please help: cant decide
please help: cant decide
Author
Discussion

carlpcross

Original Poster:

19 posts

234 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
hi guys, just about to enter the world of the elise, only cant decide which car to start with.
been to look at two today, both cars around 15.5k

car 1) type 23, 22,000 miles 53 plate (dealer with 12 month warranty)

car 2) 111s 03 plate similar milage.(private)

car will be a second car to my inpreza sti.

looking forward to all of your opinions

carlos...

rfoster

1,482 posts

285 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
Which one do you prefer?

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
Look at the differences and decide:

Type 23
Dealer so have some comeback
Warranty
Limited edition can push up price at a dealer even though it isn't much more than a paintjob

111 - VVC engine, more power and good day-to-day choice
Private - no comeback/warranty so may want to factor in cost of inspection/Hpi/Warranty
If it checks out OK, probably better in the long term

StuartB

339 posts

266 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
So its engine vs. paint scheme?

Personally I'd get the Type 23 on the basis it is the best looking paint scheme Lotus have used on the Elise, you can always spend a few hundred quid with DVAPower and get similar performance.

Thing is, inside the car where you spend the time is the important bit - which drive did you prefer?

carlpcross

Original Poster:

19 posts

234 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
after driving both, cant really tell any difference in power/handle

i would of thought that both cars would depreciate similar.

might have to toss a coin

carlos..

StuartB

339 posts

266 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
kevin ritson said:
Limited edition can push up price at a dealer even though it isn't much more than a paintjob

And embroidery on the seats!

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
Re: the engine comments. If you couldn't tell the difference then perhaps it's a T23 with the 111S engine option?

carlpcross

Original Poster:

19 posts

234 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
dont think so, dealer said it was the 120bhp engine.
the 111s had all the gadgets, aircon, e/windows ect so would add weight to the car, maybe thats why?

carlos..

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
StuartB said:
kevin ritson said:
Limited edition can push up price at a dealer even though it isn't much more than a paintjob

And embroidery on the seats!


Wooo! hehe

VVC is mated to a wide ratio gearbox so won't feel massively different around town but pulls 500rpm less on the motorway which makes a fair bit of difference plus the top end is better

You'll know if it's got a VVC by checking the diffuser - one part=120bhp two part=VVC

lawrence5

1,254 posts

266 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
111s

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
carlpcross said:
dont think so, dealer said it was the 120bhp engine.
the 111s had all the gadgets, aircon, e/windows ect so would add weight to the car, maybe thats why?

carlos..

Fair enough. As Kevin notes there's a closer ratio 'box on the standard engines S2's which will get it up to motorway speeds quicker but as he also notes, the 111S is a better bet over that.

I'd go for the private 111S, get it checked out by a specialists and then get the AA breakdown cover with Parts & Labour warranty.

kambites

71,729 posts

252 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
Well I would say 111S but then mine has just started making a rather disturbing noise...

carlpcross

Original Poster:

19 posts

234 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
is the vvc engine any more or less reliable than the non vvc one??

carlos

tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
About the same i beleive regarding HGF . Why dont you add 3k more and get the R , you'll regret not doing so otherwise .

mahju

407 posts

242 months

Wednesday 16th May 2007
quotequote all
carlpcross said:
is the vvc engine any more or less reliable than the non vvc one??

carlos


The vvc has the variable value timing trickery, which shouldn't be a problem really, unless you're very unlucky, or me... (i.e. had a variator broken for number 3&4 pistons...

But the extra torque, power and fuel econ make up for it

carlpcross

Original Poster:

19 posts

234 months

Wednesday 16th May 2007
quotequote all
thanks guys,still cant decide , swaying towards the type23,
do you guys think 15.5k is a fair price for a 53 plate with 22k miles

carlos..

StuartB

339 posts

266 months

Wednesday 16th May 2007
quotequote all
carlpcross said:

do you guys think 15.5k is a fair price

Its an asking price - its worth what you are willing to pay for it.

Everybody will have an opinion mine is that you are probably paying £1500 for the limited edition paint scheme *if* you buy it at their marked up price

Cars priced well like this
www.pistonheads.com/sales/165861.htm
might help you gain some perspective

carlpcross

Original Poster:

19 posts

234 months

Wednesday 16th May 2007
quotequote all
looked at that one, but bcause the car had a cat d insurance claim put me off/

carlos...

Stevie P

270 posts

314 months

Wednesday 16th May 2007
quotequote all
Why not buy the 111S and get it striped? Must be cheaper than engine upgrades for the Type 23...

Steve