Should one buy an Elise s2 111r or a VX220 Turbo?
Should one buy an Elise s2 111r or a VX220 Turbo?
Author
Discussion

chicosgroove

Original Poster:

30 posts

255 months

Tuesday 29th May 2007
quotequote all
Hi Guys and gals,
the dilemna I have is choosing with a second generation elise 111r or a vx220 turbo?

Im just starting my research so Im not massively knowledgable on either car right now but Ive narrowed my choice down to these two babies right now.

I know the 111r was a sort of response to the brute of the turbo version of the VX. Which has more punch, which is the better drive?

All thoughts and comments appreciated!!!

Many thanks

C

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 29th May 2007
quotequote all
It's a very contentious issue this, dealt with on many previous threads. Please do use the search facility and have a good hunt around.

For Lotus buying info read this thread which we all keep topped up with lots of info http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

As this is a Lotus forum, most of us prefer the Lotus.

Both are sound sportscars, each with it's pro's and con's. Ultimately you should drive both, and make your mind up as to which you prefer.

JTBUSH

629 posts

239 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
I drove both, much prefered the Vauxhall, but bought a Lotus. Figure that one out!

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
You really should test drive both. People behave like f*cking schoolkids on this forum whenever this question comes up, and lots of toys are slung out of prams. However, I would say that both are cracking cars, and you won't go wrong with either. For sheer value for money the VX is hard to beat.

edp190

336 posts

240 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
I wouldnt buy either! I'd get an exige! wink But seriously, if i had to choose i'd get a 111r and stick on exige rims(48s) and suspension. I didnt get on very well with the VXT but they are fecking quick in a straight line. HTH cheers Ed

L888DER

523 posts

243 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
A turbo or a badge what is more important ?

Phil-CH

1,132 posts

295 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
Depends on what you prefer: The Speedster Turbo offers to much of tuning potential for little money, it really isn't funny and makes it a killer car for good value.

On the other hand, the Lotus is a little more focused, even if it doesn't match up to the Speedster in terms of power. There are tuning options available that will make it more than quick enough if more grunt is wanted.

Drive both and make up your mind.

Personally, I'm not too much of a fan of turbos. They feel f*cking quick, but I'd prefer a supercharger or NA power delivery on this type of car. To each their own though.

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
Out of interest, is the geometry of the suspension mount points the same in the VX220 as the Elise? If so, couldn't you get much of the Elise's sharpness back by fitting Elise suspension and steering components to a VX220T (yes I know they're different weights but not by THAT much)? I'd guessing that'd be significantly cheaper than getting an Elise up to VX220T power.


shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
kambites said:
Out of interest, is the geometry of the suspension mount points the same in the VX220 as the Elise? If so, couldn't you get much of the Elise's sharpness back by fitting Elise suspension and steering components to a VX220T (yes I know they're different weights but not by THAT much)? I'd guessing that'd be significantly cheaper than getting an Elise up to VX220T power.
On the strength of the LoT race series so far, there doesn't seem to be a lot that can be done to make a VX handle like a properly sorted elise. Even a 320 bhp VX on its best lap hasn't matched elises with almost 100 bhp less, let alone the VX vs 300 bhp elises / exiges.

Engine weight + clam weight are two basics that are difficult to work around - they will always be heavier than the elises and this does impact performance even if everything else is sorted.

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
shangani said:
On the strength of the LoT race series so far, there doesn't seem to be a lot that can be done to make a VX handle like a properly sorted elise. Even a 320 bhp VX on its best lap hasn't matched elises with almost 100 bhp less, let alone the VX vs 300 bhp elises / exiges.

Engine weight + clam weight are two basics that are difficult to work around - they will always be heavier than the elises and this does impact performance even if everything else is sorted.
Fair enough. I didn't realise the clams were heavier too.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
A VX220 rear clam weighs as much as an entire elise body including doors. The manufacturing process is different iirc and the sharp angles necessitate much thicker fibreglass reinforcing, all adding to extra weight.

I sould add that the elise S2 body is actually fairly light (slightly lighter than the S1)

Edited by shangani on Wednesday 30th May 13:16

crackthatoff

3,314 posts

244 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
L888DER said:
A turbo or a badge what is more important ?
badge thumbup

Alex_S

75 posts

249 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
crackthatoff said:
L888DER said:
A turbo or a badge what is more important ?
badge thumbup
I did see a VX220T once where the owner had removed the griffin badges and replaced them with lotus ones! Problem solved! wink

chicosgroove

Original Poster:

30 posts

255 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
Many thanks everyone,
I apologise for asking a question that appears to have already done the rounds.

A test drive on both sounds the way forward although the weight issue discussed is an interesting one!

C

Jay Dee

75 posts

250 months

bjc388

459 posts

255 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
It's a very contentious issue this, dealt with on many previous threads. Please do use the search facility and have a good hunt around.

For Lotus buying info read this thread which we all keep topped up with lots of info http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

As this is a Lotus forum, most of us prefer the Lotus.

Both are sound sportscars, each with it's pro's and con's. Ultimately you should drive both, and make your mind up as to which you prefer.
Great measured and diplomatic response - nice one Tim yes

mahju

407 posts

242 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
Jay Dee said:
I watch that before getting my lotus, and helped focus my mind.... a little... but in summary, badge! (111s badge that is)