Profit Margin?
Discussion
Just interested to know how much profit margin do Lotus actually make on every new car sold? We all know that they use alot of parts from different manufactures so by the time they have paid them, how much would thay see from a brand new sale? This is something that has interested me for a while.
I suspect the answer goes something along the lines that they don't shift enough units to make a profit margin (that anyone would notice) on any of the production cars. I was under the impression that in recent years the engineering consultancy business has supported the rest of the group and the production cars are essentially the "shop window" for the consultancy business.
Either way - without the (less than healthy itself) Malaysian owners, who wrote off £30m of debt this year, Lotus might be edging towards the front of the queue to join the long list of Ex-great British motor manufacturers.
If any of this is bo**ox, I hope someone will correct me. Personally I wish I'm wrong.
Either way - without the (less than healthy itself) Malaysian owners, who wrote off £30m of debt this year, Lotus might be edging towards the front of the queue to join the long list of Ex-great British motor manufacturers.
If any of this is bo**ox, I hope someone will correct me. Personally I wish I'm wrong.
Lotus to blossom as owner gives fresh start
By John Griffiths
Financial Times, Mar 23, 2007
Group Lotus, the Norfolk-based sports car maker and engineering consultancy, is to be given "a completely fresh start" by its Malaysian owner after running up £40m in debts.
Proton, Malaysia's national car maker, which spent $80m on buying Lotus a decade ago, has already issued Lotus with an equivalent loan to pay off debts that had been run up with external lenders.
By John Griffiths
Financial Times, Mar 23, 2007
Group Lotus, the Norfolk-based sports car maker and engineering consultancy, is to be given "a completely fresh start" by its Malaysian owner after running up £40m in debts.
Proton, Malaysia's national car maker, which spent $80m on buying Lotus a decade ago, has already issued Lotus with an equivalent loan to pay off debts that had been run up with external lenders.
Lotus' finances are screwed basically, and the 'loan' from Proton is a last ditch effort to get it back on track by restructuring the debt (which IIRC was incurred in 2000 from a loan from Proton). If Kimberley's 5-year-plan doesn't start to show traction the whole lot will go under IMO.
http://business.edp24.co.uk/content/Guide/EngTech/...
02 April 2007
Malaysian car company Proton last night completed a financial restructuring of Group Lotus, wiping out debts of more than £60m.
The move is designed to strengthen the finances of the Norfolk based sports car manufacturer, which has just embarked on a new five year turnaround plan.
The plan, which is being overseen by chief executive Mike Kimberley, includes the launch of three new models and an expansion of its engineering division.
Earlier this year Group Lotus reported pre-tax losses of £17.7m for the year to the end of March 2006, up from £6.7m in 2005.
The losses grew despite the company selling a record number of cars, as the rising dollar squeezed margins on cars exported to the United States.
Lotus was left with £18m worth of unsold cars after a slowdown in sales in the US, forcing the company to cut production with the loss of 200 jobs at Hethel.
At the same time the company's engineering division saw turnover drop sharply following the loss of a major contract.
Proton, which acquired the Norfolk car maker a decade ago, had already provided the company with a £48.8m loan to cover debts run up with external lenders.
This loan is now being turned into equity in Group Lotus, effectively writing it off.
At the same time Proton has agreed to waive another £16.5m of debt which it is owed by Lotus.
In a statement issued to the Malaysian stock market last week, Proton said the measures being taken were part of its commitment to Group Lotus. Proton said the moves were part of the Lotus business turnaround plan and would considerably strengthen the financial position of Group Lotus, which has about 1,100 staff.
Mr Kimberley said: “This recapitalisation is very important for us.
“It is a vote of confidence in us by our owner Proton and will allow us to work on the five year plan.
“But at the same time we have to perform to the business plan going forward and that means commitment from everyone going forward.”
The business plan includes the launch of new mid-range car codenamed the Eagle, and a replacement for the Esprit, as well as a high performance variant of a Proton car.
Group Lotus is also building up its engineering business, with the signing of a major contract with Chinese automotive group Youngman earlier this week.
Lotus is looking to grow its operations in China, and is also planning to open an engineering office in India, as well as working on new technologies such as hybrid engines.
The third leg of the five year strategy is third party manufacturing. Lotus is currently talking to three companies about building their vehicles at Hethel.
As well as contract building for other manufacturers, the company is also looking to develop high-performance variants of production-based models for major automotive groups in the tradition of the Lotus Carlton and the Ford Lotus Cortina.The message is clear. Currently the business is (and has been) losing money hand-over-fist on manufacturing and sales, with over production and unsold stock needing to be shifted asap.
Diversification and expansion of non-Lotus manufacturing is high on the agenda and partnerships with other companies looks certain to form the backbone of any revival, with some hopes pinned on the 2+2 and Esprit to revive interest in core sales.
CHRIS STARKIE EDP BUSINESS EDITOR said:
http://business.edp24.co.uk/content/Guide/EngTech/...
02 April 2007
Malaysian car company Proton last night completed a financial restructuring of Group Lotus, wiping out debts of more than £60m.
The move is designed to strengthen the finances of the Norfolk based sports car manufacturer, which has just embarked on a new five year turnaround plan.
The plan, which is being overseen by chief executive Mike Kimberley, includes the launch of three new models and an expansion of its engineering division.
Earlier this year Group Lotus reported pre-tax losses of £17.7m for the year to the end of March 2006, up from £6.7m in 2005.
The losses grew despite the company selling a record number of cars, as the rising dollar squeezed margins on cars exported to the United States.
Lotus was left with £18m worth of unsold cars after a slowdown in sales in the US, forcing the company to cut production with the loss of 200 jobs at Hethel.
At the same time the company's engineering division saw turnover drop sharply following the loss of a major contract.
Proton, which acquired the Norfolk car maker a decade ago, had already provided the company with a £48.8m loan to cover debts run up with external lenders.
This loan is now being turned into equity in Group Lotus, effectively writing it off.
At the same time Proton has agreed to waive another £16.5m of debt which it is owed by Lotus.
In a statement issued to the Malaysian stock market last week, Proton said the measures being taken were part of its commitment to Group Lotus. Proton said the moves were part of the Lotus business turnaround plan and would considerably strengthen the financial position of Group Lotus, which has about 1,100 staff.
Mr Kimberley said: “This recapitalisation is very important for us.
“It is a vote of confidence in us by our owner Proton and will allow us to work on the five year plan.
“But at the same time we have to perform to the business plan going forward and that means commitment from everyone going forward.”
The business plan includes the launch of new mid-range car codenamed the Eagle, and a replacement for the Esprit, as well as a high performance variant of a Proton car.
Group Lotus is also building up its engineering business, with the signing of a major contract with Chinese automotive group Youngman earlier this week.
Lotus is looking to grow its operations in China, and is also planning to open an engineering office in India, as well as working on new technologies such as hybrid engines.
The third leg of the five year strategy is third party manufacturing. Lotus is currently talking to three companies about building their vehicles at Hethel.
As well as contract building for other manufacturers, the company is also looking to develop high-performance variants of production-based models for major automotive groups in the tradition of the Lotus Carlton and the Ford Lotus Cortina.
Diversification and expansion of non-Lotus manufacturing is high on the agenda and partnerships with other companies looks certain to form the backbone of any revival, with some hopes pinned on the 2+2 and Esprit to revive interest in core sales.
Edited by S Works on Wednesday 11th July 10:37
The SMMT produce and publish figures for vehicle sales each month for UK (which I guess is probably Lotus's biggest market).
In June 07 Lotus sold 97 cars making a total for 2007 of 376.
In June 06 Lotus sold 61, but the total to June 06 was 473 sold.
So they're currently 20% down on UK sales compared to last year.
In June 07 Lotus sold 97 cars making a total for 2007 of 376.
In June 06 Lotus sold 61, but the total to June 06 was 473 sold.
So they're currently 20% down on UK sales compared to last year.
I guess the answer is that their investors (in the case of Ford and GM pension funds) believe that the situation will turn around; losses will become profits the value of their investment will rise - but, as in most things the first cut is the cheapest and the longer the investors hold on, the more the investors will lose I suspect.
In this case the investor is Proton, a motor manufacturer who isn't in great shape themselves and while Kyle is right £40m accumulated losses over a five year period or so isn't a huge amount in this business its just another issue that Proton don't need.
There are plenty of firms that dont make much profit (or even continue trading with losses for ages) that keep trading because of their strong cashflows. Sales = cashflow and a 20% y-o-y fall isn't great, its worrying!
In this case the investor is Proton, a motor manufacturer who isn't in great shape themselves and while Kyle is right £40m accumulated losses over a five year period or so isn't a huge amount in this business its just another issue that Proton don't need.
There are plenty of firms that dont make much profit (or even continue trading with losses for ages) that keep trading because of their strong cashflows. Sales = cashflow and a 20% y-o-y fall isn't great, its worrying!
subaqua said:
A lot of really good stuff...
Dont forget that proton get loads of intangible benefits. Lotus expertise, and being associated with such a great name brings them above the "white goods" association. Also when the full product line is realised and Lotus get seriously back into the business of producing cars, they will be VERY Saleable. At the moment they are a 1 horse trick, although a VERY GOOD 1 horse trick. They will have a 3-4 car line up (Not 1 chassis, 2 variants)The big problem is there is very little will in the investment houses (pension funds) for such a long term, low yield investment and Protron writing off debts is far from serious investment in getting the new product lines functioning and selling. Is the old rumour of a VAG purchase the kick in the arse Lotus needs? I hope not, I dont like VW style cars and the veyron though technically marvelous would appeal to me if it had a bit more character.
Additionally 40mil is a drop in the ocean for a company the size of Ford/GM, and could pretty easily be brought back with healthy sales of a new model. They also have greater diversity across their portfolios already which means they can trim down to focus on areas where they know they can sell, and can react to market forces more quickly as a result (see how they are canning SUV's and moving towards smaller, more efficient models to put into the US market).
Lotus simply don't have the backing or resources to do that. They are reliant on their (albeit successful) one-trick-pony (the Elise platform) for all production and sales at the moment. It would appear that this will be modified to accommodate the Eagle project, but the significant developments required for a brand new model (Esprit) are proving much more challenging and frankly, Lotus have failed so far (hence Kimberley unceremoniously chucking it back to the drawing board).
Proton and Lotus are to my mind, unlikely and unsuitable bedfellows in the longer term. For Lotus to survive it needs to either be leaner and to expand it's consultancy arm as it's core business (and retain the manufacturing arm as a niche business), or to find a bigger, better, more suitable parent who can push Lotus as it's premium brand within a larger group. Only then will it attract the levels of investment that it needs to really take on the likes of Porsche at their own game.
Lotus simply don't have the backing or resources to do that. They are reliant on their (albeit successful) one-trick-pony (the Elise platform) for all production and sales at the moment. It would appear that this will be modified to accommodate the Eagle project, but the significant developments required for a brand new model (Esprit) are proving much more challenging and frankly, Lotus have failed so far (hence Kimberley unceremoniously chucking it back to the drawing board).
Proton and Lotus are to my mind, unlikely and unsuitable bedfellows in the longer term. For Lotus to survive it needs to either be leaner and to expand it's consultancy arm as it's core business (and retain the manufacturing arm as a niche business), or to find a bigger, better, more suitable parent who can push Lotus as it's premium brand within a larger group. Only then will it attract the levels of investment that it needs to really take on the likes of Porsche at their own game.
S Works said:
Additionally 40mil is a drop in the ocean for a company the size of Ford/GM, and could pretty easily be brought back with healthy sales of a new model. They also have greater diversity across their portfolios already which means they can trim down to focus on areas where they know they can sell, and can react to market forces more quickly as a result (see how they are canning SUV's and moving towards smaller, more efficient models to put into the US market).
Lotus simply don't have the backing or resources to do that. They are reliant on their (albeit successful) one-trick-pony (the Elise platform) for all production and sales at the moment. It would appear that this will be modified to accommodate the Eagle project, but the significant developments required for a brand new model (Esprit) are proving much more challenging and frankly, Lotus have failed so far (hence Kimberley unceremoniously chucking it back to the drawing board).
Proton and Lotus are to my mind, unlikely and unsuitable bedfellows in the longer term. For Lotus to survive it needs to either be leaner and to expand it's consultancy arm as it's core business (and retain the manufacturing arm as a niche business), or to find a bigger, better, more suitable parent who can push Lotus as it's premium brand within a larger group. Only then will it attract the levels of investment that it needs to really take on the likes of Porsche at their own game.
I think Lotus have developed the chassis for the eagle using the same technology used to build the Elise? I think it's going to be re-designed from the ground up but uses the same technique of extruded units of aluminium bonded together to give strength with lightness? The car's already built and has been for a very long timeLotus simply don't have the backing or resources to do that. They are reliant on their (albeit successful) one-trick-pony (the Elise platform) for all production and sales at the moment. It would appear that this will be modified to accommodate the Eagle project, but the significant developments required for a brand new model (Esprit) are proving much more challenging and frankly, Lotus have failed so far (hence Kimberley unceremoniously chucking it back to the drawing board).
Proton and Lotus are to my mind, unlikely and unsuitable bedfellows in the longer term. For Lotus to survive it needs to either be leaner and to expand it's consultancy arm as it's core business (and retain the manufacturing arm as a niche business), or to find a bigger, better, more suitable parent who can push Lotus as it's premium brand within a larger group. Only then will it attract the levels of investment that it needs to really take on the likes of Porsche at their own game.

Boggy
Edited by Boggy on Wednesday 11th July 16:03
Boggy said:
S Works said:
Additionally 40mil is a drop in the ocean for a company the size of Ford/GM, and could pretty easily be brought back with healthy sales of a new model. They also have greater diversity across their portfolios already which means they can trim down to focus on areas where they know they can sell, and can react to market forces more quickly as a result (see how they are canning SUV's and moving towards smaller, more efficient models to put into the US market).
Lotus simply don't have the backing or resources to do that. They are reliant on their (albeit successful) one-trick-pony (the Elise platform) for all production and sales at the moment. It would appear that this will be modified to accommodate the Eagle project, but the significant developments required for a brand new model (Esprit) are proving much more challenging and frankly, Lotus have failed so far (hence Kimberley unceremoniously chucking it back to the drawing board).
Proton and Lotus are to my mind, unlikely and unsuitable bedfellows in the longer term. For Lotus to survive it needs to either be leaner and to expand it's consultancy arm as it's core business (and retain the manufacturing arm as a niche business), or to find a bigger, better, more suitable parent who can push Lotus as it's premium brand within a larger group. Only then will it attract the levels of investment that it needs to really take on the likes of Porsche at their own game.
I think Lotus have developed the chassis for the eagle using the same technology used to build the Elise? I think it's going to be re-designed from the ground up but uses the same technique of extruded units of aluminium bonded together to give strength with lightness? The car's already built and has been for a very long timeLotus simply don't have the backing or resources to do that. They are reliant on their (albeit successful) one-trick-pony (the Elise platform) for all production and sales at the moment. It would appear that this will be modified to accommodate the Eagle project, but the significant developments required for a brand new model (Esprit) are proving much more challenging and frankly, Lotus have failed so far (hence Kimberley unceremoniously chucking it back to the drawing board).
Proton and Lotus are to my mind, unlikely and unsuitable bedfellows in the longer term. For Lotus to survive it needs to either be leaner and to expand it's consultancy arm as it's core business (and retain the manufacturing arm as a niche business), or to find a bigger, better, more suitable parent who can push Lotus as it's premium brand within a larger group. Only then will it attract the levels of investment that it needs to really take on the likes of Porsche at their own game.

Boggy
If it's not the M250 with a few bits redesigned I'll eat my shorts. All I can say is that it had better be good, because if it's not (and they bodge it like they did the Europa) I can see it causing huge problems. It's probably going to be the most important car in Lotus' recent history, because if they get it right, the Esprit project will probably continue to market. If they get it wrong...
I really, really hope it's a winner, god knows it's needed to give the brand and all the enthusiasts a lift.
Edited by S Works on Wednesday 11th July 16:52
S Works said:
Boggy said:
S Works said:
Additionally 40mil is a drop in the ocean for a company the size of Ford/GM, and could pretty easily be brought back with healthy sales of a new model. They also have greater diversity across their portfolios already which means they can trim down to focus on areas where they know they can sell, and can react to market forces more quickly as a result (see how they are canning SUV's and moving towards smaller, more efficient models to put into the US market).
Lotus simply don't have the backing or resources to do that. They are reliant on their (albeit successful) one-trick-pony (the Elise platform) for all production and sales at the moment. It would appear that this will be modified to accommodate the Eagle project, but the significant developments required for a brand new model (Esprit) are proving much more challenging and frankly, Lotus have failed so far (hence Kimberley unceremoniously chucking it back to the drawing board).
Proton and Lotus are to my mind, unlikely and unsuitable bedfellows in the longer term. For Lotus to survive it needs to either be leaner and to expand it's consultancy arm as it's core business (and retain the manufacturing arm as a niche business), or to find a bigger, better, more suitable parent who can push Lotus as it's premium brand within a larger group. Only then will it attract the levels of investment that it needs to really take on the likes of Porsche at their own game.
I think Lotus have developed the chassis for the eagle using the same technology used to build the Elise? I think it's going to be re-designed from the ground up but uses the same technique of extruded units of aluminium bonded together to give strength with lightness? The car's already built and has been for a very long timeLotus simply don't have the backing or resources to do that. They are reliant on their (albeit successful) one-trick-pony (the Elise platform) for all production and sales at the moment. It would appear that this will be modified to accommodate the Eagle project, but the significant developments required for a brand new model (Esprit) are proving much more challenging and frankly, Lotus have failed so far (hence Kimberley unceremoniously chucking it back to the drawing board).
Proton and Lotus are to my mind, unlikely and unsuitable bedfellows in the longer term. For Lotus to survive it needs to either be leaner and to expand it's consultancy arm as it's core business (and retain the manufacturing arm as a niche business), or to find a bigger, better, more suitable parent who can push Lotus as it's premium brand within a larger group. Only then will it attract the levels of investment that it needs to really take on the likes of Porsche at their own game.

Boggy
If it's not the M250 with a few bits redesigned I'll eat my shorts. All I can say is that it had better be good, because if it's not (and they bodge it like they did the Europa) I can see it causing huge problems. It's probably going to be the most important car in Lotus' recent history, because if they get it right, the Esprit project will probably continue to market. If they get it wrong...
I really, really hope it's a winner, god knows it's needed to give the brand and all the enthusiasts a lift.
Edited by S Works on Wednesday 11th July 16:52
Boggy
Lawrence5 said:
For a manufacturer like Lotus sales price should be 3 times the Bill of Material.
Out of that comes all your overheads and some profit for reinvestment - lol
Higher than 3 times I would have thought, probably nearer 15 - 20 times.... Total sale price of each car would be 5 - 8 times that of total production cost...Out of that comes all your overheads and some profit for reinvestment - lol
In a previous life our total production target cost was $1500 for a vehicle that would sell for £16,000...
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




