a convert from the darkside.....?
a convert from the darkside.....?
Author
Discussion

histonpead

Original Poster:

86 posts

235 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
Hi guys/gals - I'm currently trying to make a decision on what to swap my boxster s for as I want something a little more raw/fun....So far ruled out TVR as I dont drive far enough to work so its like engine suicide...currently teatering between an exige, an M3 and and z m coupe.

Think the idea of an early exige S2 is winning at the moment (arranging a test drive for the weeked as driven the others already)seen a couple of trade sales on autotrader starting from £22k...is this right sort of money (know it depends on spec to a degree).

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
money sounds about right...as for car choice it really depends on what you want to do with it - if its pure road use and commuting etc then an M3 would be a lot of car for the dosh....but if you intend on doing trackdays etc then you cant beat an Elise/Exige derivative for all round capability combined with low running costs etc

histonpead

Original Poster:

86 posts

235 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
m3 is a lot of car for the dosh but the SMG version I took out just felt like it was driving itself and they're also not as bullet proof as people think...I like to feel like I'm doing something when I'm drivnig. To be honest want somehting to put a smile on my face that i can give a good thrashing as and when but obviously at all times obeying the speed limit ;-)

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Thursday 3rd May 2007
quotequote all
Having seen an S2 Exige on pistonheads at £19,995, I think 22k will find you a good one.

Janitor

2,372 posts

250 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
histonpead said:
m3 is a lot of car for the dosh but the SMG version I took out just felt like it was driving itself and they're also not as bullet proof as people think...I like to feel like I'm doing something when I'm drivnig. To be honest want somehting to put a smile on my face that i can give a good thrashing as and when but obviously at all times obeying the speed limit ;-)


wavey Welcome over Mr pead

Double-ding-a-ling to what you've written above - I had TT before the Elise... very well built car, classic design and very good in it's own right, BUT, towards the end of ownership I too began to feel like a passenger in my own car. Sure it got from A to B very nicely, quickly and in style, but there was just no real feeling of engagement

The Elise (or potentially in your case, Exige) feels very special every time. Had mine now for 15 months and each and every time I open the garage door, I smile a very big smile and a genuine sense of occasion is present... and that's way before even starting the thing!

Ok, perhaps in asking a Lotus forum for their opinion you will get a pretty clear cut reply, but if you go into it with eyes wide open regarding the lack of creature comforts, practicality and 'characteristics' that somehow endear themselves to you as 'unique qualities' and can live with all that, then there's little to touch it regarding involvement, heritage and overall reward thumbup

Spend some time in one and see if 'its for you'... it just doesn't work for some, but for others, it ruins every other car out there in it's bracket / class!!!


Oh and one last thing - that speed limit thing you referred to... you can get some great fulfilment from a Lotus well inside the National Speed Limit! yes Not many cars give you that


Enjoy looking!

driving

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
Two words you need to consider with the M3 or Z3M (which are a LOT of car for the money these days)...

VANOS

and

Warranty

If the latter isn't a part of the cars vocab then I'd seriously consider the decision carefully. If the VANOS goes I assume you've read into the potential bills to rectify it?

The Exige is a great buy for the money - light, nimble, will *feel* a lot more like a proper sportscar and plenty quick enough. There's loads of upgrades available once you get used to it and want to start tinkering. Get one with a nice sports exhaust and a decent "pack" (Touring and or Sports) and you'll have great fun.

The Lotus doesn't just buy you a car, it buys you a whole community, a great trackday club (www.lotus-on-track.com) and more smiles than you can possibly imagine.

P.S. don't be scared of a private purchase. Just get any prospective new toy checked over by a good independent Lotus specialist (loads about, check the Buyers Guide sticky or the SELOC TechWiki for info) and buy from an enthusiast.

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
If its raw fun you are after then the Exige will win hands down!
The others dont even come close for pure driving experience.

21TonyK

13,414 posts

240 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
Agree pretty much with everything so far.

I've just moved from an M3 to an S2 Exige and "borrowed" a Boxster S for a few months. If you are looking for "fun" the Exige wins hands down. Costs are also a lot less both in terms of maintenance, warranties, running costs etc.

The M3 is a great car but at circa £20K your probably looking outside of BMW AUC and therefore outside of warranty. Don't believe anyone who tells you a 3rd party warranty is just as good or that you can "buy" a warranty from BMW.

On the plus side the M3 is more comfortable and has toys like nav, elec everything etc. SMG is something you either love or hate. For fast road or track use its good, for round town its a bit of a pain. Its a hell of a good cruiser as well, eats miles very quickly on the motorway. Downside is maintenance, tyres, insurance etc and of course petrol.. I averaged 21.7mpg over 2 years!

The Boxster is far better on fuel but same issues with parts, tyres etc. Warranty from Porsche is far more flexible (and cheaper than BMW).

Having experienced all three cars I would go for the Exige if it is mainly for recreational driving and for the enjoyment of driving as opposed to getting from A to B.

histonpead

Original Poster:

86 posts

235 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
Thanks guys.

S Works I hear what your saying re the z m coupe - the vanos on E36 M3 engine used is a real issue - and in all honesty is what puts me off. The E46 M3 suffers its own issues too form what I gather but if the recalls have been done then there's not much else (commonly) to go wrong (apart from cluth/whole SMG failure on the SMG model). Its just come to light that if an E46 owner didnt have the engine re-call work done BMW will do it for even out of warranty!

Any way pro's and cons of all the above, but the exige is looking favourite. Its nice to find a forum of people who feel the urge to tell every newbie that they're asking the smae questions that have been asked 1000's of times. Will no doubt post after my test drive....if i can pull my self away from the car!!!


Edited by histonpead on Friday 4th May 08:25

histonpead

Original Poster:

86 posts

235 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
Sorry peeps dont know how to post links etc but saw this on autotrader/p/heads - the reg is SN04 BZP, does anyone know the car?

2004 04 Reg Lotus Exige 1.8 Performance PackManual, Coupe, Petrol, 12,000 miles, Black, 2 Owner(s), Outsatnding low mileage example with Full Lotus Service history and 6mths Lotus Warranty. Spec includes: PERFORMANCE PACK / SPORTS SEATS / 4 POINT HARNESSES / CARBON TRIM / CD RADIO / 190 BHP TOYOTA ENGINE / STAGE 2 LOTUS SPORTS EXHAUST / INDUCTION SYSTEM. Truly exhilarating to drive and exceptional value at this price!. Please click on the Dealers Website link to view more details and larger photos. £21,975. Tel: 01992 577288 or 07711 648867 Distance: 43 milesPrice: £21,975
Links:

Dealer's Website
www.fletchdale.co.uk/
Dealer's Location
Services:
Used vehicle sales
Links: Buyers Checklist | Insurance | Finance | Roadtests

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
Don't know it but it looks an OK deal. Sports pack is worth having BUT it doesn't mention Aircon which in that car you will want.

This is worth a look if you're down South... www.pistonheads.com/sales/162941.htm

mahju

407 posts

242 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
S works said:
Don't know it but it looks an OK deal. Sports pack is worth having BUT it doesn't mention Aircon which in that car you will want.

This is worth a look if you're down South... www.pistonheads.com/sales/162941.htm



Nice comment on that: " Sale due to wife! :-( "
rofl