Repaired cat d insurance claim
Repaired cat d insurance claim
Author
Discussion

deep purple

Original Poster:

35 posts

236 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
Would you touch one of these if was at the right price?

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
Yes (I nearly did buy one) as long as (1) I was planning to keep the car for a long time and (2) I could get a detailed inspection done by a specialist.

Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
Personally, not even with a barge pole.

21TonyK

13,408 posts

240 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
Unless it was a rare car or amazingly cheap I wouldn't on the basis that there are a lot of non-cat D repaired cars to chose from.

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
Unless it was a rare car or amazingly cheap I wouldn't on the basis that there are a lot of non-cat D repaired cars to chose from.
But unless you intend to ever sell the car (which I don't), the cat-Dness of it is only a mark on a piece of paper - or I suppose in a database these days.

Bare in mind that cat-D can mean stolen and recovered too.

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
I personally prefer to buy a car that has never had an accident. Even if a car has an accident and parts appear un-touched, stresses could still have been put on components and could introduce tolerance differences, week points etc and any difference can be a problem. Depends how fussy you are...

21TonyK

13,408 posts

240 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
kambites said:
21TonyK said:
Unless it was a rare car or amazingly cheap I wouldn't on the basis that there are a lot of non-cat D repaired cars to chose from.
But unless you intend to ever sell the car (which I don't), the cat-Dness of it is only a mark on a piece of paper - or I suppose in a database these days.

Bare in mind that cat-D can mean stolen and recovered too.
True, but can you really say you will never sell it? Depends what its worth as well. If you could potentially be out of pocket by more than whatever you can afford to lose then I'd still say no. Bit diff. it's a £10K Elise than a £70K Fezza and you're only going to lose £1-2K but even so, it's all money!


21TonyK

13,408 posts

240 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
kambites said:
21TonyK said:
Unless it was a rare car or amazingly cheap I wouldn't on the basis that there are a lot of non-cat D repaired cars to chose from.
But unless you intend to ever sell the car (which I don't), the cat-Dness of it is only a mark on a piece of paper - or I suppose in a database these days.

Bare in mind that cat-D can mean stolen and recovered too.
True, but can you really say you will never sell it? Depends what its worth as well. If you could potentially be out of pocket by more than whatever you can afford to lose then I'd still say no. Bit diff. it's a £10K Elise than a £70K Fezza and you're only going to lose £1-2K but even so, it's all money!


Risotto

3,934 posts

243 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
I'd say it's a risk worth taking assuming you pay a suitable price. Taking things to the extreme, if it was £500 we'd all buy it without a second though. If it was the same price as a non cat d car, nobody would touch it.

I think Elises are something of a special case:

The way the bodywork is designed means that a minor low speed accident can result in the need to replace the entire front or rear of the car. Insurance companies like to deal with approved bodyshops who fit new parts. I dread to think how much a new clam from Lotus would cost, let alone the cost of fitting/painting. When you add in the other factors common to any insurance claim, it's not hard to see how so may Elises end up being written off with purely cosmetic damage. Granted, cat d can encompass more significant damage but I wouldn't dismiss a cat-d car out of hand.

Ultimately, unless you buy a brand new car, who can guarantee that their car hasn't suffered unrecorded damage?

Say for example you're the second owner. You bought the car privately, got a clean HPI check and off you went. But who knows - maybe the first owner came off a wet roundabout backwards and smacked into a lamp post. Guy drives it home, gets a new clam off eBay for £250, gives his mate a few quid to spray and fit it, maybe gets a new exhaust etc. No record of an accident, no insurance company involvement. At least if the car is recorded as a cat-d write off you KNOW it's had an accident!

Really, all that matters with cat d cars is the price and evidence that the car has been repaired to a good standard. If you're lucky there'll be photos of the damage before, during and after repair and a nice big receipt from a reputable bodyshop.


Edited by Risotto on Wednesday 13th June 22:40

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
Risotto said:
...photos of the damage before, during and after repair ...
A MUST if you ask me.

deep purple

Original Poster:

35 posts

236 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
Thanks guys for all your advice.

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
True, but can you really say you will never sell it? Depends what its worth as well. If you could potentially be out of pocket by more than whatever you can afford to lose then I'd still say no. Bit diff. it's a £10K Elise than a £70K Fezza and you're only going to lose £1-2K but even so, it's all money!
I can't imagine why I would ever sell the car. I'd get rid of the girlfriend's Fiat before my Elise. wink I suppose if I got made redundant I might need to (although I could live for at least a couple of years off my savings).