Buying a Lotus not a Rover
Discussion
Get:
An Elise S - 134 bhp toyota engine
Elise R 189 bhp toyota engine (formally known as 111r)
Exige S2 189 bhp toyota engine
Exige S 220 bhp supercharged toyota engine
Alternatively a car that has had an engine conversion to audi or honda power - faster than just about any factory car.
Then at least you will have a proton with a toyota engine.
An Elise S - 134 bhp toyota engine
Elise R 189 bhp toyota engine (formally known as 111r)
Exige S2 189 bhp toyota engine
Exige S 220 bhp supercharged toyota engine
Alternatively a car that has had an engine conversion to audi or honda power - faster than just about any factory car.
Then at least you will have a proton with a toyota engine.

Edited by shangani on Friday 1st June 11:44
I believe some of the later S2 Elise's incorporate the Toyota VVT-i engine and gearbox, thus Japanese reliability. Although whilst I was researching into purchasing a Rover engined S1, lots of people mentioned the head gasket failures are overhyped and do not occur that often ... I love my Elise - The engine has fantastic power delivery and the exhaust note is perfect 

R5Gttgaz said:
Could you get a non-rover Elise for 10-11k?
Not unless it had been recently wrapped around a tree.My ealier post about mirrors was a bit flippant - but as Kam says, there are bound to be rover bits and pieces in there somewhere, just as there are vauxhall indicator stalks, citroen wiper motors etc.
Essentially, if the well documented (but from what i hear, far from terminal) HGF issues are the problem, then you have a choce of toyota models from the factory, or aftermarket conversions. But if its about pace, there's barely any difference in speed between a standard 120bhp K and a 111R at road legal speeds.
Choice is all yours
Edited by subaqua on Friday 1st June 11:59
Don't knock the K-series in the earlier Elise. Provided its warmed up correctly (a good ten minutes after coolant reaches temp to allow oil to also warm up) they are very reliable. I had my first Elise (k-series) for 18 months and no problems. Simple engine to work on as well apparently. Yes- love the 'yota engine in my Exige but dont discount Rover engine cars.
Tanman
Tanman
I wouldn't have thought that buying any car with no Rover components was too much a of a problem. I would think that Rover contracted out the manufacture of virtually every component to smaller Engineering and manufacturing companies - just like Lotus do - and probably the same companys.
You could perhaps try for a Perodura or Kia. I wouldn't imagine much overlap of manufacturers there.......
You could perhaps try for a Perodura or Kia. I wouldn't imagine much overlap of manufacturers there.......
jb111s said:
What a stupid post.
Don't think I'll buy one of those lamborghini's, they've got audi bits in them, and you can forget those ferarri's, they're fiats really....
I'm not being rude but I also wouldn't buy another Rover engined Elise. I had an S1 it was nothing but trouble Head Gasket etc, if Lotus hadn't moved to Toyota then I wouldn't own one. The Rover engine is basically a bored out Metro engine not a good place to start in my view, I thought this is why most people who blow up Rover engine's move to either Honda or Audi they don't buy another RoverDon't think I'll buy one of those lamborghini's, they've got audi bits in them, and you can forget those ferarri's, they're fiats really....
Boggy
bananamana said:
Hi guys,
Im getting closer to getting this Elise, however, I am buying a Lotus and not a Rover. I want an Elise that has absolutly no Rover components in it at all! I couldnt live with myself if it had.
Thanks
Seems to be a bit of an extreme statement.Im getting closer to getting this Elise, however, I am buying a Lotus and not a Rover. I want an Elise that has absolutly no Rover components in it at all! I couldnt live with myself if it had.
Thanks
What are your reasons for hating Rover so much?
Badge snob? Ex-employee?
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff






