Coolant problem (again...)
Coolant problem (again...)
Author
Discussion

trondhb

Original Poster:

55 posts

262 months

Monday 7th May 2007
quotequote all
My temperature problem seems to have no end to it...

The car was at a workshop today and a pressure test showed quite a bit of air in the system. Got it out (they think) and refilled about 1 litre of coolant.

Time for a test drive. Everything seems fine for about 25-30 minutes when the temperature is stable at 86-87. But then the same symptoms as before shows up... First a few times up to 91-92, further up to 95, and in between returning to normal. After a few minutes it continues to rise to 95-98 and when it continues to rise instead of returning to normal I slow down. I can hear the fan kicking in at 103-104 but when it still doesn't go down I pull over and when I turn off the engine the display is blinking at 112-114.

Starts up slowly after some minutes. Temperature at 107 but goes quite quick down to normal when I start moving. Stays at 86-87 for about 15-20 minutes and then it starts to rise again. Parked up at home the display shows 97 after being 91 and 94 right before.

A quick review of what has been done;
- coolant replaced (last autumn)
- termostat replaced with a 82-degree one from EliseParts (last autumn)
- temp sensor replaced with one from EliseParts (last autumn)
- bleeding of the coolant system (today)

Strangely enough, the symptoms seems to be just about the same as they were in the first place...

Now what...?

Sometimes it can be kind of frustrating to be around 1100 kms away from the nearest workshop who knows anything about the car. Almost as I am considering to get an MX-5 instead...

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Monday 7th May 2007
quotequote all
I'm guessing the water pump is ok? Have you checked for signs of a HGF?

tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Monday 7th May 2007
quotequote all
HGF.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 7th May 2007
quotequote all
Is it loosing coolant or just getting hot?

porteouz

123 posts

235 months

Monday 7th May 2007
quotequote all
sounds like your losing coolent. id check that first, Bear in mind the elise coolent sits at minimum level, Dont fill it to the max line cuz when you go back to check it it will be at the min line. this is normal, just make sure it isnt going below the min line!

trondhb

Original Poster:

55 posts

262 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
Don't know about the water pump. How can I find out if it's OK or not ?

I have heard that if it is HGF it would be oil in the coolant and/or the other way around ? Some mention petrol smell as well. I haven't noticed any of this. What are the symptoms and how can the workshop find out whether it is or not ?

No loss of coolant that I know of. The level used to be at the minimum level, a bit higher after they refilled some coolant yesterday.


Edited by trondhb on Tuesday 8th May 06:38

AlexT

565 posts

267 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
Buy an MX5 : if you want to have many many miles of trouble free motoring.

AlexT

565 posts

267 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
P.S. Check for signs of HGF: mayo-like substance under oil cap, dipstick etc. Could be a dodgy temp sensor if you are lucky. I am in the same situation as you...about 800km from nearest workshop that deals with these cars.

wacattack

576 posts

256 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
I too have also been experiencing the same problem, but I am also losing coolant. I have checked for the mayo stuff under the cap and on the dipstick but there is nothing there. I need to get it checked by a pro i think

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
wacattack said:
I too have also been experiencing the same problem, but I am also losing coolant. I have checked for the mayo stuff under the cap and on the dipstick but there is nothing there. I need to get it checked by a pro i think

Then next step should be to check at the Rad end for leaks. You should be able to get the system pressure tested.

trondhb

Original Poster:

55 posts

262 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all

Thanks for the suggestions so far. Some replies on the last posts;

No mayo-like stuff neither under the oil cap or on the dipstick. The temp sensor was replaced last autumn with a new one from EliseParts so it should be OK (?)

No loosing coolant as I have noticed.

Don't know about any leaks around the radiator, but the system was pressure tested prior to bleeding the coolant 2 days ago.

The local car club got together this evening, a guy with a Triumph recognized the symptoms and thought it might be the water pump. Guess that would be simpler than HGF to fix so it might be the best thing to do next (?)

Is the water pump a standard part so I can get a new one where they service Rovers? How much time are we talking about to replace it?

CloverLoti

80 posts

238 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
Have you had a look at clicky?

trondhb

Original Poster:

55 posts

262 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
Yes, I have seen it. Is it much better than the original? I'm planning quite a long trip next thursday and I would have liked to have the car fixed by then. Will save almost a week if I can get a pump at a Rover place here instead of ordering online.

AlexT

565 posts

267 months

Wednesday 9th May 2007
quotequote all
If your coolant is gradually dropping then it is not normal. Indicates a leak; as Sworks suggested get pressure tested. Should remain at min mark when cold. I have had 2 replacement radiators so far.

Trondh: mmm I am not sure what else it could be, but excessive temps will cause permamanent damage as you might be aware so i wouldnt be driving it

trondhb

Original Poster:

55 posts

262 months

Wednesday 9th May 2007
quotequote all
OK. Guess they can do another pressure test although it was done before bleeding the system 3 days ago.

Have been advised to get a "hydrocarbon" test as well to check if there is any exhaust gases in the coolant which would indicate HGF. The cambelt should have been changed anyway, so I might have the water pump and maybe the temp sensor replaced at the same time.

I am not driving the car any longer than a few kilometres at a time at the moment, no temperature problems the first 25-30 minutes of driving.

wezzer-45's

187 posts

234 months

Wednesday 9th May 2007
quotequote all
Hi, I'm new to piston heads so be gentle. I've seen a few coolant problens on K series elises. Nearly always down to the head gasket or an air lock in the system. It's best to jack the front of the car up as high as possible, get the engine upto temp and open the rad bleed screw while holding at approx 2000 rpm untill all of the air is out. Its also important to bleed the engine via the 8mm bolt in the coolant pipe underneath the throttle intake pipe.
If the water pump was faulty you wouldn't get any coolant flow back to the header tank via the small hose at the top.
I've also seen head gasket failure without any of the usual signs. No oil in the water or vice versa. No HC's in the coolant (tested with a block tester) and no porrage in the oil filler cap. The only signs was the coolant level would rise to the top of the header tank when driven very hard. You could leave it idle for hours and appear normal. Once the engine was stripped you could see the head was very badly grooved from the head gasket rings and all 4 piston liners were sunk down below the top of the block.
Hope this helps.

trondhb

Original Poster:

55 posts

262 months

Thursday 10th May 2007
quotequote all
HGF it is...

Found some exhaust gases (hydrocarbons) in the expansion tank today. Don't know exactly how much work has to be done until they remove the head but at least a couple of days at the workshop was mentioned. They recommend to change the cam belt and tensioners (which I planned to do soon anyhow), water pump, oil and oil filter at the same time. At least afterwards everything should be OK i guess...

Actually my insurance deal has a clause that says that repairs that have to be done in case of a gearbox or engine crash are covered. At least that will be the result of this after some time so it might be worth to ask. The same deal that costed them about £9.000 for a clamshell repair, rental car etc. last autumn...

trondhb

Original Poster:

55 posts

262 months

Thursday 24th May 2007
quotequote all
Finally the car is ready after about a week at the workshop :-) This has been done to it: head skimming, new and better head gasket, new water pump, new cam belt and tensioners, new remote thermostat kit, new oil and oil filter, new spark plugs. Guess that should solve the problem...

Luckily for me my insurance deal covers everything except the remote thermostat kit and maybe the water pump. Will cost me in total around £450 at most, not much more that the planned cam belt change would cost. Guess the actual cost will be at least 3 times that.

Nice timing as the local sports car club goes for a 4-day trip this afternoon... :-) Hopefully everything is working perfectly now.

trondhb

Original Poster:

55 posts

262 months

Tuesday 29th May 2007
quotequote all
She works perfectly smile About 1300 kms on great roads in fantastic weather this weekend, no problems and the car is as good as new. The normal temperature with the remote thermostat is a couple of degrees lower than before, 84-86 and very stable.

The only noticeable temperature rise was to around 95 degrees after having driven up here. Quite normal I guess... wink The steepest road in Norway, 13 hairpin turns and 240 meters up in just 1.3 kms, twice as steep as the more famous Trollstigen. A spectacular experience and a fantastic view from the top.