s1 for the weekend?
Author
Discussion

MW666

Original Poster:

64 posts

255 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
Owned high specced new S2's in the past - am about to be able to contemplate elise ownership again. I was looking again at new s2 - sportsracers etc.
The car would mainly be used for dry weather country road blasts and the very occasional european run - It occured to me that I would have just as much fun in a nice s1? - any view's on this - will i get the same enjoyment for a 10k discount?
The only thing that concerns me is build quality probs, lots of rattles and niggles etc - did these get better with the later models? is there anything to worry about?

Altrezia

8,742 posts

242 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
S1 is more hardcore, so for a weekend toy, it's what I'd choose.

MW666

Original Poster:

64 posts

255 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
is that what you own? - the shape is really classic. how do you find the ownership experience as opposed to the driving experience?

Also - are they all a great drive or should you really look for thew special -111s / 160 sport etc?

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
I bought a boggo '99 S1 in October 05 with the intention of seeing how I got on with the Elise thing and then trading up to a newer/faster car. Never bothered to trade up as I fallen for my little S1 - its got right under my skin. I've put over 20k on the clock and love the rawness and essential 'rightness' of the S1. In its time with me the car has been completely reliable and in due course I'll be upgrading the suspension and adding a bit of power. Just because its relatively cheap doesn't mean its not fun. Whenever I've been tempted by a newer model I ask myself if it will give me more fun. Inevitably the answer is 'No'.

Altrezia

8,742 posts

242 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
Sorry, forgot to reply to this thread.

Yes, mine is an S1. It's great. The only downside is how hard it is to get into, but the S2's suffer from this too. Go and drive one, then you'll just have to get one!

MW666

Original Poster:

64 posts

255 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
looking around on the net for info on s1/160's On the net and found the following: Any of you recognise any symptoms? or do you think they would have been dealt with by now?


collection the edge of the boot lid had been scuffed down to the fiberglass after coming into contact with the bodywork opposite the corner of the boot lid. Obviously owing to bad quality control at the factory and the receiving dealership.

Boot lid catch sticks open and has to be pushed back into place.

Since 2000 miles: Knocking front suspension over bumps, becoming worse with time. Now the rear suspension knocks as well. The service department insists that they can find nothing wrong.

Headlamp button failed to stay pushed in. Had to drive around for two evenings with one hand on the button.

General comments?
Roof leaks: Regardless of how you fit the soft top or the hard top, water flows easily into the cabin and gathers in pools just inside either door. Don't even think about going near the car with a jet wash.

After rain, a couple of pints of water gather in the radiator well. Once above 60 MPH this water is ejected onto the windscreen and completely obscures vision for long enough for it to be dangerous.

Rear alloy panel under the car has become loose after the fixing on one corner broke away from some weakened fiberglass.

General build quality: Atrocious. All over the car (inside and out) are hard-to-locate squeaks, rattles, buzzes, knocks and bumps. On any normal car, a single persistent squeak or rattle would be a nuisance and require investigation, but on the Elise it's something that you just have to accept. All these noises magically disappear when the car is test driven by the service department.

Noise: With the roof off it's almost bearable. But that's only relative to what it's like with the roof on. The hard top is worst, the soft top is not much better. After long journeys my ears ring for several hours. Don't bother with a stereo because the combination of poor acoustics (alloy interior) and massive engine noise will be too much for it. The noise could be forgiven if it sounded like a TVR (for example), but it doesn't. It's just noise and there's lots of it.

Any of you recognise any symptoms? or do you think they would have been dealt with by now?

Porlock

386 posts

244 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
Sounds O.K. to me!!

If you want comfort get a boring saloon, the cars about the driving experience, not creature comforts. My soft top seems more water proof than my hardtop. Suspension rattles, Yes So? Radio Reception patchy, use the CD ! My advice go get one, you will rediscover the Joy of Motoring, Nothing beats it especially on a sunny day. permanent smile and messy hair.

Dave

GKP

15,099 posts

272 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
The symptoms described above make me think the chap should've purchased a Micra convertible. He'd be a lot happier.

MW666

Original Poster:

64 posts

255 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
don't want to get off the point - as i have already had s2's I am aware of elise ownership - what i was trying to figure out is if the s1 was a significant level below in terms of build quality and painless ownership. My previous car was great and I didn't find it uch of a comprimise - what I don't want is to move to an s1 and find it needing lots of work and anoying traits - squeaks, rattles, leaks - or are these just part of the experience?

When lotus developed the vx200 - did vaxhall's developement money find it's way into the quality of later s1's 99/00 m.y's? - or did any improvements come with the s2's

Owners seem passionate about their s1's so they must be special? -

Esprit

6,373 posts

314 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
MW666 said:
looking around on the net for info on s1/160's On the net and found the following: Any of you recognise any symptoms? or do you think they would have been dealt with by now?


collection the edge of the boot lid had been scuffed down to the fiberglass after coming into contact with the bodywork opposite the corner of the boot lid. Obviously owing to bad quality control at the factory and the receiving dealership.

Boot lid catch sticks open and has to be pushed back into place.

Since 2000 miles: Knocking front suspension over bumps, becoming worse with time. Now the rear suspension knocks as well. The service department insists that they can find nothing wrong.

Headlamp button failed to stay pushed in. Had to drive around for two evenings with one hand on the button.

General comments?
Roof leaks: Regardless of how you fit the soft top or the hard top, water flows easily into the cabin and gathers in pools just inside either door. Don't even think about going near the car with a jet wash.

After rain, a couple of pints of water gather in the radiator well. Once above 60 MPH this water is ejected onto the windscreen and completely obscures vision for long enough for it to be dangerous.

Rear alloy panel under the car has become loose after the fixing on one corner broke away from some weakened fiberglass.

General build quality: Atrocious. All over the car (inside and out) are hard-to-locate squeaks, rattles, buzzes, knocks and bumps. On any normal car, a single persistent squeak or rattle would be a nuisance and require investigation, but on the Elise it's something that you just have to accept. All these noises magically disappear when the car is test driven by the service department.

Noise: With the roof off it's almost bearable. But that's only relative to what it's like with the roof on. The hard top is worst, the soft top is not much better. After long journeys my ears ring for several hours. Don't bother with a stereo because the combination of poor acoustics (alloy interior) and massive engine noise will be too much for it. The noise could be forgiven if it sounded like a TVR (for example), but it doesn't. It's just noise and there's lots of it.

Any of you recognise any symptoms? or do you think they would have been dealt with by now?
Sounds like someone that would be better off in an MX5 or poncing about in a Boxter/TT etc.. the car was designed as a weekend track racer, nothing more... it was launched with just enough in the way of :creature comforts" to get you to and from the track with your helmet in the boot and a makeshift roof in case it rains... the fact that people have bought it and expected it to be a comfortable, rattle-free, mile-minching touring convertible is not the fault of the car... The Elise HAS evolved into more of a touring car in later versions, but any S1 is not far removed from the original concept.

It's funny how people level such criticisms at the Elise, yet they don't seem to with things like Caterhams etc.... that's because people KNOW that a Caterham is ONLY a toy and isn't intended to be anything serious. They should remember that the Elise was designed to be a modern player in the Caterham sector... that people expect it to be a touring car as well just shows how the Elise has done well enough to fool some people into thinking of it that way.

If you're looking for fun, the Elise has it in spades. If you're looking for comfort and refinement, please shop elsewhere and leave the Elise for those of us who appreciate it for what it is.... driving distilled smile

Personally, I think if you're just going to use it as a weekend fun car, the S1 is the better bet dynamically... as for styling, it's up to you smile Personally, I don't see any need for anything other than an S1, it suits my need perfectly. It's not my daily driver, but could be if I wanted it to be (don't see the point of putting mundane miles on such a rare car... I'm in NZ remember and they're rocking horse sh1te over here) and it looks better (IMO). I've been in many S2s and while they all feel more complete than the S1, they fail to light my wick as much. If the S1 didn't exist, I'd have an S2 (or any variant thereof) in an instant... but it does, so I don't smile

Edited by Esprit on Sunday 15th July 10:07

Skyman

1,663 posts

255 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
My last "weekend" cars were a 111R and then Exige S. My new car is a seven year old S1 111S. There will not be another car. Enough said.

Edited by Skyman on Sunday 15th July 10:18

MW666

Original Poster:

64 posts

255 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
skyman - what do you think you lost and also gained by moving to the older car?

Skyman

1,663 posts

255 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
MW666 said:
skyman - what do you think you lost and also gained by moving to the older car?
My S1 does not actually arrive for another four weeks (holidays are getting in the way). However, from my experience of S2 ownership, S1 test drives and just the sheer joy that my new car gives me simply by looking at it (just take a look at the picture in my profile to see what I mean) -

Lost - S2 civility, better overall build quality, weight
Gained - S1 rawness, better design (IMHO, and nothing against the S2, just the S1 is so pure), less weight, and a much bigger smile

lamb jiblets

338 posts

245 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
S1 love it, better looking and more fun,a real case of "less is more" bow

Tango7

694 posts

257 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
I have just got rid of my bog standard S1 Elise and pretty much regretted it straightaway! I drive Caterhams and have an R400 at the moment and this offers tremendous fun and performance. However, the little S1 could give similar smiles on the road (not sure on the track at all but really don't expect it to match the Caterham unless its raining...).

Big negative for me was water leaks into the cabin when the car was parked up. I thought I had sorted it but the puddles would returnfrown It was the same with either the hard top or the soft top if parked for a while. Interesting the point about an Elise being a tourer and if you wanted this type of car, you should be buying a tintop. Compared to the Caterham, the S1 made an excellent tourer with its fuel range, performance and comfort as we took both cars down to France with the kids. 40 mpg and over 300 miles on a tank makes a massive difference to the Caterham!

The suspension did crash and bang a bit but could be rectified by fitting the S2 suspension. Otherwise it was a brilliant car and I sold it with a view to getting a 111S but the prices start to rise with the summer so it will have to wait.

fatboy111

308 posts

248 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
Very similar situation to me...

I had a S2, bought brand new on 2005. Loved it. Never went wrong and I thought it was fantastically well put together. But...
I've always wanted an Elise since launch, so inevitably that meant I had to get an S1 at some point. Sold the S2, and stated the search. Tried looking for a 111S or S160, but the 160's I saw were scruffy...finally got a '99 111S with 11k in May.

I've now done about 2k miles in it, with 2 trips to the Lakes, including this weekend with all the weather! It really is superb. The suspension is crashier than the S2 (and I think mines a good one too), but the difference isn't huge. The sound levels as a whole are higher / harsher which is somewhat of a drag on the M6, but adds to the raw experience on a country road. Does mean I didn't get to listen to my newe Interpol CD all weekend though! Mine doesnt seem to leak either, which is a bonus.

So, I got to thinking about an S2 Exige this weekend in the comfort of the hotel bar: would I get 20k's worth further enjoment / fun / ownership pride over the 111S: no. For me, I couldn't be parted, it's a performance car bargain, and a classic to boot!

Skyman

1,663 posts

255 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
fatboy111 said:
Very similar situation to me...

I had a S2, bought brand new on 2005. Loved it. Never went wrong and I thought it was fantastically well put together. But...
I've always wanted an Elise since launch, so inevitably that meant I had to get an S1 at some point. Sold the S2, and stated the search. Tried looking for a 111S or S160, but the 160's I saw were scruffy...finally got a '99 111S with 11k in May.

I've now done about 2k miles in it, with 2 trips to the Lakes, including this weekend with all the weather! It really is superb. The suspension is crashier than the S2 (and I think mines a good one too), but the difference isn't huge. The sound levels as a whole are higher / harsher which is somewhat of a drag on the M6, but adds to the raw experience on a country road. Does mean I didn't get to listen to my newe Interpol CD all weekend though! Mine doesnt seem to leak either, which is a bonus.

So, I got to thinking about an S2 Exige this weekend in the comfort of the hotel bar: would I get 20k's worth further enjoment / fun / ownership pride over the 111S: no. For me, I couldn't be parted, it's a performance car bargain, and a classic to boot!
Well said that man.clap

MW666

Original Poster:

64 posts

255 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
the leaking roof's seem to be a common complaint - this is the first thread where someone has said differently - and if you were driving in this weekends weather without problem, you can be fairly sure it will remain leak proof - have there been any solutions developed in the last few years?

fatboy111

308 posts

248 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
I don't think there is a mod to 'cure' the roof as such, and I don't think I'm the only S1 owner not to have a swimming pool in my floorwells in bad weather...make sure the roof is aligned properly when putting up, and ensure the windows rise to the tops as they should: I believe they can drop, but can be re-positioned / re-aligned.

Also ensure the floor pan has been checked by a Lotus dealer...

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
my S1 doesnt leak at all.

using the soft top at the moment but picking up my lotus factory hardtop a week tomorrow so from what ive read I may have a leaking roof with the hardtop if I dont get the specialist to change the angle of the windows (small scre im told, no big job)

either way it doesnt bother me one bit, for me it was S1 all the way, not a question of price more the fact that ive always wanted a S1 elise with its true lightweight no messing about, no electrics real sports car ethos.

might upgrade to a exige for the winter, but again it will be the S1 and NOT the S2 as the S1 seems to me to be the one to buy and experience propperly rather than the slightly overwieght, more to go wrong S2.