Opinions on "Self service"
Opinions on "Self service"
Author
Discussion

TheYeti

Original Poster:

656 posts

247 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
Hey guys,

I am trying to keep cost down at the moment as I have just spent £450 on the S2 Suspension kit GB, I have a complete new set of tyres to replace (the fronts locking up and smoke everywhere coming up to a junction yesterday in blazing sunshine, even when not braking that hard kinda confirmed what Walshy said about my Pirellis.........they are shit!) and a service in about 2000 miles coming up, I was wondering what people thought on the owner doing the service on the car themselves? My Dad is a retired mechanic, I am relatively handy with a spanner and I have seen a number of posts on SELOC of how to do it and some good pics and write ups...........

But never anyones opinion on if its a good idea or not. Its a small service coming up on mine (so, just oil, filter, plugs and sundries I guess......), but it WILL mean I won't get a stamp in the book, which is a BIG downside when come to resale........

So, pros and cons please guys. I am going to be financially crippled with all the things coming up to pay for if I have to pay for a service myself, so if I can keep it cheap, I will. I want one more summer out of this car, with top notch suspension set up so I can enjoy it for what it is...............

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
1. Have you factored in the price of a GEO for the new suspension? If not, add another £150.

2. What service is it? If it's an A then I'd not worry too much, anything else and you'd be better off getting a specialist to do it. Fibreglass Services is probably cheapest, albeit a bit of a trek from you. You can download the service manual, and you can check off all the items on the check-sheet, but (IMvHO) there's no substitute for knowledge of the little foibles of these cars. You may miss something which could come back to haunt you if it's a B or a C.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
Also depends on which car you have, and therefore its market value.

Any Elise worth less than £10k will find it hard to re-coup the thousands you will pay in dealer servicing - at most this will knock £500 or so off the price.

BUT it may well make it more difficult to sell as buyers will, understandably, call the ads in your price range with a FSH first.

A good compromise I have used is to DIY, keep all receipts, but then have the car serviced by a dealer just before selling, and advertise that point - that you have taken extreme care but have now made sure a dealer gave the car a thorough once over before the sale.

Also had a mate who would never let anyone touch his car - not even when new and under warranty. He saved around £5000 on servicing, then paid £200 for a top dealer to inspect the car and write an extensive report.

He got above market value for his car and it sold within hours.

Likewise, if you have a FSH but are selling with a 'C' service due, you do come across as a bit sneaky, so in some cases even a FSH works against you!

Simply, I'd say the newer the car, the more a FSH makes sense. As the car gets older, the maths turn against you.

I would personally prefer to buy from an owner who changed the oil every 6 months and used Silkolene, than the owner who uses an independent dealer and gets Magnetec every 12.

But we are all different!

TheYeti

Original Poster:

656 posts

247 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
1. Have you factored in the price of a GEO for the new suspension? If not, add another £150.

2. What service is it? If it's an A then I'd not worry too much, anything else and you'd be better off getting a specialist to do it. Fibreglass Services is probably cheapest, albeit a bit of a trek from you. You can download the service manual, and you can check off all the items on the check-sheet, but (IMvHO) there's no substitute for knowledge of the little foibles of these cars. You may miss something which could come back to haunt you if it's a B or a C.


Yeah, factored in the geo......

The service is an A as far as I can tell. Need to check the book, but a B was done not that long back and the Cambelt was changed on a C when I bought the car, so guess a standard A is next.........but I do need to check. I have a specialist near here (Gerald Turner of Newmarket), but he INSISTS on taking the car to pieces and looking over it completely, and charged me over £300 just for that, which I just cant afford. I know "specialists" will do it cheaper than this, but I can't get near one really.........apart from a fairly hefty trek. The only alternative I have is to find a specialist near my Dad (120miles away) and leave it there with him, come back, then pick up from my Dads a few days later. Even factoring the petrol I would spend travelling there and back, its still going to be cheaper than £300!!!

Can you point me in the right direction of the service manual please? I have a pdf of something, but this is service notes from Lotus, and not the manual. I could be wrong though...........

TheYeti

Original Poster:

656 posts

247 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
jondude said:
Also depends on which car you have, and therefore its market value.

Any Elise worth less than £10k will find it hard to re-coup the thousands you will pay in dealer servicing - at most this will knock £500 or so off the price.

BUT it may well make it more difficult to sell as buyers will, understandably, call the ads in your price range with a FSH first.

A good compromise I have used is to DIY, keep all receipts, but then have the car serviced by a dealer just before selling, and advertise that point - that you have taken extreme care but have now made sure a dealer gave the car a thorough once over before the sale.

Also had a mate who would never let anyone touch his car - not even when new and under warranty. He saved around £5000 on servicing, then paid £200 for a top dealer to inspect the car and write an extensive report.

He got above market value for his car and it sold within hours.

Likewise, if you have a FSH but are selling with a 'C' service due, you do come across as a bit sneaky, so in some cases even a FSH works against you!

Simply, I'd say the newer the car, the more a FSH makes sense. As the car gets older, the maths turn against you.

I would personally prefer to buy from an owner who changed the oil every 6 months and used Silkolene, than the owner who uses an independent dealer and gets Magnetec every 12.

But we are all different!


This is kinda what I was thinking to be honest. Its a basic service and can be done fairly simply by myself and my Dad. I was going to keep ALL the reciepts (I do for everything else anyway) and make sure that whoever wanted to buy it (WHEN I come to sell it....) will see these and get it serviced properly by a specialist just before......my car is a 7 year old Millenium Edition S1 with FSH so far...............I don't want to break that, but will have to weigh up the options........

Cheers for the info and opinions guys. Much appreciated.......

stevie111s

123 posts

266 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
I like the DIY route and have done all the servicing on my last two Loti (S1 111S and S1 Sport 160). I think the fact that the service book is not stamped can be offset with well documented services, i.e. I treat each one as a project, keep all receipts and the service checklist (found in the easily available CD Service Manuals) together in a bundle for each service, then prospective buyer can review each service in detail.

There is very little the confident homer can't do and if you're willing to have a go you can save moned even on bigger items, for example, if you need a top/bottom ball joint (common failure) take the suspension arm out and take to dealer to have the ball joint replaced ... save £100 (ish) of labour (cost me £15). For wheel bearing failure (also quite common) remove hub similarly (cost me £30 + bearing, similar saving). For disks/pads, if disks are scored or rusted at the edges as often happens at the back, take them off and have them skimmed (not MMC's though) ... cost me £15 per axle!

Keeping all receipts proves the work has been done and demonstrates good maintenance. I have not found that this deters potential buyers. HTH

TheYeti

Original Poster:

656 posts

247 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
stevie111s said:
I like the DIY route and have done all the servicing on my last two Loti (S1 111S and S1 Sport 160). I think the fact that the service book is not stamped can be offset with well documented services, i.e. I treat each one as a project, keep all receipts and the service checklist (found in the easily available CD Service Manuals) together in a bundle for each service, then prospective buyer can review each service in detail.

There is very little the confident homer can't do and if you're willing to have a go you can save moned even on bigger items, for example, if you need a top/bottom ball joint (common failure) take the suspension arm out and take to dealer to have the ball joint replaced ... save £100 (ish) of labour (cost me £15). For wheel bearing failure (also quite common) remove hub similarly (cost me £30 + bearing, similar saving). For disks/pads, if disks are scored or rusted at the edges as often happens at the back, take them off and have them skimmed (not MMC's though) ... cost me £15 per axle!

Keeping all receipts proves the work has been done and demonstrates good maintenance. I have not found that this deters potential buyers. HTH



Great stuff Stevie! All good advice taken on board!

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
I have done all the work needed on mine for nearly 2 years now. Keep all reciepts of parts bought and everything that you do. Its easy for a buyer to see if the car is in good condition. Mines in better nick than its ever been. and saves you a stack !

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
Your gamble of course being that you're hoping that they will see it the same as you and be confident in your ability as an adequate spanner man... and not just some tight-arsed have-a-go-hero with a B&Q socket-set.

jtbush

629 posts

239 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
I do all my own servicing, but then I am a degree qualified engineer with a father who sprinted and hill climbed and a grand father who owned one of the biggest garages in manchester. Ive been working on cars from an early age so am confident enough. In all honesty, the elise is simple enough to work on if you have the right equipment. I have my own full length pit and workshop which makes things very simple.

To be honest, I would be tempted to go to a specialist to have work done. People like Jude Performance come highly recommended and are fairly cheap.

If you have the tools and the enthusiasm and a bit of knowledge, do it yourself. If not, I dont think the specialists charge too much!