Advice Required
Author
Discussion

Bing o

Original Poster:

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
I have a friend, we shall call him "Dirk".

Now, Dirk took his car to a specialist company 80 miles away for a service and to get new brake pads fitted. Since the service the brakes have grumbled due to the fact that the leading edge of the pad overlaps the disc onto the wheel hub itself.

Dirks car is due it's first MOT next weekend, Dirk wants to know:

1. Would the brake pads in this condition constitute an MOT fail?

2. How he should approach the specialist concerned should any remedial work be required at the local garage who are providing the MOT?

Dirk thanks you in advance....

(NB, it isn't convenient for Dirk to do a 160 mile round trip to get the specialist garage to look at it....)

tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
Can't see how Dirks pads can do this as if as you say the pads are to big for the discs then they would not have been able to fit them into the calipers as they have to be the perfect size. That said as long as the brakes are working correctly and achieve the correct percentages on the rolling road then all should be well .
If they are noisy perhaps Dirk should take them apart , clean and grease them.

Bing o

Original Poster:

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
tricky 100 said:
If they are noisy perhaps Dirk should take them apart , clean and grease them.
Dirk is no spanner monkey, and doesn't see why he should have to be a part time spanner monkey when he has paid someone an attractive hourly rate to do it in the first place...


darren_S2

32 posts

233 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
My advice for Dirk, is to stop worrying about the noise. Go out, drive the car like it was intended and use the brakes as they are surposed to be used and not worry too much about the noise. After some heavy braking then the noise will reduce. You will always get some noise, especially if you using drilled / slotted discs. If fitted properly Mintex 1144 which you (mean Dirk wink) has fitted should not be touching the hub, rather an "unswept" part of the disc.

Not much the dealer can do, apart from replace new discs or clean old one but doubt that would solve problem.

If I was closer would come and help you (mean Dirk) and put your mind at rest but am miles away. You might be able to ask one of the BOLOC's guys to come take a look as although I dont know them some of them are very knowledgeable.

As for MOT, it should be fine as long as the brakes work, (am assuming they do!) and are within the percentages and do not suffer from any inbalance. You can't fail an MOT due to noise from brakes.

Best thing to do is just go out for a hoon driving and use the brakes till the noise begins to fade. This is what I did and it work and puts a biggrin on your face at the same time!



driving

Bing o

Original Poster:

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
Dirks been trying to wear them in for the past month - he can see where they actually touch the wheel hub. He doesn't mean a bit of noise, he is talking full on metal vs metal "nnnnnnAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAArrrrrrrrrfggggggggghhhhh"....

tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
Bit silly taking it 80 miles away then to get a simple service and pads , should of taken it somewhere local if your not prepared to return 80 miles to deal with any reprecussions !
I dont see how refering to people with the nohow and ability to fix their own cars as " monkeys " helps either .

darren_S2

32 posts

233 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
Can you post pics of the discs and pads etc?

Bing o

Original Poster:

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
tricky 100 said:
Bit silly taking it 80 miles away then to get a simple service and pads , should of taken it somewhere local if your not prepared to return 80 miles to deal with any reprecussions !
I was getting other work done at the same time, and it fitted in with my going on holiday.

tricky 100 said:
I dont see how refering to people with the nohow and ability to fix their own cars as " monkeys " helps either .
Can I refer you here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-deprecation

darren_S2 said:
Can you post pics of the discs and pads etc?{/quote]

Genius idea - I'll have a crack tonight!



tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all

tricky 100 said:
I dont see how refering to people with the nohow and ability to fix their own cars as " monkeys " helps either .
Can I refer you here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-deprecation

Oh i see , you were making a self-deprecating joke about your inabilities ........so then whose the monkey ?

ChristianM

257 posts

258 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
Edited to add: All references to 'you' are references to Mr D Diggler.

Just read your ealier post mate.

I had Mintex rears fitted at a highly reccomended specialist and fitted the fronts myself. I experienced exactly the same noise as you describe however the pads are excellent, better bite from cold and firmer feeling pedal. When driving in france for Le Mans we set the sat nav to avoid all highways and toll roads so took windy country roads all the way there and back. Not really hard drivng due to the rain and slower cars in convoy but a good workout for the pads.

The noise has now reduced significantly and I rarely hear it at all. It seems my rears are clearing a sligtly greater area on the disk as suggested. If yours are indeed the same, my advice is as others, just drive it and be patient. It was feking loud tho and pretty emmbarasing to start with.

Edited by ChristianM on Tuesday 3rd July 13:17

Bing o

Original Poster:

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
tricky 100 said:
...so then whose the monkey ?
<tries hard not to be rude smilie>

Cheers Christian, sounds like it's another TADTS - I'll post piccies tonight on behalf of Dirk, and let the PH massive all point at my (er I mean Dirk's) inadequacies as a mechanic....

Bing o

Original Poster:

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
Right, after numerous attempts this is my best effort (crap camera/lighting):

Front pad



Rear pad



All comments welcome chaps/chapesses

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
That looks bad, and wrong. I'm no spanner man but any fool can tell that the pad shouldn't be touching the hub like that. Were it me, I'd be on the phone to whoever fitted them and be asking them if they'll pay for the labour at Dirks most local indie to remedy the situation.

Bing o

Original Poster:

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
Cheers Tim - did you mean the fronts only, or fronts and rear? They do squeal when I put the hand brake on if the car is moving?

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
All I know is that I've *never* seen pads which overrun the disc to the point where they foul the hub. I've seen them overhang the disc on the outer edge somewhat, but (as far as I can remember) that's not an issue other than you not getting the full value of the friction possible if the whole pad is in contact with the disc (I guess). Common-sense tells me that the hub shouldn't be in contact with anything rotating like that and fouling it.

cej

961 posts

253 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2007
quotequote all
Ouch yikes That doesn't look good. Get it fixed . And whoever fitted it should pay the cost

darren_S2

32 posts

233 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Impossible to tell on the fronts as all you can see is the caliper!

but agree with everyone here on the rears, looks like the pads are actually on the hub and not a question of just purely the noise coming from a unswept part of a disc.

Maybe its me but are the rear pads in properly. It looks to me as they are not straight and the tops are not in calipers properly causing the top of the pad to out further (hence on hub) than the bottom part but could be down to the skills of the photographer? Have you tried to "wiggle" the pads in the caliper - do they move?

You can see where the pad is rubbing on the hub in the second photo by the presence of the lighter brown ring around the hub. Would send this to the garage that fitted them and then point out that this is wrong and ask them to sort out.


Grinzzz

566 posts

248 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Sounds like the wrong pads to me, but hey, what do i know compared to motor industry professionals.

Bing o

Original Poster:

15,184 posts

250 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Grinzzz said:
Sounds like the wrong pads to me
Mintex 1144's ordered from Elise Parts....

Bing o

Original Poster:

15,184 posts

250 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Dirk's spoken to the specialist, it is just a fact that the pads are slightly larger than the old ones, and are rubbing against an unworn part of the disc - you can see on the rear picture that the hub starts where the darker metal is about 2/3rds of the way in.

Panic averted and I (I mean Dirk) must stop being so precious smile

Remedial action is apparently to take it for a damn good thrashing, so that's Dirk's weekend sorted out!!

Thanks to all those that contributed.