New brake pads fitted, mother of all noises...
Discussion
Is there anything more frustrating than taking your car to a reputable specialist 80 miles away, asking them to put new Mintex 1144 pads on as part of a £700 service, and finding out that when you come to a complete stop there is a massive graunching noise?
Symptoms appear to be that it only happens when they are warm, and not every single time. It really is a horrendously loud graunchy, graty noise, and I think I can feel a slight pulse through the pedal as well.
Basically my car sounds like a bus with defective brakes only noisier - has anyone had the same problem after having these pads fitted (IIRC it was a B service so they would have changed the brake fluid too?)
Over to you the PH massive...
(04 plate 111S, with standard drilled brakes)
Symptoms appear to be that it only happens when they are warm, and not every single time. It really is a horrendously loud graunchy, graty noise, and I think I can feel a slight pulse through the pedal as well.
Basically my car sounds like a bus with defective brakes only noisier - has anyone had the same problem after having these pads fitted (IIRC it was a B service so they would have changed the brake fluid too?)
Over to you the PH massive...
(04 plate 111S, with standard drilled brakes)
Are you following the correct bedding in procedure for the pads???
I am quite new to cars, but on bikes you are told to use slow firm to increasing firm pressure on the pads, throwing in a few emergency stops here and there, but otherwise keeping away from late and heavy use of the brakes.
If you don't 'skim' the pads into place, you can get blisters or even baked pads which shine like mirrors - and your brakes end up all over the place.
However, the only time I used a mechanic to do my brakes I ended up with the same noises as you on leaving the shop - on the brake there is a anti-chatter pin, which stops the brakes sounding like they are clicking or catching - and the mechanic had fitted this upside down.
( This tends to sound more like a helicopter has got stuck in the brakes )
One other possibility is the mechanic did not push the pistons back into place and re-set them, and the pads, correctly. Very likely, actually - and a brake fluid change, while it should have been done, is not part of a 'B' service, it is always an extra. You can check this by pushing the car and listening if the pads grind, or go for a run without using the brakes if possible, and feel if the discs are warm.
If this is the case then you can sometimes free the pistons by using the brakes a lot - keeping in mind your dilemma with bedding them properly.
I am quite new to cars, but on bikes you are told to use slow firm to increasing firm pressure on the pads, throwing in a few emergency stops here and there, but otherwise keeping away from late and heavy use of the brakes.
If you don't 'skim' the pads into place, you can get blisters or even baked pads which shine like mirrors - and your brakes end up all over the place.
However, the only time I used a mechanic to do my brakes I ended up with the same noises as you on leaving the shop - on the brake there is a anti-chatter pin, which stops the brakes sounding like they are clicking or catching - and the mechanic had fitted this upside down.
( This tends to sound more like a helicopter has got stuck in the brakes )
One other possibility is the mechanic did not push the pistons back into place and re-set them, and the pads, correctly. Very likely, actually - and a brake fluid change, while it should have been done, is not part of a 'B' service, it is always an extra. You can check this by pushing the car and listening if the pads grind, or go for a run without using the brakes if possible, and feel if the discs are warm.
If this is the case then you can sometimes free the pistons by using the brakes a lot - keeping in mind your dilemma with bedding them properly.
Taken from SELOC Techwiki:- brake bedding in procedure - although I not sure as to whether this might cause your discs to warp but as it is from Lotus direct. I guess the same applied to Mintex 1144. I did it and it seemed to work ok for my 1144's
For Standard Lotus OEM items the following recommendations came from Nick Adams (Lotus development engineer)
With new pads and discs, or just new pads fitted run the car around for 10/20 miles using the brakes gently as normal to bed the two surfaces together. Once this has been done, check the surfaces of the discs and make sure there are no signs of any scoring or damage. Assuming all looks well take the car to an appropriate piece of quiet and straight, well sighted road and perform half a dozen medium pressure stops from 50 mph down to 20 mph to warm the brakes up. Avoid more than a minute between each stop so that the temperatures do not get a chance to deteriorate too much. Once the brakes are warm and the coast is clear, perform 2 or 3 hard stops from 70mph (where local laws allow!) to 20 mph, braking as hard as you can without locking up. Do not come to a halt between each stop, do them as fast as you can to get the brakes really hot. On the third stop come to a halt and, keeping your foot on the brake, press the brake pedal down as hard as you can and hold it there for at least a couple of minutes, don't apply the handbrake. This hurts if you are doing it right! This will bed the pistons, shims and pads together and will compress the pad material, giving a hard and repeatable pedal. Once the 2 minutes have passed, release the pedal and go for a short drive, using the brakes as normal to let everything return to normal temperatures. The brakes are now fully bedded in and ready for use in anger. Recompressing the pads once every few thousand miles to the above procedure will help keep the pedal firm, especially if you don't normally use the brakes hard.
Also I beleive in the box that the pads come in there is a specific procedure for mintex 1144's. If you dont have the box I can go and look in mine and post at a later time... let me know, I think it is a series of stops from 40 down to 10 and then 70 to 10 or something like this. However if you look at the website it says 50 miles of soft breaking avoiding emergency breaking..Pretty confusing I know hence why I just took the advice of lotus and applied that to Mintex pads and it seemed to work.
Hope this helps
As for the noise I get a pulse too - think it is the pads running over lines of the drilled discs and a case of TADTS.....
For Standard Lotus OEM items the following recommendations came from Nick Adams (Lotus development engineer)
With new pads and discs, or just new pads fitted run the car around for 10/20 miles using the brakes gently as normal to bed the two surfaces together. Once this has been done, check the surfaces of the discs and make sure there are no signs of any scoring or damage. Assuming all looks well take the car to an appropriate piece of quiet and straight, well sighted road and perform half a dozen medium pressure stops from 50 mph down to 20 mph to warm the brakes up. Avoid more than a minute between each stop so that the temperatures do not get a chance to deteriorate too much. Once the brakes are warm and the coast is clear, perform 2 or 3 hard stops from 70mph (where local laws allow!) to 20 mph, braking as hard as you can without locking up. Do not come to a halt between each stop, do them as fast as you can to get the brakes really hot. On the third stop come to a halt and, keeping your foot on the brake, press the brake pedal down as hard as you can and hold it there for at least a couple of minutes, don't apply the handbrake. This hurts if you are doing it right! This will bed the pistons, shims and pads together and will compress the pad material, giving a hard and repeatable pedal. Once the 2 minutes have passed, release the pedal and go for a short drive, using the brakes as normal to let everything return to normal temperatures. The brakes are now fully bedded in and ready for use in anger. Recompressing the pads once every few thousand miles to the above procedure will help keep the pedal firm, especially if you don't normally use the brakes hard.
Also I beleive in the box that the pads come in there is a specific procedure for mintex 1144's. If you dont have the box I can go and look in mine and post at a later time... let me know, I think it is a series of stops from 40 down to 10 and then 70 to 10 or something like this. However if you look at the website it says 50 miles of soft breaking avoiding emergency breaking..Pretty confusing I know hence why I just took the advice of lotus and applied that to Mintex pads and it seemed to work.
Hope this helps
As for the noise I get a pulse too - think it is the pads running over lines of the drilled discs and a case of TADTS.....
Edited by darren_S2 on Saturday 16th June 22:25
Is the swept area of the new pads slightly different? You might be braking with the very edge of the pad on an unuseed part of the disk or maybe the pad is moving slightly in the caliper and doing the same thing in fact if it's not doing it consistently, it's more likely to be the latter.
Take the wheel off and see if the pads can move in the caliper.
Take the wheel off and see if the pads can move in the caliper.
jondude said:
One other possibility is the mechanic did not push the pistons back into place and re-set them, and the pads, correctly. Very likely, actually - and a brake fluid change, while it should have been done, is not part of a 'B' service, it is always an extra. You can check this by pushing the car and listening if the pads grind
Well, the noise is still happening - I tried pushing it, and yes, there is a grinding from the front right pad at least.I am pretty fvcked off having just spent 700 quid on a B service with a reputable specialists who I used because of the work they have done on several BoLOCs' cars, and they can't even fit brake pads properly.
With that in mind, and the fact that I can't be arsed to drive back to Guildford because I got a "Friday afternoon" job, what's my next step to get this sorted?
Appreciate what you are saying.
Anyhow, what the mechanic should have done was push the pistons back into the calipers, THEN put the pads on. This means they then slip over the discs, and you re-set the pads and pistons by pumping ( gently ) the brake pedal until they sit on the discs. A bit like makimg sure you don't cross thread a screw...and your pistons and pads may now be acting like this as they are out of balance.
On motorbikes there is much easier access, so you can swing the caliper off and push the piston back in 5 minutes or less ( you may need a clamp ).
On the Lotus I would imagine this is not so easy to do timewise or toolwise.
So what you can try are some hard and firm 'panic' braking stops - like how you react if a football bounces across the road but you then see it has missed...or how you might react to spotting a GATSO late...a quick and firm kick on the pedal, then release.
This can, reasonably often too, 'shock' the piston into lining up and freeing itself a little - it only needs to free up a little.
If you still get no joy, then bearing in mind what you have paid, I would take the car back and let them sort it, especially as it still could be something else.
Agree totally, that you should not pay £700 and then get a car back with work ( or lack of ) related issues.
Anyhow, what the mechanic should have done was push the pistons back into the calipers, THEN put the pads on. This means they then slip over the discs, and you re-set the pads and pistons by pumping ( gently ) the brake pedal until they sit on the discs. A bit like makimg sure you don't cross thread a screw...and your pistons and pads may now be acting like this as they are out of balance.
On motorbikes there is much easier access, so you can swing the caliper off and push the piston back in 5 minutes or less ( you may need a clamp ).
On the Lotus I would imagine this is not so easy to do timewise or toolwise.
So what you can try are some hard and firm 'panic' braking stops - like how you react if a football bounces across the road but you then see it has missed...or how you might react to spotting a GATSO late...a quick and firm kick on the pedal, then release.
This can, reasonably often too, 'shock' the piston into lining up and freeing itself a little - it only needs to free up a little.
If you still get no joy, then bearing in mind what you have paid, I would take the car back and let them sort it, especially as it still could be something else.
Agree totally, that you should not pay £700 and then get a car back with work ( or lack of ) related issues.
Bing o - am assuming the noise is only when you use the brakes and there is not a constant noise when the wheel is turning?
Sounds to me like the new pads are rubbing on the unswept part of the disc. My Mintex 1144's did this to start with. i.e on picture below the blue arrow points to the swept part of disc. Red arrow to unswept part (it is the "rusted" part). My new mintex's sat slightly on the unswpet part. Whilst no noise could be heard on turning of the wheel, under braking, the pads would bite onto the unswept part and due to the roughness of the surface cause a bit of a racket. Solution is to either wiggle the pads a little so that they are no longer on the unswept part or some heavy braking to make the unswept part become the swept part. You know you will be doing this as new shiny metal will appear on the disc where the new swept part has been created.

Before taking it back to dealer - I would check this. Best thing to do is take wheel off and take a look - this should be easy to spot if this is the case as I am assuming you have been using them and you should be able to see some off the unswept part becoming swept. Also check for stones or debris between brake pad/caliper and disc - is there any scoring on disc? (inside or out)
p.s sorry if I am teaching you to suck eggs - i dont know if you mechanically gifted or not...
Sounds to me like the new pads are rubbing on the unswept part of the disc. My Mintex 1144's did this to start with. i.e on picture below the blue arrow points to the swept part of disc. Red arrow to unswept part (it is the "rusted" part). My new mintex's sat slightly on the unswpet part. Whilst no noise could be heard on turning of the wheel, under braking, the pads would bite onto the unswept part and due to the roughness of the surface cause a bit of a racket. Solution is to either wiggle the pads a little so that they are no longer on the unswept part or some heavy braking to make the unswept part become the swept part. You know you will be doing this as new shiny metal will appear on the disc where the new swept part has been created.

Before taking it back to dealer - I would check this. Best thing to do is take wheel off and take a look - this should be easy to spot if this is the case as I am assuming you have been using them and you should be able to see some off the unswept part becoming swept. Also check for stones or debris between brake pad/caliper and disc - is there any scoring on disc? (inside or out)
p.s sorry if I am teaching you to suck eggs - i dont know if you mechanically gifted or not...
Edited by darren_S2 on Wednesday 20th June 22:10
jondude said:
Anyhow, what the mechanic should have done was push the pistons back into the calipers, THEN put the pads on. This means they then slip over the discs, and you re-set the pads and pistons by pumping ( gently ) the brake pedal until they sit on the discs. A bit like makimg sure you don't cross thread a screw...and your pistons and pads may now be acting like this as they are out of balance.
Wouldn't this be a quick job if i took it somewhere local?Numpties!!
You can even do it yourself and you only need a few simple tools. Only takes an hour or 2 and not much can go wrong - just the pistons. The front ones are easy - you can just use your thumb or a spanner - the rears can be a pain but pretty easy with a pair of long nose pliers.
Full guide is here:-
http://elise-faq.info/index.php?title=Pad_change
Full guide is here:-
http://elise-faq.info/index.php?title=Pad_change
You are right in that in shouldn't take too long to do and it is a straightforward job, only that - like you - I feel it is wrong you may be charged another hour's labour ( at least ) to do something which should have been done before.
Annoying.
Hope you get it sorted soon - and properly!!!
Annoying.
Hope you get it sorted soon - and properly!!!
darren_S2 said:
Sounds to me like the new pads are rubbing on the unswept part of the disc.
I agree with this and the other guys that have mentioned it... my RS42's did this when i changed them... took it for a blast and bedding in proceedure and all was cured, very embarassing driving through town initially though!I now have cronnic rattle which on investigation is due to shims 'popping' out and disappearing...gonna fit some buffer pads when I can get the jammed wheel nut off

IF you have a look yourself bing-o then deffo use a torque wrench on wheel nuts!
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



