Our baby is fooked!!!
Our baby is fooked!!!
Author
Discussion

lotustuart

Original Poster:

1,465 posts

262 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
(X posted from Seloc)

Our 2002 S2 135 ST has issues! I over heated back on the way to the first LOT trophyday at Brands and have had issues ever since! On that day the AA came out and diagnosed a faulty coolant tank cap so it was replaced and we thought nothing more of it. then the coolant temp started becoming erratic and we has air in the system. I bled it a few times thinking that when the AA filled it up he caused an air lock. After a few bleeds we were stil getting air in the system and then I over heated on the way back from work. I had a hydrocarbon test done the next day by the AA and it shower up positive so we assumed HGF! I trailered it down to Miles at FGS yesterday and today I phoned him and he seems to think its not the head gasket but short of another £500 diagnostic work, thinks putting the new reinforced gasket on is worth a try! So thats where I`m at at the moment. Now for the advice bit.....

He said that if this does not cure it them I`d have to get the head crack and pourus(sp) tested which will cost lots of £££, if it is cracked or pourus then I need a new head! Ouch! he estimates somewhere in the region of £1500 for a new head, so if that is the problem what are my options??

New head £1500

New 2nd hand engine £800ish plus fitting (what will that cost?)

Or upgrade, I cannot afford honda etc so don`t even suggest it so I`ve looked at PTP or DVA. DVA want me to supply the head i think so thats out but PTP appear to supply the head included in their RS170 packages at either £1600 without Emerald or £2400 with, what difference will ECU make??

Any advice or suggestions welcomed as I am currently clueless!!!

TIA

deepseatiger

543 posts

236 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
when mine went on my old 160 had it all done £1900 by Tom new bishops watham including new pots etc tec cam belt

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
Bad luck chap. Not under warranty then?
I couldnt spend that sort of cash & i personally would count my losses & move on.

lotustuart

Original Poster:

1,465 posts

262 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
boobles said:
Bad luck chap. Not under warranty then?
I couldnt spend that sort of cash & i personally would count my losses & move on.
Ehh???

Its a £12000 car!

Are you saying you wouldn`t spend £2k repairing a £12k car? or am I missing something?

fatwomble

1,389 posts

245 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all



Stuart, really sorry to hear of your problems, hope you can get it sorted without completely breaking the bank.

deepseatiger said:
when mine went on my old 160 had it all done £1900 by Tom new bishops watham including new pots etc tec cam belt
Where does Tom work now, I lost track of him after he stopped working for Tony Pond.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
PTP vulcan head with valves and gaskets, headbolts etc is £995 ex vat.

http://www.ptp-ltd.co.uk/Special%20offers.aspx

Get liner heights checked, when the head is off. You could do it DIY. With oil and cambelt - £1400 all in or about 6 hous labour. Reuse existing cams etc and you will still get more power. Decent cams on a vulcan head should get you 160-170 bhp on a std throttle body.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
Alternatively you could give Rog at Sabreheads a call (he posts as Kiwirog on Seloc). He might have something as might the South West Lotus Centre - 01566 784152 (though they would probably rather sell you a vulcan head).
Must say that Shangani's solution looks good.

Jez49

234 posts

242 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
That Sucks!

Whatever happens get the block deck checked as they can warp as well as the head on the k-series, if you decided to go the DIY route because of budget or whatever, give me a shout and I'll give you a hand if you need it.

Jez

M7RT V

428 posts

289 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
I'll give you a hand too mate smile Can't have that car off the road for too long!

deepseatiger

543 posts

236 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
fatwomble said:
Stuart, really sorry to hear of your problems, hope you can get it sorted without completely breaking the bank.

deepseatiger said:
when mine went on my old 160 had it all done £1900 by Tom new bishops watham including new pots etc tec cam belt
Where does Tom work now, I lost track of him after he stopped working for Tony Pond.
sorry to hijack for a minute hes working at his own workshop now on hoe road where his dad has the oil place hes doing really well its callec New techniques its called he does most of the other hill climbers stuff so thats a good recce also does a lot of rally cars for the National boys ,Hes got a number this year in the Hill racing

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
hey Stuart.

Sorry to hear the bad news. I too have a coolant issue. The temperature is all over the place, if I give it some beans, the coolant boiling and comes out of the tank going all over the engine. I thought the cap might have had it as I could hear it bubbling when I turn the car off. Bought a new cap, it didnt help. I think the acutal tank is to blame so I bought a new one off ebay for £10, so going to fit that when it arrives.

I dont have any head gasket tell tale signs like the white stuff in the cap or anything. Its getting though a fair bit of water though, most of it is going all over my engine bay.

Wonder if we have the same issue?

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
Oh man...

Sorry to hear the news. If you wanted to do a "DIY" then I will be there.

I have done 2 metro HGF (if that is any help)

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
piooly said:
hey Stuart.

Sorry to hear the bad news. I too have a coolant issue. The temperature is all over the place, if I give it some beans, the coolant boiling and comes out of the tank going all over the engine. I thought the cap might have had it as I could hear it bubbling when I turn the car off. Bought a new cap, it didnt help. I think the acutal tank is to blame so I bought a new one off ebay for £10, so going to fit that when it arrives.

I dont have any head gasket tell tale signs like the white stuff in the cap or anything. Its getting though a fair bit of water though, most of it is going all over my engine bay.

Wonder if we have the same issue?
You have exhaust gases entering the coolant system under load. Almost certainly means HGF or low liner height.

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
lotustuart said:
boobles said:
Bad luck chap. Not under warranty then?
I couldnt spend that sort of cash & i personally would count my losses & move on.
Ehh???

Its a £12000 car!

Are you saying you wouldn`t spend £2k repairing a £12k car? or am I missing something?
I wouldnt spend that sort of cash im affraid. What i meant by warranty was an AA type thing or something simular.

lotustuart

Original Poster:

1,465 posts

262 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
boobles said:
lotustuart said:
boobles said:
Bad luck chap. Not under warranty then?
I couldnt spend that sort of cash & i personally would count my losses & move on.
Ehh???

Its a £12000 car!

Are you saying you wouldn`t spend £2k repairing a £12k car? or am I missing something?
I wouldnt spend that sort of cash im affraid. What i meant by warranty was an AA type thing or something simular.
Yes it`s being repaired at the moment under AA warranty but only £475 after xs. I only hope that if this doesn`t fix it then I can claim again if needed. You get 5 a year but for the same(ish) problem I`m not sure.

You wouldn`t spend that sort of cash on a £12k car! You clearly have much more money than me!!biggrin

lotustuart

Original Poster:

1,465 posts

262 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
piooly said:
hey Stuart.

Sorry to hear the bad news. I too have a coolant issue. The temperature is all over the place, if I give it some beans, the coolant boiling and comes out of the tank going all over the engine. I thought the cap might have had it as I could hear it bubbling when I turn the car off. Bought a new cap, it didnt help. I think the acutal tank is to blame so I bought a new one off ebay for £10, so going to fit that when it arrives.

I dont have any head gasket tell tale signs like the white stuff in the cap or anything. Its getting though a fair bit of water though, most of it is going all over my engine bay.

Wonder if we have the same issue?
I had no signs of HGF, no oil in H2O no mayo in oil, nothing! They were the first things I checked! Sounds like you have similar issue to me. Mine was boiling up under load (which is most of the time when I was driving!!) and when on long journeys. The coolant tank bubbles away like a witches couldren. Sorry mate but I think you should get someone to have a look at it!frown




Goobs, Jez, Mart and anyone else that offered, THANKS. Its nice to know your out there! I`ll keep you all informed!

JTBUSH

629 posts

239 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
Depends what engine you want, but Im sure there is a 35k 120bhp engine for sale on here, or maybe on SELOC for about £375. If your short of cash, could be worth getting that, sticking it in then saving up for something a bit better. Just to get the car back on the road. Could take yours out, stick that one in, and then rebuild yours over time so your not taking a massive hit on expensive engine rebuild all in one month.

When finished, take this one out, stick yours in, and sell the one youve taken out.

Thats what Id do. In fact, if I was a bit more financially fluid this year, I wouldve already bought that engine for a spare.

Shnozz

30,693 posts

302 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
lotustuart said:
boobles said:
lotustuart said:
boobles said:
Bad luck chap. Not under warranty then?
I couldnt spend that sort of cash & i personally would count my losses & move on.
Ehh???

Its a £12000 car!

Are you saying you wouldn`t spend £2k repairing a £12k car? or am I missing something?
I wouldnt spend that sort of cash im affraid. What i meant by warranty was an AA type thing or something simular.
Yes it`s being repaired at the moment under AA warranty but only £475 after xs. I only hope that if this doesn`t fix it then I can claim again if needed. You get 5 a year but for the same(ish) problem I`m not sure.

You wouldn`t spend that sort of cash on a £12k car! You clearly have much more money than me!!biggrin
hehe Looking back on my first 18 months of ownership and it cost £7k, and I only did about 3000 miles in that time!

Stuart, hope you find a cheap fix and sorry to hear of your woes. Whilst its never good news, I guess its times like this that we can be thankful the K series are peanuts compared to the lion's share of performance car engines.

JTBUSH

629 posts

239 months

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
Stu, if it were me I'd ring round all the usual suspects (DVA, KiwiRog etc.) and weigh up all the options before making any hasty decisions. You're clearly going to have to invest a couple of grand, so best make sure that it gives you the biggest bang for your buck