Tire question: Yokohama, Toyos or other alternatives?
Discussion
Having driven just about 12'000 miles, I've used up 1 pair of front 195x50x16 and 3 pairs of rear 225x45x17 Yokohama A048 LTS on my Lotus Exige S2.
Thing is, before the supercharger was fitted, my driving style permitted me to get around 3750-5000 miles of rear tires. Since the supercharger was fitted, it's now down to 2800 miles.
(no track days btw!)
Since both front and rears are down, I'm able to switch to other tires - but which ones?
Am looking at Toyo R888 which are a bit cheaper which I hear are just as good, but how long do they last? Heard the compound may be a bit softer which makes me assume they're likely to last even less? Is there anyone here that switched from A048s to R888 that can tell me if they're about equal or how much less they last?
Other alternatives would also be greatly appreciated - a fellow friend with an identical Exige had his run on A039 which are not quite as grippy, but still excellent tires that lasted for ages. Sadly, these tires aren't sold anymore?
Wouldn't mind giving up a bit of grip if it means I can get around 5000-6000 miles on them...
Cheers Phil
Thing is, before the supercharger was fitted, my driving style permitted me to get around 3750-5000 miles of rear tires. Since the supercharger was fitted, it's now down to 2800 miles.
(no track days btw!) Since both front and rears are down, I'm able to switch to other tires - but which ones?
Am looking at Toyo R888 which are a bit cheaper which I hear are just as good, but how long do they last? Heard the compound may be a bit softer which makes me assume they're likely to last even less? Is there anyone here that switched from A048s to R888 that can tell me if they're about equal or how much less they last?
Other alternatives would also be greatly appreciated - a fellow friend with an identical Exige had his run on A039 which are not quite as grippy, but still excellent tires that lasted for ages. Sadly, these tires aren't sold anymore?
Wouldn't mind giving up a bit of grip if it means I can get around 5000-6000 miles on them...
Cheers Phil
R888's are very similar to the 48's Phil. IIRC there are different compounds of 48 available, not sure about the 888's.
39's were even more expensive and had less tread depth (they were designed as racing wets AFAIK).
I have Toyo T1R's on my OZ's at the moment (same size profiles as yours) and they are OK as road tyres although you do loose some feel at the dead ahead, and the first 500 miles until they were scrubbed in were (to be frank) scary. As road tyres I find them fine, but on track they go off very quickly.
39's were even more expensive and had less tread depth (they were designed as racing wets AFAIK).
I have Toyo T1R's on my OZ's at the moment (same size profiles as yours) and they are OK as road tyres although you do loose some feel at the dead ahead, and the first 500 miles until they were scrubbed in were (to be frank) scary. As road tyres I find them fine, but on track they go off very quickly.
Edited to add: I think there are some Dunlops which Plans recommend as another alternative which I might try once the T1R's need replacing, unless that is Lotus/Yoko come out with a decent alternative.
The really annoying thing is that the Advan AD07's are available in the right sizes in Japan, but not in the UK or Europe (they aren't type approved or something).
The really annoying thing is that the Advan AD07's are available in the right sizes in Japan, but not in the UK or Europe (they aren't type approved or something).
Hi Phil,
I was am having a similar dilemma:
[url]www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&f=15&t=380062[/url]
S Works said:
R888's are very similar to the 48's Phil. IIRC there are different compounds of 48 available, not sure about the 888's.
39's were even more expensive and had less tread depth (they were designed as racing wets AFAIK).
I have Toyo T1R's on my OZ's at the moment (same size profiles as yours) and they are OK as road tyres although you do loose some feel at the dead ahead, and the first 500 miles until they were scrubbed in were (to be frank) scary. As road tyres I find them fine, but on track they go off very quickly.
39's were even more expensive and had less tread depth (they were designed as racing wets AFAIK).
I have Toyo T1R's on my OZ's at the moment (same size profiles as yours) and they are OK as road tyres although you do loose some feel at the dead ahead, and the first 500 miles until they were scrubbed in were (to be frank) scary. As road tyres I find them fine, but on track they go off very quickly.
Thanks Tim. About the A048 compounds - yep, M and MH if I'm not mistaken, but from what I was told by Yokohama, the LTS compound is already the hardest of the lot. Seems to me that on the roads I'm using my car, the LTS is a tad too soft. I'm willing to go for R888 since they're a bit cheaper, but IMO it'd only be worth it if they'd last around the same as the A048 LTS. Anything shorter and the price difference would be offset by the shorter lifespan, meaning I could save the hassle and stay with A048s.
I'll be sure to check out the T1R's though. Is the difference in grip between legal racing tires like the R888 and A048 and road tires as the T1R big? If yes, I guess I'm looking for that tyre in between... what about the Yokohama A032?
Cheers and thanks!
Joe - Exige S said:
Hi Phil,
I was am having a similar dilemma:
[url]www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&f=15&t=380062[/url]
Hi Joe!
Thanks for the link - seems some of my questions were answered by Bogie:
Bogie said:
dunno the details, but based on the last 2 sets, they feel the same, last the same and are £200 a set cheaper for me
Sadly, they aren't quite £200 cheaper overhere though... perhaps around £100 for front+rears and from what I hear, we only still have one compound. Something a tad harder would still be nice, but if nothing can be found, I guess it's going to be a full set of R888...
Cheers Phil
Edited by Phil-Ch on Monday 30th April 13:32
Didnt know theyd stopped making A039s!
If you can get hold of a set and live with the price they are a fantastic road tyre. Not sure how much tread they come with but didnt think it was any less than A048s. They are quieter and more comfortable and on the road i find the grip as good in the dry and a lot better in the wet. They dont aquaplane on the motorway any more than my other normal car on normal tyres. Not sure how long they last though, ive done maybe 8-10k road miles, and a couple of dry trackdays on a set and they are coming towards the end now.
HTH
Simon
If you can get hold of a set and live with the price they are a fantastic road tyre. Not sure how much tread they come with but didnt think it was any less than A048s. They are quieter and more comfortable and on the road i find the grip as good in the dry and a lot better in the wet. They dont aquaplane on the motorway any more than my other normal car on normal tyres. Not sure how long they last though, ive done maybe 8-10k road miles, and a couple of dry trackdays on a set and they are coming towards the end now.
HTH
Simon
Found this through Google - it's German, but should be easy enough to understand by looking at the graphs.
Semi-slick tires review:
Toyo R888 vs Yoko A048 vs Kumho Ecsta V70 vs Michelin Pilot Sport Cup vs Pirelli PZero Corsa
Page 1:
http://img152.imageshack.us/my.php?im
Page 2:
http://img152.imageshack.us/my.php?im
Page 3:
http://img152.imageshack.us/my.php?im
Cheers Phil
Semi-slick tires review:
Toyo R888 vs Yoko A048 vs Kumho Ecsta V70 vs Michelin Pilot Sport Cup vs Pirelli PZero Corsa
Page 1:
http://img152.imageshack.us/my.php?im
Page 2:
http://img152.imageshack.us/my.php?im
Page 3:
http://img152.imageshack.us/my.php?im
Cheers Phil
Sure those are good comparisons, but for a bigger, heavier car with much different capabilities. On the Elise platform the 888's and 48's have very similar characteristics. I find the 888's to have a slightly wider envelope of transition from grip-to-slip, which on track and road I prefer. They are also better (IMHO) on wet/damp tarmac than 48's.
Seems like the Kumho V70A tyre could be quite an interesting alternative, as it's even a lot cheaper than the R888 tyre from Toyo with possibly a similar or better grip. The only problem is, I fear, 195/50x16 is not available.
What other dimensions would fit onto a standard front Exige rim? 205/50x16 perhaps? And if I would go for a slightly wider tyre in the front, would I have to go for wider track tyres as well to balance it out?
Anyone have any experience?
Cheers Phil
What other dimensions would fit onto a standard front Exige rim? 205/50x16 perhaps? And if I would go for a slightly wider tyre in the front, would I have to go for wider track tyres as well to balance it out?
Anyone have any experience?
Cheers Phil
Esprit said:
If it was my train set I'd be putting some AD07s on... they're a better tyre than the T1-R I believe.
I'm caught in the trap - have T1-Rs on the back and some Goodyears on the front (not guilty yer 'onour!). Time to change, for lots of reasons apart from the obvious BUT rear T1Rs have lots of life left, need new front ones so either:
A. Go with T1Rs at front or
B. Chuck two rear tyres out and replace all with costly Advans.
(MY02 S2 111S - only on road, spirited but not mental, stnd suspension etc)
Would the difference be worth it / noticeable? (Have read similar stories of T1Rs and 'soft walls' etc elsewhere)
Put it this way... my 130bhp S1 on T1Ss (which are not meant to be as good as T1Rs) has been the fastest non-honda-engined Elise at pretty much every trackday I've ever driven at.
They're not a BAD tyre, I just feel if money's no object, they're not the best road/track compromise out there... the Toyo IS good VFM though, especially for you guys over there in the UK
They're not a BAD tyre, I just feel if money's no object, they're not the best road/track compromise out there... the Toyo IS good VFM though, especially for you guys over there in the UK
road/track on a westfield Ive driven with ao32s ao48s and 888s.. they are all there or there abouts..48s come in different compounds so obviously the supersofts will be grippier than the 888s but will wear out a lump quicker...
888s are the cheapest and seem to last better than 48s, I would say straight off the line the 48s heat up quicker. but overall im not sure they are worth the extra dosh.
mate of mine runs 888s on his 160 elise and he rates them and he goes well in it, and I know of a s/charged Atom just gone to 888s and he seems to be quicker than he was on the 48s..
888s are the cheapest and seem to last better than 48s, I would say straight off the line the 48s heat up quicker. but overall im not sure they are worth the extra dosh.
mate of mine runs 888s on his 160 elise and he rates them and he goes well in it, and I know of a s/charged Atom just gone to 888s and he seems to be quicker than he was on the 48s..
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


