Potential New Owner - Advice Needed
Potential New Owner - Advice Needed
Author
Discussion

worldwidewebs

Original Poster:

2,978 posts

281 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Please help...

I've been running a Westfiled for nearly 4 years as a weekend/trackday toy - a fabulous machine that I've personally fully rebuilt and had properly setup, and with over 200bhp carrying 550kg. The problem is I'm finding less and less time to really use it and have toyed with the idea of a more practical replacement for a year or so. Top of my list (as you'll be pleased to know) is the Elise.

The problem is that the cars I've driven so far don't quite do it for me and I need to know what to do.

I initially drove an S1 back-to-back with an S2 111R. The S1 was a nice car, but as a replacement for the Westfield I found it severley lacking in the power department. The 111R, whilst still not as quick was more than acceptable in that respect. But whilst it might be ok on the track I found the power delivery more than irritating on the road - it reminded me of an old Saab turbo the way the power kicked in.

I'm not expecting to match the Westfield's power but I do want something with a bit of poke. I've got around £16k to play with, so what do I do? Do I buy something like a 135 or 111S (I think I prefer the S2) and if so what mods are available to lift the power up? Or is there something I've not thought about/missed?

I did work for a while with Tim Skipper who had the first S2 190 Sport and have thought about one of them, but they are a bit thin on the ground. Oh, and the Exige is fantastic but I want an "open" car.

Thanks for the help
www

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Depends what you're really after. There are a few about with honda/audi conversions which start at 220bhp upwards. Or if you want more power from the K series ones www.dvapower.com or have the second-cam ECU mod for the R that lowers the RPM needed for that kick.

Theres an S1 with a honda engine in for sale on SELOC for 15/17k and theres one on here for 19k

Plenty of options

worldwidewebs

Original Poster:

2,978 posts

281 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
Paul

Thanks for the reply. I do like the sound of one of the Honda cars although I've not actually driven one yet - I think they may be a bit out of my price range though tbh.

I did speak with Dave Andrews last week and from what he said, the S1 was the easier/cheaper car to work with due to engine bay size and shape. Getting an S1 up to 190bhp he reckoned would cost about £4k-ish all in - and about £5k-ish for around 220bhp. I'm not sure I'd want to spend that amount on an 'old' car but maybe if I can find one in good condition that's had the work done already it could be a good choice.

I just wonder though whether a S2 111S or S2 135 Sport might be a better bet for me - I'd like to keep the car for a while so the newer the better really. Out of the box, do you have any idea which is the better car, and which might lend itself to a slight increase in power (say 10-20bhp) for not too much cash?

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
The problem with any work on K series engines is the reliability of them, hence spending 4k on a K will see you having to refresh the engine 30/40k down the road which is more ££.

As you've said I'd try one of the S2 111S or the S2 Sport 135R (note the 'R' basically better spec - http://www.elises.co.uk/models/ ). The 111R is coming down in price looking on the classified theres one for 17k.

I'd buy with a sports exhaust and induction already on the car and you've might see 10bhp and saves you spending the cash. Plenty of places to test drive and I guessing the VVC engine will give you a perferable power delivery as its more linear then the other varients.

You've been spoilt with the power to weight ratio of the Westie, you're not going to get very close to that really for 16k.

  • edit* Don't forget you can get 160/190 variants of the S1 too. The Sport 160 and the Sport 190 both are rare (319x160s made and 50+ 190s) but they hold their value. Although I bias as I have a 160 biggrin


Edited by Paul RN on Saturday 16th June 16:12

fatwomble

1,389 posts

245 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
you can get a conversion kit for the exige to make it a convertible.

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
fatwomble said:
you can get a conversion kit for the exige to make it a convertible.
I think thats S2 Exiges only which would be more than his budget.

worldwidewebs

Original Poster:

2,978 posts

281 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
fatwomble said:
you can get a conversion kit for the exige to make it a convertible.
Aaargghhh! Messing with my mind!!!!!! biggrinbiggrin

worldwidewebs

Original Poster:

2,978 posts

281 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
Do the S2 111S, 135R and 135 Sport have the same gearbox? I'm pretty sure I've read that the 135R has a close ratio box but I'm not too sure about the others.

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
worldwidewebs said:
Do the S2 111S, 135R and 135 Sport have the same gearbox? I'm pretty sure I've read that the 135R has a close ratio box but I'm not too sure about the others.
S1 111S come with a c/r box
S1 Sport 135 comes with a c/r box
S2 Standard Model comes with a c/r box
S2 111S come with a w/r box

I'd have a guess that as the S2 Sport 135/R are just an uprated standard S2 it would come with the C/R box.

Edited by Paul RN on Saturday 16th June 23:05

kambites

71,712 posts

252 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
What about a VX220 turbo? Probably worth a drive.

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
kambites said:
What about a VX220 turbo? Probably worth a drive.
Good point, pretty much the same car with 200 BHP as standard and its easier to hike the power to 240/250.

crackthatoff

3,314 posts

244 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
Paul RN said:
worldwidewebs said:
Do the S2 111S, 135R and 135 Sport have the same gearbox? I'm pretty sure I've read that the 135R has a close ratio box but I'm not too sure about the others.
with the 135r you also get
pumpy up seats, ajustable suspension, yoko a048's, oz super t's and an inch wider on the front rims so the s1 boys can't winge about the s2 having no oversteer!

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
crackthatoff said:
worldwidewebs said:
Do the S2 111S, 135R and 135 Sport have the same gearbox? I'm pretty sure I've read that the 135R has a close ratio box but I'm not too sure about the others.
with the 135r you also get
pumpy up seats, ajustable suspension, yoko a048's, oz super t's and an inch wider on the front rims so the s1 boys can't winge about the s2 having no oversteer! oh and a free hair dryer and curling tongs
biggrin

crackthatoff

3,314 posts

244 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
Paul RN said:
crackthatoff said:
worldwidewebs said:
Do the S2 111S, 135R and 135 Sport have the same gearbox? I'm pretty sure I've read that the 135R has a close ratio box but I'm not too sure about the others.
with the 135r you also get
pumpy up seats, ajustable suspension, yoko a048's, oz super t's and an inch wider on the front rims so the s1 boys can't winge about the s2 having no oversteer! oh and a free hair dryer and curling tongs
biggrin
eat shit s1 lover nerd

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
crackthatoff said:
Paul RN said:
crackthatoff said:
worldwidewebs said:
Do the S2 111S, 135R and 135 Sport have the same gearbox? I'm pretty sure I've read that the 135R has a close ratio box but I'm not too sure about the others.
with the 135r you also get
pumpy up seats, ajustable suspension, yoko a048's, oz super t's and an inch wider on the front rims so the s1 boys can't winge about the s2 having no oversteer! oh and a free hair dryer and curling tongs
biggrin
eat shit s1 lover nerd
Ah no denial, my work here is done. biglaugh

worldwidewebs

Original Poster:

2,978 posts

281 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
Well after a bit of head scratching I think I may be getting there... At the moment, the best situation looks to be to get hold of a standard S2 for around £10-11k and take it to Dave Andrews. Another £4-5k with him and a bit more for susp mods etc should see me with 210-220bhp and a nice wedge of torque.

Anything I've overlooked???

crackthatoff

3,314 posts

244 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
urm did you mean 10-11k for a honda conversion or for the car it's self? cause the 220bhp is gonna cost you 12k for a decent s2 then 11-14k for the honda conversion...... unless someone knows otherwise or you are already buying a converted one ??? saying that I'm a relative noobie myself!