Exige v Exige S
Author
Discussion

Jimnic007

Original Poster:

108 posts

270 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Afternoon all,
Just wondered if anyone could point me in the direction of a good comparison between the Exige and the Exige S? Struggling to find anything using the search function.
Cheers,
J

slatess1

437 posts

245 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
There are so many different variants of engines between s1 and s2 exiges and then obviously the exige s and honda'd versions. What you want to do is ask the question, is model 'a' better than model 'b' then grab some popcorn and enjoy the show as people reply laugh

Phil-CH

1,132 posts

295 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Wasn't that what he was doing? (I'm assuming he wants a comparison between the Exige S2 and the ExigeS2-S?)

My 2-cents:
Get a well sorted standard Exige S2 (without the supercharger) and when you want more power, get a supercharger by Bemani and up the power significantly higher than any of the current official Lotus varients. Cheaper too.

Edited by Phil-CH on Thursday 5th July 14:50

slatess1

437 posts

245 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Phil-CH said:
Wasn't that what he was doing? (I'm assuming he wants a comparison between the Exige S2 and the ExigeS2-S?)

My 2-cents:
Get a well sorted standard Exige S2 (without the supercharger) and when you want more power, get a supercharger by Bemani and up the power significantly higher than any of the current official Lotus varients. Cheaper too.

Edited by Phil-CH on Thursday 5th July 14:50
I thought thats what he probably wanted but didnt want to assume as ive had my head bitten off on here before for some trivial things lol so i keep out of debates now... Just enjoy watching them unfold as a spectator clap

Buy a standard model and modify the engine, insurance permitting as per Phil, smile factor will be awesome and it will undoubtedly work out cheaper than buying a top of the range model, just my opinion...

Edited by slatess1 on Thursday 5th July 15:03

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Unless I am mistaken, shouldn't the thread be: Exige V Exige S V Honda'd Exige?

zebra

Boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
zebra said:
Unless I am mistaken, shouldn't the thread be: Exige V Exige S V Honda'd Exige?

zebra
Oh no here we go again

Boggy

Phil-CH

1,132 posts

295 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
zebra said:
Unless I am mistaken, shouldn't the thread be: Exige V Exige S V Honda'd Exige?

zebra
Not sure, but if he's in a position like me who loves the rawness of the Exige S1 but absolutely adores the look of the S2, the S1 may not be an option. And putting a Honda into a S2 Exige isn't all that easy and depending where you're from, may not even be an option...

slatess1

437 posts

245 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Jimnic007 said:
Afternoon all,
Just wondered if anyone could point me in the direction of a good comparison between the Exige and the Exige S? Struggling to find anything using the search function.
Cheers,
J
Just out of curiosity, How long have you been a bank robber for going by your current fleet of cars, so not fair!!

Aston Martin DB9

Porsche 997 GT3

Mercedes SL55

Maserati Gran Sport Spyder

Lamborghini Gallardo Spyder

Jaguar XKR

Harley Davidson Softtail roadster 1584

Ferrari 430 Manual

BMW M6 Convertible

Bentley Continental GTC

Aston Martin V8 Vantage

Porsche 997 Turbo

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
methinks his 'my website' offers a clue to the size of his fleet...wink

slatess1

437 posts

245 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
TTwiggy said:
methinks his 'my website' offers a clue to the size of his fleet...wink
Missed that, what a cool job smokin

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
TTwiggy said:
methinks his 'my website' offers a clue to the size of his fleet...wink
So why ask us for comparisons? Is this about to turn into a marketing strategy?

zebra

redevil

1,242 posts

237 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Maybe he wants to add one to the fleet, maybe he wants one. Surely if you can afford it, you get the 'S', right?

Boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
redevil said:
Maybe he wants to add one to the fleet, maybe he wants one. Surely if you can afford it, you get the 'S', right?
If it's going into the Club then it's an Exige S, If it's for yourself then I'd go for a Honda Conversion/240R/Cup/GT (Please say if I've missed any)

Boggy

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Boggy said:
redevil said:
Maybe he wants to add one to the fleet, maybe he wants one. Surely if you can afford it, you get the 'S', right?
If it's going into the Club then it's an Exige S, If it's for yourself then I'd go for a Honda Conversion/240R/Cup/GT (Please say if I've missed any)

Boggy
That about covers it

Boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
zebra said:
Boggy said:
redevil said:
Maybe he wants to add one to the fleet, maybe he wants one. Surely if you can afford it, you get the 'S', right?
If it's going into the Club then it's an Exige S, If it's for yourself then I'd go for a Honda Conversion/240R/Cup/GT (Please say if I've missed any)

Boggy
That about covers it
Can't keep up these day's so many variants

Boggy

Jimnic007

Original Poster:

108 posts

270 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Thanks all for the prompt replies.
The Exige is not for the club, this one is for me. I sold my S2 Elise 18 months ago and miss the Lotus fun factor.
I want to try an S2 Exige, but with so many variants around I couldn't understand the differences. I would be using it for mostly road miles (probably about 8000 a year) and possibly 3 or 4 track days a year.
I hear some people saying that the n/a Exige 'sounds' better, but is it a better drive, which is lighter etc? Is there not a page somewhere on the web with a comparison of the various Exiges? I didn't want to open a huge can of worms, but I guess it is inevitable as everyone thinks their car is the best.
I saw the black S2 Exige S in the classifieds yesterday, for about £28k ish and thought that it looks like a lot of car for the money.
Basically, I am seriously considering an S2 Exige, but am not sure which variant is best suited.
Thanks,
J

RichyBoy

3,749 posts

248 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Don't think that black exige s has aircon.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Jimnic007 said:
Thanks all for the prompt replies.
The Exige is not for the club, this one is for me. I sold my S2 Elise 18 months ago and miss the Lotus fun factor.
I want to try an S2 Exige, but with so many variants around I couldn't understand the differences. I would be using it for mostly road miles (probably about 8000 a year) and possibly 3 or 4 track days a year.
I hear some people saying that the n/a Exige 'sounds' better, but is it a better drive, which is lighter etc? Is there not a page somewhere on the web with a comparison of the various Exiges? I didn't want to open a huge can of worms, but I guess it is inevitable as everyone thinks their car is the best.
I saw the black S2 Exige S in the classifieds yesterday, for about £28k ish and thought that it looks like a lot of car for the money.
Basically, I am seriously considering an S2 Exige, but am not sure which variant is best suited.
Thanks,
J
James, welcome to the forum. As I'm sure you know, there is simply no better comparison than what your hands, heart, head, feet and arse tell you from the drivers seat. My strong advice is call up your local dealer and try to arrange test drives of an NA Exige, an S, and a Cup spec car. Then you have the 3 variants commonly available (189NA, 220SC and 240SC bhp). No substitute for driving them.

Enjoy.

m1nky

142 posts

238 months

Friday 6th July 2007
quotequote all
If you can afford go for the S. Look at the 0-100 times between the 2 cars - the S is well over 3 seconds quicker. It is a lot easier to drive, bags more torque for overtaking etc without having to ring it's neck. Mine has the stage 1 fitted and I can't imagine an exige sounding better without the supercharger. Oh, and mine is the one for sale you referred to. It makes me smile that, in general, the only people who say AC is essential are those that already have it. How would they know if they can live without it? Do a search on the forums like I did and the vast majority of owners WITHOUT AC say that they don't miss it at all. And besides not having AC makes mine the cheapest S in the country at the moment!!

Phil-CH

1,132 posts

295 months

Friday 6th July 2007
quotequote all
m1nky said:
If you can afford go for the S. Look at the 0-100 times between the 2 cars - the S is well over 3 seconds quicker. It is a lot easier to drive, bags more torque for overtaking etc without having to ring it's neck. Mine has the stage 1 fitted and I can't imagine an exige sounding better without the supercharger. Oh, and mine is the one for sale you referred to. It makes me smile that, in general, the only people who say AC is essential are those that already have it. How would they know if they can live without it? Do a search on the forums like I did and the vast majority of owners WITHOUT AC say that they don't miss it at all. And besides not having AC makes mine the cheapest S in the country at the moment!!
No offence m1nky, but I'm sure you are aware that all people that have the AC have the option of turning it off when needed - which ultimately puts them in a position to comment on it, just as you are. I rarely drive mine with the A/C turned on, but boy am I glad on hot days when temperatures are close to 30°C and it's too hot to have the windows open. A/C is the only option then. Adding to that, the supercharger does generate additional heat that will be noticable in the cabine. If this is as relevant up there in cold Britain or not, that's up to the buyer to judge. I do know though that I'd be seriously buggered not to drive the car due to no A/C when the weather is extremely nice and sunny -> that's when the car is the most fun!

I applaud you for keeping the car as raw as possible though. wink