S1 Exige vs S2 Elise??
S1 Exige vs S2 Elise??
Author
Discussion

robm3

Original Poster:

4,930 posts

258 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
Thinking pretty seriously about a resting the CSL from trackday work (it's my regular drive as well, 150miles per day) and now going to get a S2 Elise but then I saw that Exige's are getting down to 17K'ish which sounds tempting.
I would use the car for sunny weekend blasts ("Off to the shops to get some Widgets Honey&quotwink and about 6 track days per year plus Nurburgring but, is a S1 Exige really 4K better than an S2 Elise??
Has anyone driven both?

Esprit

6,373 posts

314 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
Chalk and cheese mate is all I can say...

If you're thinking of using the Exige in summer at ALL (certainly if you're thinking about using it to pop down the shops!) then you'll need one with aircon.

The S2 is a genuine everyday prospect, probably quicker on the road than an Exige (unless you're really committed) and while not as quick on the track, for 6 trackdays a year probably not worth the extra outlay.

I've just bought an S1 Exige (from an S1 Elise) but that's because I've always had a love-affair with the Exige and it's going to be a pure weekend toy for me.

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
the way i see it S1 is a lotus, S2 is a proton designed by lotus.

that aside I couldnt care less what badge is on my car or who owned the company whos badge is on it (i once owned a reliant! a 350 bhp 5 ltr V8reliant never the less but still badged as original)

me personally, I'd have a S1 over an S2 any day.

the S1 is the classic iconic full fat elise, the S2 was to cater for the wider market.

but try them both, i use my s1 elise as a daily hack, get called all kinds of names by the lads too. . . . . .

most of them would fit the S2 bracket, a few would buy the S2, try a S1 and sell the S2 for a S1, the rest would not mess around and just get the S1 and be done with it.

depends what way you swing really.

robm3

Original Poster:

4,930 posts

258 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
DucatiGary said:
the way i see it S1 is a lotus, S2 is a proton designed by lotus.

that aside I couldnt care less what badge is on my car or who owned the company whos badge is on it (i once owned a reliant! a 350 bhp 5 ltr V8reliant never the less but still badged as original)

me personally, I'd have a S1 over an S2 any day.

the S1 is the classic iconic full fat elise, the S2 was to cater for the wider market.

but try them both, i use my s1 elise as a daily hack, get called all kinds of names by the lads too. . . . . .

most of them would fit the S2 bracket, a few would buy the S2, try a S1 and sell the S2 for a S1, the rest would not mess around and just get the S1 and be done with it.

depends what way you swing really.
I'd never really thought about what people would think just after what would suit best. Personally I prefer the looks of the S2 but just wondered about it on the track vs an S1 Exige as prices are pretty close.
Like all things I need to drive both methinks and I've seen one (Exige) at SPA AUTO CENTRE which is quite close for 17K so will check it out.

Also I think the Exige may become a future 'classic' so values should hold well whereas a 17K S2 will probably decline faster.
After I drive the Exige will no doubt have many more questions so will repost then....

robm3

Original Poster:

4,930 posts

258 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
Esprit said:
The S2 is a genuine everyday prospect, probably quicker on the road than an Exige (unless you're really committed).
Yeah, I wonder if the Exige would be more 'fun' even though slower on the road due to noise, nervousness, edgy response etc...

jke11y

3,200 posts

268 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
robm3 said:
Like all things I need to drive both methinks and I've seen one (Exige) at SPA AUTO CENTRE which is quite close for 17K so will check it out.

After I drive the Exige will no doubt have many more questions so will repost then....
Not that one you wont, as its been mine since Saturday biggrin

I have owned in the last 3 months an S2 Exige, S2 Elise and now the S1 Exige - the S1 is awesome. Feels way more like a mini racer than the S2 Exige, and I only had the S2 Elise for 6 weeks as I really didnt like it after the Exige.


fatboy111

308 posts

248 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
Er, let me think about this for a second....HELLO, S1 EXIGE!!!

crackthatoff

3,314 posts

244 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
get a 135R! apparently ( not that i've tracked mine yet) is as close as you can get to the exige with but with a soft top.. And of course less power !
Check out the specs and see what you think !

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
Has to be the S1 Exige everytime, no contest at all......cloud9

robm3

Original Poster:

4,930 posts

258 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
jke11y said:
robm3 said:
Like all things I need to drive both methinks and I've seen one (Exige) at SPA AUTO CENTRE which is quite close for 17K so will check it out.

After I drive the Exige will no doubt have many more questions so will repost then....
Not that one you wont, as its been mine since Saturday biggrin

I have owned in the last 3 months an S2 Exige, S2 Elise and now the S1 Exige - the S1 is awesome. Feels way more like a mini racer than the S2 Exige, and I only had the S2 Elise for 6 weeks as I really didnt like it after the Exige.
~Bloody Hell, rang em today and they said it was sold and here you are with it!
You're not allowed so many, rules say you gotta share!

I'm wondering if a S1 Exige would be faster round say Silverstone than my CSL?? I suspect it would be slower however with a little fettling it should be quicker....

edp190

336 posts

240 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
It depends on the exige! My one would leave a CSL for dust! Wanna buy it?! wink


Edited by edp190 on Wednesday 18th July 23:41

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
You have to drive both, think about the engine (VHPD is a bomb looking for a place to go off), and how much you're prepared to spend on it.

The S1 is the raw, iconic, road-racer, and to me is everything a Lotus should be. The engine is the only weakpoint, but if it's properly maintained and refreshed at the appropriate times, will be a very fun prospect. If it blows up, you can always Honda/Audi it and have a very, very quick car.

The S2's are better put together but I found the suspension to be lacking, the brakes to be average, and the engine to be too Jeckyll & Hyde with the NA regular ECU program. The later revision to bring the cam-change down is a good option and makes it less mentally top endy. The S is a better bet, the 240R even better still, but then you're heading into the upper £20's and £30 k's.

£ for £ if you can find a sorted S2, with Aircon and Sportspack which has had the ECU reflash, then it'll probably be the better long-term bet.

The S1 will be the one for the collectors though.

robm3

Original Poster:

4,930 posts

258 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
edp190 said:
It depends on the exige! My one would leave a CSL for dust! Wanna buy it?! wink


Edited by edp190 on Wednesday 18th July 23:41
Could do, any pics? email me at robin_ellard@hotmail.com cheers wink

robm3

Original Poster:

4,930 posts

258 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
You have to drive both, think about the engine (VHPD is a bomb looking for a place to go off), and how much you're prepared to spend on it.

The S1 is the raw, iconic, road-racer, and to me is everything a Lotus should be. The engine is the only weakpoint, but if it's properly maintained and refreshed at the appropriate times, will be a very fun prospect. If it blows up, you can always Honda/Audi it and have a very, very quick car.

The S2's are better put together but I found the suspension to be lacking, the brakes to be average, and the engine to be too Jeckyll & Hyde with the NA regular ECU program. The later revision to bring the cam-change down is a good option and makes it less mentally top endy. The S is a better bet, the 240R even better still, but then you're heading into the upper £20's and £30 k's.

£ for £ if you can find a sorted S2, with Aircon and Sportspack which has had the ECU reflash, then it'll probably be the better long-term bet.

The S1 will be the one for the collectors though.
Perversly I don't fancy a S2 Exige as I prefer the looks of an S1 however the situation is reversed for the Elise...
Agreed I reckon a S1 will be a collectors item, didn't they only get manufactored for a year or so?? (how many built??) but not sure how an engine change will effect that. Ideally you'd keep the original engine transmission for insertion at a later date e.g. 20years..

edp190

336 posts

240 months

robm3

Original Poster:

4,930 posts

258 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
edp190 said:
Ah, as lovely as it is I can't stretch to that amount although I'd be the first to admit it would kill my CSL (but that's more than a 'little' fettling).

edp190

336 posts

240 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
Shame! Good luck with the search! You wont regret it!

renmure

4,952 posts

255 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
S2 elise or S1 exige ??? Hmmmm. get one of each.
Only kidding cause only a Silly Billy would do that.
But, speaking as a Silly Billy... I would go for the S1 exige. It is just more special.

999

402 posts

243 months

Friday 20th July 2007
quotequote all
crackthatoff said:
get a 135R! apparently is as close as you can get to the exige with but with a soft top..
Nah, surely a Sports Racer is closer than the 135, even if you only take into account the suspension enhanchments over the standard Elise, never mind the twin oil coolers etc. (oh, and the stripes make them a lot faster too...smile )

Chris.

Twinpipe

1,396 posts

260 months

Friday 20th July 2007
quotequote all
Exige