'Tis the season...
Author
Discussion

Gooby

Original Poster:

9,269 posts

265 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
... for HGF.

Why?

Every year at this time we get a flood of HGF's, it seems more so than any other time. Any ideas?

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
People getting their cars out for summer?

toxic frog

3,227 posts

298 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
the ambient outside temperature does seem to make a difference... during the winter when sat in traffic, the frog's temp reading would usually stay fairly static... during the summer, it rockets up into the low 90's when the fan kicks in... this surely must have some long-term effect on the head gasket?

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
The thing that annoys me is the fact that its a car! Its going to be in situations where as people get stuck in traffic or did Lotus not consider this in the design concept? Bloody poor engineering on there behalf if you ask me! madconfused

Gooby

Original Poster:

9,269 posts

265 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
Paul RN said:
People getting their cars out for summer?
Piooly, Shangani and Lotustuart use thier car all year round.

Talkwrench

910 posts

264 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
It is a design fault - on three counts.
Firstly, the thermostat is in the wrong place for the cooling system layout, particularly on the Elise (and, incidentally, the MGF!). When the thermostat opens, the engine suffers a sudden rush of very cool water into the head and puts the top of the engine through a rather severe temperature cycle. This causes contraction and expansion that often results in HGF.
Secondly, the locating of the head on the block was a poor design. Nylon dowels will never provide a sufficiently rigid location for a light alloy head going through continual temperature cycles and a block twisting under fairly high torque loads.
Thirdly, the original gasket design didn't leave much margin for error - and unfortunately, errors are exactly what it has to endure!
The good news is that all are relatively cheap to fix. A well designed pressure relief thermostat in the outflow from the head will provide a far kinder cooling environment for the engine, steel dowels keep the head in place, and double sided head gaskets provide a far more resilient and flexible seal.

Edited by Talkwrench on Sunday 10th June 13:28


Edited by Talkwrench on Sunday 10th June 13:44

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
It does seem that there are seasonal variations. In the winter, a lot of radiators seem to go - perhaps the extremes of water tem contribute to splits in the plastic endcaps of the radiator.

Summer - I am not sure why - the thermal shock is probably worse in winter. Mine has been a bit suspicious since January, but under road driving is absolutely fine. It only had problems on track under high load. Still, a few hundred quid to fix at the same time that I need a C service means that the experience will only cost a couple of hundred quid more than I would have paid for the c service. That is if I wasn't having other stuff done....

The engines are otherwise pretty robust. If the PRT has been designed ito the system and rover had sorted liner heights from the factory, HGF would be almost unheard of in the K. In fact it would be seen as a light and fairly "bulletproof" engine.

Similarly, if the yota had a better oil pump, it would probably also not have experienced the failures it has. I would choose a £700 HGF over a £7K new engine every time considering the abuse mine gets on track. It has been buzzed to 9K and was fine appart from the gearbox shrapnel. (not me driving BTW) Cost £70 for me to buy and fit a 2nd hand gearbox with less mileage than my old one.

Gooby

Original Poster:

9,269 posts

265 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
Talkwrench said:
It is a design fault - on three counts.
Firstly, the thermostat is in the wrong place for the cooling system layout, particularly on the Elise (and, incidentally, the MGF!). When the thermostat opens, the engine suffers a sudden rush of very cool water into the head and puts the top of the engine through a rather severe temperature cycle. This causes contraction and expansion that often results in HGF.
Secondly, the locating of the head on the block was a poor design. Nylon dowels will never provide a sufficiently rigid location for a light alloy head going through continual temperature cycles and a block twisting under fairly high torque loads.
Thirdly, the original gasket design didn't leave much margin for error - and unfortunately, errors are exactly what it has to endure!
The good news is that all are relatively cheap to fix. A well designed pressure relief thermostat in the outflow from the head will provide a far kinder cooling environment for the engine, steel dowels keep the head in place, and double sided head gaskets provide a far more resilient and flexible seal.

Edited by Talkwrench on Sunday 10th June 13:28


Edited by Talkwrench on Sunday 10th June 13:44
We all know about the fundamental design faults. That doesnt tell why they tend to go at the beginning of summer / end of spring. 3-4 well used cars that are driven hard and well maintained, they are driven all through the year, all go in the same week. We had the same sort of thing last year.

Why

What has happened in the last week or so to make gaskets leak? If it was thermal shock then this would be more pronounced in winter / spring, if it was height of temp then it would be August.....

Stato

37 posts

250 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
Gooby said:
Paul RN said:
People getting their cars out for summer?
Piooly, Shangani and Lotustuart use thier car all year round.
Me too and mine went last month frown

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
Stato said:
Gooby said:
Paul RN said:
People getting their cars out for summer?
Piooly, Shangani and Lotustuart use thier car all year round.
Me too and mine went last month frown
Me to & mine had early symptoms so no hesitation in getting it repaired. Hopefully get mine back Tues or Wed

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
Gooby said:
What has happened in the last week or so to make gaskets leak? If it was thermal shock then this would be more pronounced in winter / spring, if it was height of temp then it would be August.....
I am not sure that it is all in the same week. Stu blew the radiator tank cap off back in March - that suggests the problem was already there back then. Piooly sounds like his problems have aso been ongoing. FWIW I knew mine was gone more than a month ago.

Mine was causing problems as far back as January, but I couldn't prove HGF (still can't), but its obvious that it is.

I suppose now that the weather is better, people are driving the cars harder and the symptoms are manifesting, whereas tiptoeing about in the wet / cold, there was less likelihood of pressurised gases entering the cooling system - something that usually happens at high rpm / load.

Because the process of developing HGF is a gradual one, it could manifest at any time. Theoretically it would seem nore likely that the process happens more rapidly during the winter months, but perhaps it is the hard driving on track etc which is bringing to light the effects of a process that has been ongoing for months.



Edited by shangani on Sunday 10th June 17:38

Heesen

97 posts

243 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
yep my rad went last week. Hopefully caught it in time to save it from HGF. Going in next week for new upgraded rad and upgraded fan.

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
Well my car is all fixed now. Managed to complete the whole job in 3 evenings work, 14 hours in total which isnt bad for my first ever attempt. I reckon I do it in half the time now I know what I'm doing. My temper was tested many times when I couldnt get enough access to certain bolts etc. I changed the thermostat too for a 82 degree one instead of the standard 87. The car now runs at a rock steady 80 degrees although I am taking it easy at the moment.

Are there any rules on running in? Stuart was told 300 miles at no more than 2500 rpm. Does this need to be done? I've been driving mine around all weekend and not gone over 3000 rpm, but driving a lump sport 160 at under 3000rpm is challenge in its own right !!!!

lotustuart

1,465 posts

262 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
piooly said:
Well my car is all fixed now. Managed to complete the whole job in 3 evenings work, 14 hours in total which isnt bad for my first ever attempt. I reckon I do it in half the time now I know what I'm doing. My temper was tested many times when I couldnt get enough access to certain bolts etc. I changed the thermostat too for a 82 degree one instead of the standard 87. The car now runs at a rock steady 80 degrees although I am taking it easy at the moment.

Are there any rules on running in? Stuart was told 300 miles at no more than 2500 rpm. Does this need to be done? I've been driving mine around all weekend and not gone over 3000 rpm, but driving a lump sport 160 at under 3000rpm is challenge in its own right !!!!
Miles only told us to do that because it was a new type of composite gasket from landrover and that was the instructions on the packet!! I would suggest you take it realativley easy for a few miles though! But you are right its fecking hard!!

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
Oh dear - I am going to Cadwell park the day after I get my car back. At least it is a 200 mile trip. That will have to be enough.

Talkwrench

910 posts

264 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
Gooby said:
Talkwrench said:
It is a design fault - on three counts.
And everything else what I said......
We all know about the fundamental design faults. That doesnt tell why they tend to go at the beginning of summer / end of spring. 3-4 well used cars that are driven hard and well maintained, they are driven all through the year, all go in the same week. We had the same sort of thing last year.

Why

What has happened in the last week or so to make gaskets leak? If it was thermal shock then this would be more pronounced in winter / spring, if it was height of temp then it would be August.....
My apologies. I didn't realise everybody knew. I wonder why more people don't fit the PRT uprade to stop it happening then?

My guess is that it happens as soon as the sun is out, the roads are dry and every Elise owner stops being sensibly cautious on slippery roads!

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
Talkwrench said:
I wonder why more people don't fit the PRT uprade to stop it happening then?
Most of us did not own the cars from new. The process starts as soon as the car is first used. Installing a PRT on a new engine is the best bet.

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
What is PRT & how does it perevent HGF & how much does it cost?

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
boobles said:
What is PRT & how does it perevent HGF & how much does it cost?
I wouldn't say it prevents, theres cases over on SELOC with PRTS fitted and they have still got HGFs. Its a Pressure Relief Thermostat (also known as the PRT).

http://wiki.seloc.org/a/Pressure_Relief_Remote_The...


Talkwrench

910 posts

264 months

Sunday 10th June 2007
quotequote all
Though not necessarily preventing HGF if the damage is already done, it can certainly ease the stress on the gasket and may well prevent the failure if no damage is present.
More relevant is the fitment of a PRT kit during/after head gasket replacement to try and make sure it doesnt happen again!

Edited by Talkwrench on Sunday 10th June 22:39