PROBLEM NO. 147: NOISY CLUTCH
PROBLEM NO. 147: NOISY CLUTCH
Author
Discussion

rhy 11s

Original Poster:

78 posts

248 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
My Mk2 111S has recently developed a nasty sound which accoustically seems to come from the passenger-side, near the front of the car (almost like it's coming from the wheel), but is definitely connected to the clutch.

After accelerating, if I take my foot of the gas I hear a noise which I can only describe as like a knife blade being sharpened on a butcher's knife wheel!! My investigations have establised:

1) Noise goes once the engine has settled down to around 2500 revs.
2) Noise goes instantly if I press clutch pedal and disengage clutch.
3) Noise almost goes if I reapply gas - although it's obviously harder to hear the noise when I'm applying gas, I have noticed I can reduce or eliminate noise if I apply a small amount of gas.

It's a new noise which is why I'm concerned.

Any ideas as to what it might be and size of job to remedy?

Car has done 38,000 miles so I'd be really p'ssed off if it needs a new clutch!

Cheers!

rfoster

1,482 posts

285 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
I'd had to suggest that it's just a noisy gearbox - the lack of any soundproofing tends to make all noises amplified compared to a eurobox. And in the words of most Lotus Service centres, - They all do that sir! All 3 of my Elises have done this.

ROB1979

221 posts

236 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
Had my clutch replaced last month after it gave up completely. Had only covered 34,500 un tracked miles. When i asked the garage if this was normal they said they normally last till 40k but thats about it. I had it replaced but opted for the AP Racing one as it's far better for little extra cost!
Basically it's quite possible it could be the clutch at your sort of milage.

rhy 11s

Original Poster:

78 posts

248 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
Cheers Rob. How much did it cost to replace?

This is my second Elise and it's a new noise that I've never heard before on either car - which is is why I think something has changed with the car.

ROB1979

221 posts

236 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
I had it done at Sinclaires, don't know where you're based but in the Essex area they were by far the cheapest. I had quotes of over £1000 but in the end they did it for me (with uprated clutch and slave cylinder) for about £750 which was a good price for a good job. I still had a heart attack at the cost though as last time i owned a car that needed a clutch it cost me 200 quid!!

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
OP - as you're in Bucks call Steve Williams Lotus (www.swlotus.com) - I'm sure he'll give it a check-over for you and advise on the appropriate course of action. Very well respected independent specialist, and a racer in the LOTRDC this year!

Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
ROB1979 said:
I had it done at Sinclaires, don't know where you're based but in the Essex area they were by far the cheapest. I had quotes of over £1000 but in the end they did it for me (with uprated clutch and slave cylinder) for about £750 which was a good price for a good job. I still had a heart attack at the cost though as last time i owned a car that needed a clutch it cost me 200 quid!!


750 Quid to change a clutch?! Holy Crap! I'd better lay off the racing starts then!

ROB1979

221 posts

236 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
You're telling me. That's creamed my bank balance this month for sure! It's these little unexpected repairs (or should i say big unexpected repairs) that spoil the ownership for me.
Anyway it's up for sale now so someones gonna get a real bargin with all the work i've shelled out for recently!cry

siwil1

1,022 posts

262 months

Saturday 5th May 2007
quotequote all
ROB1979 said:
Had my clutch replaced last month after it gave up completely. Had only covered 34,500 un tracked miles. When i asked the garage if this was normal they said they normally last till 40k but thats about it. I had it replaced but opted for the AP Racing one as it's far better for little extra cost!
Basically it's quite possible it could be the clutch at your sort of milage.


Cheers Rob thats just the info I need rolleyes as my car has done 39600 I noticed this morning. I'm assuming its clam off that costs all the money.

ROB1979

221 posts

236 months

Saturday 5th May 2007
quotequote all
Sorry to be the bearer of bad tidings. You may get away with it for ages yet, i'm sure they're not all the same! To be fair most of the guys talking on hear seem to have a bottomless pit of money so i thought it was just me who thought the cost was high, i mean people are spending far more than that on just one suspension upgrade.

rhy 11s

Original Poster:

78 posts

248 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
Just out of curiosity then, at what mileage have people on here replaced clutches?