Anyone gone from Boxster S to Elise?
Anyone gone from Boxster S to Elise?
Author
Discussion

twcullen

Original Poster:

238 posts

236 months

Thursday 24th May 2007
quotequote all
Thinking about changing my Boxster (my every day car) for an Elise, either an S1 160bhp, S2 111s or S2 111R. Anyone else done this? good idea or a complete mistake? I tend to drive mainly A & B roads 10k miles per year. When I was in my early 20's I had a Westfield as my daily drive. Now I am in my mid 30's with a dog and a girlfriend who like to go places at the weekend the Box is great at this. I realise luggage space would be lacking but could I make one of these cars a serious daily and weekend driver? Any thoughts would be great!



21TonyK

13,413 posts

240 months

Thursday 24th May 2007
quotequote all
twcullen said:
Thinking about changing my Boxster (my every day car) for an Elise, either an S1 160bhp, S2 111s or S2 111R. Anyone else done this? good idea or a complete mistake? I tend to drive mainly A & B roads 10k miles per year. When I was in my early 20's I had a Westfield as my daily drive. Now I am in my mid 30's with a dog and a girlfriend who like to go places at the weekend the Box is great at this. I realise luggage space would be lacking but could I make one of these cars a serious daily and weekend driver? Any thoughts would be great!
Not made the transition as such but drove a Boxster S for some time and recently moved to an Exige via an M3 cab.

If you hanker after the civility of a S then I'd suggest some serious thought and a few test drives first. If you are looking for an outright driving car then no hesitation. I've only experienced S2 S and R's. If moving from an Boxster S you'll miss the torque and I think you'll find an S lacking in terms of performance so I'd be looking at an R.

But, really, get some test drives in. It's a totally different car to Boxster, absolutely no comparison. Although in real terms it's not an R will make the Porker feel loose and wobbly. Just be aware you can tweak the brakes on the Elise and PASM "does not exist" wink

Lawrence5

1,254 posts

266 months

Thursday 24th May 2007
quotequote all
If you can drive a westie daily then you certainly can put up with an elise. As said go testdrive one.......

Chr1sG

39 posts

235 months

Thursday 24th May 2007
quotequote all
Absolutely, compared to a West you'll be surrounded by luxury!!!

I have an S1 as my only car and its been very good to me so far.

21TonyK

13,413 posts

240 months

Thursday 24th May 2007
quotequote all
/Note the OP/

When I was in my early twenties I had sensible cars and silly women. Now in my thirties I have silly cars and sensible women.

Somewhere on the middle I had Porsches, semi-sensible women and an semi-sensible cars.

EOP




mahju

407 posts

242 months

Thursday 24th May 2007
quotequote all
twcullen said:
Now I am in my mid 30's with a dog and a girlfriend who like to go places at the weekend the Box is great at this.
You'll fit the girlfriend fine... but if the dog's a Great Dane you might have a problem!

kambites

71,724 posts

252 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
If you hanker after the civility of a S then I'd suggest some serious thought and a few test drives first. If you are looking for an outright driving car then no hesitation. I've only experienced S2 S and R's. If moving from an Boxster S you'll miss the torque and I think you'll find an S lacking in terms of performance so I'd be looking at an R.
I'm not actually sure that an S2 111S is any slower than a Boxster-S until you get well above the legal limit. The raw figures suggest that it's much the same to 60 and it certainly feels as quick (although you do have to work it harder).

You'll struggle to get your girlfriend and a dog in at the same time (unless she has no legs or it's one of them little rat-dog things that can sit on her knee) but I would have thought that would be a problem in the Boxster too?

One word of warning though, my girlfriend can't stand going in my Elise, I have no idea why (and she swears it's not because of my driving).


Edited by kambites on Friday 25th May 08:13

tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all
Thats funny i was contemplating changing to a Porsche for a while later this year .

L888DER

523 posts

243 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all
OK. I went from elise to exige to boxster. It really depends on what you want from the car. in my opinion the only simularity is that they are both two seaters.

Elise is raw and a pleasure to drive - boxster is better for everyday but boring.

Shnozz

30,694 posts

302 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all
The Elise is great but I couldn't be doing with one every day (albeit the S2 is slightly more civilised). If I was restricted to 1 car I'd be looking at a Boxster/350Z. Luckily I have several cars so it means when I really want to drive rather than just travel, I can get the Elise out.

Jonblue

107 posts

241 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all
I think the lack of boot space may be an issue for you if you like going places. If you want to drive with the top down (and you will), you have to put the roof in the back, which means you'll be lucky to travel with more than one soft bag between you.

If it's going to be your only car, this might be an issue. Having said all that, I'd have an Elise over Boxter any day.

mahju

407 posts

242 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all
Jonblue said:
I think the lack of boot space may be an issue for you if you like going places. If you want to drive with the top down (and you will), you have to put the roof in the back, which means you'll be lucky to travel with more than one soft bag between you.

If it's going to be your only car, this might be an issue. Having said all that, I'd have an Elise over Boxter any day.
In a S2 you can get the top behind the seat smile

Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all
I went From 2003 Boxster S back to Elise 111S

The Elise is so much better than the Boxster. Yeah, the Boxster is more practical but I wanted a proper sportscar, one that drives properly and doesn't cost the earth to run like the Porsche. I had BIG problems with the Porsche (needed a new gearbox at 30k miles that resulted in a court case which is still not resolved over 1 year later). Plus the usual RMS failiures etc.

I'm so much happier in my Lotus than I ever was in the Boxster. Boxster is fine if you like to think you can drive because you can drive it fast very easily. It's like being in a big saloon car that just happens to go fast. But dynamically it's compromised, I found it boring to drive after a while. Plus everyone hate you if you drive a porsche, and you get everyone telling you "it's not even a proper porsche!".

Elise runs rings round it on the road. Get one.

Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all
Oh, and I use mine every day too. Get a S2 111S and you'll have "creature comforts" of extra soundproofing (still loud) and Leccy windows! Plus you'll get over 40 mpg. My Boxster could manage about 19!

Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all


I'm not actually sure that an S2 111S is any slower than a Boxster-S until you get well above the legal limit. The raw figures suggest that it's much the same to 60 and it certainly feels as quick (although you do have to work it harder).


[/quote]

My 111S is Definately faster to 60 than My Boxster was! After that the boxsters power will take over but it's a much heavier car than the lotus and it really makes a difference when setting off/changing direction.

fatboy111

308 posts

248 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all


[/quote]

My 111S is Definately faster to 60 than My Boxster was! After that the boxsters power will take over but it's a much heavier car than the lotus and it really makes a difference when setting off/changing direction.
[/quote]

Your Elise would be even faster if you stopped eating so much cheese cake...
yum

Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all
Cheesecake? I would do if you hadn't eat it all before I got there fatboy!

twcullen

Original Poster:

238 posts

236 months

Friday 25th May 2007
quotequote all
I agree Box is a bit boring to drive after a while, maybe it's just a bit too German and it does cost a fair bit to look after properly. My other half has a Clio 182 so I do have use of another, more practical car just feel a bit like a boy racer in it!!

Thanks for all the advise guys!!