S1 or S2?
Author
Discussion

ikemi

Original Poster:

8,613 posts

236 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
Afternoon PH'ers!

Ever since the Elise S1 was released I have always loved the design and light-weight performance the car offers, as well as the heritage behind the Lotus badge. However at the time I was still a student and had no money whatsoever!

A few years on and I've just changed jobs, the Elise is finally accessible! I've been searching around on the PH classfieds and found some nice examples of the S1, but the S2 is only a small increase for what is a newer car ... I need some help to decide, although ultimately I believe the insurance (21 years | 1 years NCB/experience) may decide for me.

So should I:

1) Purchase an Elise S1 ready for the summer and have an absolute blast
2) Wait a year and save for a S2?
3) If 1), should I wait until next year and get the S1 111S?

How reliable are the K-series engines? Is there anything specific on the Elises that I should look for when looking at second hand private sales?

Also, what is the average mpg/servicing costs? Just interested as this will be my everyday car.

Any information is much appreciated! Thanks! thumbup

cej

961 posts

253 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
I vote for option 1 .I like the S1 much better thumbup

With regards to servicing and mpg: only problem I've had so far with my S1 is a faulty clutch slave cylinder,which I replaced myself (cost around 50 GBP). All other costs so far have been regular service parts and me screwing up

I've not been able to get my 'liz below 40 mpg yet even with spirited driving

Mind you,I don't do trackdays Which would definately bring that number waaay down. My record so far is 51 mpg cool

It's great to have a blast and still get good mileage thumbup Best car I ever had. cloud9

Now go get one

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
Drive both and see what you prefer, running costs have a look at my profile. (Keep in mind mine needs servicing every 6k, while most are 9k).

fatboy111

308 posts

248 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
I had an S2; best car I've ever owned. Sold it, now just getting back into an Elise next week when I pick up my 111S S1! Can't wait; always wanted an original Elise and just love the shape. They are not as civilised ( I use to run the S2 as an everyday car no problem), but they do feel a little more raw, with a little more character(?): great for a weekend toy!

Yoy won't lose much on an S1 now, so have some fun this summer, see if you get on with it and if you feel like a change, or the necessity, get an S2 next year.

Good luck!

M11TEY

34 posts

245 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
S1.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
Hi. I suspect from your post that you're looking towards the top of the S1 market which will get you a car with FSH (preferably from a specialist) lots of other work done and maybe a few worthwhile add-ons. Most cars have some sort of stainless sports exhaust fitted and probably an induction kit as well. You may also find a car with S2 suspension upgrade (Bilsteins instead of the not so good original Konis).
An Elise takes miles well and I'd be inclined to look for an example that's had regular use rather than a garage queen (cars, like most machines, thrive on use). Up to about 60k is fine, beyond that start to look for a price allowance for the mileage.Look for brake disc changes and suspension work (ball joints go and steering racks can wear).
Buy on condition rather than year and see if you can get a local Lotus specialist to check the car over prior to purchase. AA etc are a waste of time when it comes to the Elise.
Just realised that I haven't answered your main question! As a very content S1 owner who bought his car to see how he'd get on with it prior to spending more, I'd naturally suggest get an S1 and see how it goes.
The biggest potential problem with the S1 (and K series engines S2s) is HGF. You'll see lots of mentions of it on the forums. Don't get too hung up on it. It may or may not happen, is fixable for about £700 and if you make sure you allow the engine to warm up properly before giving stick that'll help. On that note I'd keep £1k or so available for repairs that may (or may not) come along.
For the type of car that it is the Elise is very cheap to run. However to keep it handling etc as the makers intended then it'll cost more than the average hot hatch to run. You will however be getting a very special car and if you get an S1 then you get the purest distillation of the original concept.
Try a few and see how you get on. You pays your money.....
Happy Hunting.

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
TIPPER said:

The biggest potential problem with the S1 (and K series engines S2s) is HGF. You'll see lots of mentions of it on the forums. Don't get too hung up on it.



... just get an AA breakdown & parts/labour warrenty which pay for repairs (max claim £500 x 5 in a year). £65 although the car has to be under 10 years old and under 100k. Then you can forget about it

www.theaa.com/breakdownrepaircover/index.html

/pats AA warrenty

simon813

415 posts

236 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
I was in a similar position as you just over a year ago. I could afford a top end S1 or one of the older S2 models. I went for the S2 because, for me, the styling is much more pleasing to the eye. I have read a lot about the S2 being more user friendly as an everyday car, but I cannot speak from experience because I have never owned an S1.

As for servicing, touch wood, I have not had to spend anything in my 15 or so months of ownership apart from an 'A' service which was £130 at a specialist and a new set of front pads, £30 fitted. I am about to change the front tyres at a cost of around £75 each. I think you would struggle to find a similar performing car with such cheap running costs. On the subject of petrol, my tank holds about £29 worth and I get around 200 miles out of it. I'm not clever enough to work out an MPG figure from that!!

Si

david@mediacopy

173 posts

252 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
S1 more fun with sharper handling, S2 more refined & probably better built (paint issues aside). I've used both as everyday cars over about 45k miles each.

toxic frog

3,227 posts

298 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
if you are a bloke that likes other men's bottoms,,, buy an s2...

if you're not a chutney ferret who enjoys meandering along the marmite motorway, buy an S1...

quite simple really...

if you're a little on the 'bi' side, a S2 135R is probably the right solution.

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Saturday 28th April 2007
quotequote all
First of all, read the buyers guide sticky thread at the top of the forum. Second, familiarise yourself with all the variants. Third check insurance premiums with the specialist insurers (at your age, you're going to get ass-raped). IF you think it's worth it, then go start test driving cars to get a feel for what you prefer - they really are all very different, and you'll begin to know what a decent one *feels* like.

Forget the S1 vs. S2 bullshit bravado written above. Neither is *better* or *sharper*, I know I've had 3 of them in the last 4 years and driven even more. I'll bet you any amount of money that my S2 is more planted and better set-up than almost ANY S1 owned by anyone who's posted above that say to the contrary. The Elise is VERY sensitive to set-up - a well geo'd (geometry set-up... toe, camber, bump-steer) car will turn-in and handle sublimely. A badly set-up one will bite you hard if you don't know what you're doing.

Don't buy on a budget, and beware that you can, and will get big bills from time to time. So think about the possibility that it will cost you 2k a year (including insurance, excluding petrol). If it's not the right time for you yet (for whatever reason) walk away and wait a little time. The worst thing in the world would be to have a car you love, that you can't use.

If you do get one, get driver training as soon as possible, and plan on doing it regularly to hone your skills - the best upgrade money can buy thumbup


Edited by S works on Saturday 28th April 21:31

toxic frog

3,227 posts

298 months

Sunday 29th April 2007
quotequote all
S works said:
First of all, read the buyers guide sticky thread at the top of the forum. Second, familiarise yourself with all the variants. Third check insurance premiums with the specialist insurers (at your age, you're going to get ass-raped). IF you think it's worth it, then go start test driving cars to get a feel for what you prefer - they really are all very different, and you'll begin to know what a decent one *feels* like.

Forget the S1 vs. S2 bullshit bravado written above. Neither is *better* or *sharper*, I know I've had 3 of them in the last 4 years and driven even more. I'll bet you any amount of money that my S2 is more planted and better set-up than almost ANY S1 owned by anyone who's posted above that say to the contrary. The Elise is VERY sensitive to set-up - a well geo'd (geometry set-up... toe, camber, bump-steer) car will turn-in and handle sublimely. A badly set-up one will bite you hard if you don't know what you're doing.

Don't buy on a budget, and beware that you can, and will get big bills from time to time. So think about the possibility that it will cost you 2k a year (including insurance, excluding petrol). If it's not the right time for you yet (for whatever reason) walk away and wait a little time. The worst thing in the world would be to have a car you love, that you can't use.

If you do get one, get driver training as soon as possible, and plan on doing it regularly to hone your skills - the best upgrade money can buy thumbup


Edited by S works on Saturday 28th April 21:31


His S2 is more planted than others as there's approx 25 stone of tim freeman sat between the front and rear wheels, his lunch in a packing case on the passenger seat, plus the contents of his weekly shop to waitrose in the boot.

In all seriousness, I agree with what Tim says... they're all great and the S2 is indeed an excellent evolution of the original car... provided you are partial to a little bit of truncheon from time to time, an S2 would also make an excellent choice.

Good luck


Edited by toxic frog on Sunday 29th April 09:04

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Sunday 29th April 2007
quotequote all
Alex, please have a roflroflrofl on me...........

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Sunday 29th April 2007
quotequote all
I look forward to seeing you both at Bedford in August to see how "planted" those S160's are girls. hehe

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Sunday 29th April 2007
quotequote all

xxplod

2,269 posts

275 months

Sunday 29th April 2007
quotequote all
I've had an S1, an early S2 (which I guess is what you'd get if an S2 is just on budget) and a later S2 111S. The S2 111S was superb, and much better than the 2001/Y Racetech I had. Like a lot of any early Lotus models, it had a lot of little niggles.

Although these would probably be sorted by now, unless you can stretch to a 2002/3 S2 with good spec, pref a 111S, I'd recommend looking out for a gem of an S1, again a 111S if funds/insurance permitted.

As for servicing - really not an issue. Not sure where you are but Fibreglass Services in Sussex are superb value for servicing and franchised service agents too. As for mpg, you'd have to be on a track to see the wrong side of 30 mpg and 40 mpg is attainable with reasonable road driving.

ikemi

Original Poster:

8,613 posts

236 months

Monday 30th April 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for all the helpful information, although to be honest I was pretty much sold on the first reply! thumbup I've decided that I'll aim for a good example S1 and have already been looking around at the various specifications and prices to find what could be a good deal. This evening once I finished work I visited my local dealership and drooled over the range that they had to offer - Bad idea - Came away very tempted!

Anyway it seems that insurance will screw me for as much money as possible. So far Confused.com is throwing up TPFT quotes of £1200 and FC quotes of £2400! eek However MoneySupermarket.com retrieved a company called CSMA via London Victoria, which have quoted me FC £1600 - Sounds a little too good to be true?

I'm going to arrange a test drive very soon and will then begin looking on the PH classifieds in June/July. I'll let you know what happens and hopefully I can join some of you on these Lotus fish n' chip runs I've heard so much about!

Chr1sG

39 posts

235 months

Monday 30th April 2007
quotequote all
Agreed you should test drive them both.
I did and settled on an S1 simply because it felt right......... and it was a few grand cheaper!

Both will change your life for good though so be warned!!!!

earlyriser

592 posts

238 months

Monday 30th April 2007
quotequote all
I've sold mine now, but S1 every time. I get confused between the S2 and the Vauxhall VX thingy laugh

Pied Piper

1,388 posts

278 months

Tuesday 1st May 2007
quotequote all
earlyriser said:
I've sold mine now, but S1 every time. I get confused between the S2 and the Vauxhall VX thingy laugh


Says someone who purchased a TVR.