
(3) Aero better on most cars with roof - convertibles almost always create more drag than hardtop, unless you're in something like an F1 car, where the opening is the size of a sink!
(4) Heard you can block larger particulates with stockings over air vents
(5) Is that opinion or fact?
(6) Don't want salmonella thank you very much - will need to pack bbq in boot for next trip!

sequential said:
This might sound like I'm flaming, but before we start, I'm going to preface this by saying I absolutely LOVE my Elise and none of these comments are directed at the Elise/Exige specifically.
However, I HATE convertibles and I just can't understand why people are so attracted to the concept of open-top motoring.
I've owned the Elise for about nine months now and I've only driven roof-off on two or three days. I just can't see the appeal from:
(1) wind noise and buffeting at 90mph+ (My Sonny Burnett mullet probably has a lot to do with this!);
(2) dried-out (or at the other extreme, excessively watery) eyes from said buffeting;
(3) increased fuel consumption from greater drag (or reduced SC airflow with Exige S);
(4) exposure to airborne cr@p from the exhausts of trucks and other vehicles whose owners collectively need to purchase the developing world's share of carbon credits;
(5) looking like a c**k while driving roof-off through city en-route to B-roads (less a problem with Elise/Exige; certainly a problem with convertible BMWs/Porkers/Fezzas), and
(6) the "broken arrow" threat from low-flying pheasants and other airborne organic projectiles when you eventually reach those roads!
I bought a hardtop for the car back in November and it hasn't been removed since, and I can honestly say I have no regrets whatsoever. I also intend to leave it on on over summer.
HARDTOPS AND BERLINETTA'S ALL THE WAY I SAY!!!
However, I HATE convertibles and I just can't understand why people are so attracted to the concept of open-top motoring.
I've owned the Elise for about nine months now and I've only driven roof-off on two or three days. I just can't see the appeal from:
(1) wind noise and buffeting at 90mph+ (My Sonny Burnett mullet probably has a lot to do with this!);
(2) dried-out (or at the other extreme, excessively watery) eyes from said buffeting;
(3) increased fuel consumption from greater drag (or reduced SC airflow with Exige S);
(4) exposure to airborne cr@p from the exhausts of trucks and other vehicles whose owners collectively need to purchase the developing world's share of carbon credits;
(5) looking like a c**k while driving roof-off through city en-route to B-roads (less a problem with Elise/Exige; certainly a problem with convertible BMWs/Porkers/Fezzas), and
(6) the "broken arrow" threat from low-flying pheasants and other airborne organic projectiles when you eventually reach those roads!
I bought a hardtop for the car back in November and it hasn't been removed since, and I can honestly say I have no regrets whatsoever. I also intend to leave it on on over summer.
HARDTOPS AND BERLINETTA'S ALL THE WAY I SAY!!!

Oh dear....
(1) Makes me feel alive especially coupled with great tunes blasting out
(2) Having owned 5 convertibles, can honestly say have never suffered from this.
(3) Buy a diesel or a prius
(5) Speak for yourself!
(6) Whatever you do, be careful crossing the road or passing the baked bean tin mountain in the supermarket
Edited by andy g bmth on Tuesday 24th April 18:37
I agree about the convertible thing, I had a Triumph Spitfire at the age of 17 for 4 years and this got the convertible bug out of my system, never wanted another.
Bought the Elise because I loved the car, now I have it I take the roof off whenever possible, makes me feel more at one with the car (not meant to sound quite a poncey as it does), you get to hear the engine fully etc.
Bought the Elise because I loved the car, now I have it I take the roof off whenever possible, makes me feel more at one with the car (not meant to sound quite a poncey as it does), you get to hear the engine fully etc.
andy g bmth said:
Oh dear....
(1) Makes me feel alive especially coupled with great tunes blasting out
(2) Having owned 5 convertibles, can honestly say have never suffered from this.
(3) Buy a diesel or a prius
(5) Speak for yourself!
(6) Whatever you do, be careful crossing the road or passing the baked bean tin mountain in the supermarket
(1) Makes me feel alive especially coupled with great tunes blasting out
(2) Having owned 5 convertibles, can honestly say have never suffered from this.
(3) Buy a diesel or a prius
(5) Speak for yourself!
(6) Whatever you do, be careful crossing the road or passing the baked bean tin mountain in the supermarket
(1) But I have trouble hearing Englebert Humperdinck above 90 with roof-off
(2) Drive faster!
(3) Ahh, but only if a Prius would get me to 60 under 5
(5) Point taken - maybe this is related to Englebert's greatest hits in (1) above?

Humm... I don't have a preference in truth. Love the Elise with the Hardtop on and love it without. It's just great to have the choice
Sometimes the roof just has to be on because it's way too rough / grim / cold... and at other times it simply doesn't matter! Like when heading for Dartmoor under the stars after a tasty curry and a natter with like-minded souls
Sometimes the roof just has to be on because it's way too rough / grim / cold... and at other times it simply doesn't matter! Like when heading for Dartmoor under the stars after a tasty curry and a natter with like-minded souls
Janitor said:
Humm... I don't have a preference in truth. Love the Elise with the Hardtop on and love it without. It's just great to have the choice
Sometimes the roof just has to be on because it's way too rough / grim / cold... and at other times it simply doesn't matter! Like when heading for Dartmoor under the stars after a tasty curry and a natter with like-minded souls
Sometimes the roof just has to be on because it's way too rough / grim / cold... and at other times it simply doesn't matter! Like when heading for Dartmoor under the stars after a tasty curry and a natter with like-minded souls
Either thats a Tor or your head!
I've done the convertible thing for several years and decided against it this time. I really suffer with headaches from flashing sunlight when driving through country lanes which you don't get with a roof in place.
Also I am approaching an age where exposing yourself (steady!) in a convertible to all and sundry does make you a bit conspicuous. So for me, those days are gone for a few more years until I buy an a reworked e-type or a really nice old Merc SL when I can waft around in my retirement. Either than or a Zonda just to rekindle my youth!
Also I am approaching an age where exposing yourself (steady!) in a convertible to all and sundry does make you a bit conspicuous. So for me, those days are gone for a few more years until I buy an a reworked e-type or a really nice old Merc SL when I can waft around in my retirement. Either than or a Zonda just to rekindle my youth!
What a load of Cr*p!
Ive had a convertible in one shape or form for the last 19yrs, there is nothing better than fresh air motoring even in the winter.
Decent Sunglasses are a must (especially in the elise as no visors)but have never had a problem with dried up eyes, in fact I find my eyes dry up in airconditioned cars more.
There is nothing better than blatting down a country lane early on a summers evening with the sound of the exhaust ripping through the air
pah
Ive had a convertible in one shape or form for the last 19yrs, there is nothing better than fresh air motoring even in the winter.
Decent Sunglasses are a must (especially in the elise as no visors)but have never had a problem with dried up eyes, in fact I find my eyes dry up in airconditioned cars more.
There is nothing better than blatting down a country lane early on a summers evening with the sound of the exhaust ripping through the air
pah

siwil1 said:
Ive had a convertible in one shape or form for the last 19yrs, there is nothing better than fresh air motoring even in the winter.
Fresh air motoring? I think my definition of fresh air must be different from yours - there's nothing refreshing at all IMO about being blasted with exhaust fumes from vehicles requiring a tune. I prefer my fresh (or should I say, clean) air in other ways thanks.
siwil1 said:
Decent Sunglasses are a must (especially in the elise as no visors)but have never had a problem with dried up eyes, in fact I find my eyes dry up in airconditioned cars more.
Like I said before, drive faster!
siwil1 said:
There is nothing better than blatting down a country lane early on a summers evening with the sound of the exhaust ripping through the air 

I can see the appeal from this, especially through tunnels with a great sounding exhaust. However, I still don't think this outweighs the other negatives from open top motoring. But hey, whatever floats your boat!

sequential said:
siwil1 said:
Ive had a convertible in one shape or form for the last 19yrs, there is nothing better than fresh air motoring even in the winter.
Fresh air motoring? I think my definition of fresh air must be different from yours - there's nothing refreshing at all IMO about being blasted with exhaust fumes from vehicles requiring a tune. I prefer my fresh (or should I say, clean) air in other ways thanks.
siwil1 said:
Decent Sunglasses are a must (especially in the elise as no visors)but have never had a problem with dried up eyes, in fact I find my eyes dry up in airconditioned cars more.
Like I said before, drive faster!
siwil1 said:
There is nothing better than blatting down a country lane early on a summers evening with the sound of the exhaust ripping through the air 

I can see the appeal from this, especially through tunnels with a great sounding exhaust. However, I still don't think this outweighs the other negatives from open top motoring. But hey, whatever floats your boat!

Exactly whatever floats your boat ! I think you would be better posting this in the Pie and Piston where there is always a "why do soft top drivers have their roof up thread" You will get a lot of like minded people there!
I lived on the outskirts of london for many years before moving to Essex and still loved having the roof off, In fact often commuted roof off before red Ken wanted money to do so.
I dont get your comments re dry eyes drive faster Mr Plod has earnt well off of me over the years so I think I drive fast enough Thank you
Edited by siwil1 on Wednesday 25th April 10:43
twpbugger said:
Buy one of these then 

Good point, but it mainly comes down to usability - the Elise is more usable than the Exige IMO. I'm actually thinking of getting an Exige sometime down the line, but for the time being, I'm more than happy with the Elise - hardtop on of course! twpbugger said:
Why buy an elise if you are not gonna go topless!! part of the thrill i would have thought!!
I had no problem buying an Elise, despite it being a convertible, because the chassis doesn't need the roof - it's plenty stiff already. But think how much more stiff it could be with a permanent hardtop - you only need to look at the difference in chassis flex between an Alfa Spider and GTV, a Z4 Convertible and Coupe, etc, as examples.
The plain truth is that cars with roofs are stronger than cars without, and generally drive better.
If Lotus offered an Elise Berlinetta, I would definitely prefer that over the current design. But they don't, and the closest thing to an Elise B would be an Elise with hardtop, which is what I have.
What I can't understand is why people are willing to pay more for something that, in general, is heavier, slower, and more flexible.
Having said that, everyone is entitled to their opinion, and whatever floats their boat!

Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff






