S2 std, 135 or 111s choice.
S2 std, 135 or 111s choice.
Author
Discussion

71mb0

Original Poster:

6 posts

232 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
Hi,

am new to Elise's and this forum, have done a little research about all the various models etc and on paper I know the differences between them but I am after some impressions from those of you that know.

Ideally it seems the 111s is the best choice but searching for second hand examples of each I see a great number of Std S2's with the 135 upgrade pack for a few ££££ less. Also certain FAQ's list this as more like 145bhp.

I know even a std S2 is a quick beast but on the road, are the 0-60, 20-40 times of the std (or 135 for that matter) that different so as to take the edge off?

Reason for asking all this is that a good 111s is likely to be near the top end of what I can go for. If I could save a few K and get a good std S2 or ideally a S2 135 then that may be an option. I just don't want to be driving round an a years time wishing I'd plumped for the 111s cause it's soo much better.

I will be changing up from a std Impreza Turbo to give you an idea of where I will be getting my benchmark from.

Is the Exhaust mod on the S2 -> 135 upgrade a louder one? Do they sound sweet?

Many Thanks.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
Most cars have aftermarket exhausts that sound far better then the stock item (but can be tiring on long drives).

The 111S is the best all-rounder. Standard ones have short-ratio gearboxes so can feel almost as quick up to legal speeds. 135 conversions quicker still but both are more tiring on long motorway journeys (111S is only around 3,200 revs at 70, standard S2s and 135s nearer 4K) plus they don't have as much comfort kit, which is all down to preference and use.

Then there is the 135R which is a track special with harder suspension and A048 tyres, possibly the best track-focussed Elise to leave the factory but not really an everyday car.

Lawrence5

1,254 posts

266 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
71mb0 said:
Hi,

am new to Elise's and this forum, have done a little research about all the various models etc and on paper I know the differences between them but I am after some impressions from those of you that know.

Ideally it seems the 111s is the best choice but searching for second hand examples of each I see a great number of Std S2's with the 135 upgrade pack for a few ££££ less. Also certain FAQ's list this as more like 145bhp.

I know even a std S2 is a quick beast but on the road, are the 0-60, 20-40 times of the std (or 135 for that matter) that different so as to take the edge off?

Reason for asking all this is that a good 111s is likely to be near the top end of what I can go for. If I could save a few K and get a good std S2 or ideally a S2 135 then that may be an option. I just don't want to be driving round an a years time wishing I'd plumped for the 111s cause it's soo much better.

I will be changing up from a std Impreza Turbo to give you an idea of where I will be getting my benchmark from.

Is the Exhaust mod on the S2 -> 135 upgrade a louder one? Do they sound sweet?

Many Thanks.
So many questions !

135 feels as quick the 111s as it has the close ratio gearbox. But this make cruising a noisy business. 0-60 times for all variants are within spitting distance so wouldn't worry too much. Midrange will be well down on a scoob so think carefully what suits..... you'll find the 135/111s much better here.

Most will have a sports exhaust - larini, Bell and Colville Janspeed all sound great. Better noise wise is good induction so look out for ITG or hurricane.

If you like toys (air con electric etc) then 111s is your boy. 135bhp cannot be specidfied with air IIRC and pre-dates electrics of the 04model 111S.

Try as many as you can and get to local meets and talk to owners - see SELOC.org regions for your area.

Happy hunting biggrin

siwil1

1,022 posts

262 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
HI i test drove all the models you are looking at at ended up buying a 135 and have loved very minute of it.



http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/199534.htm
Due to a change of circumstances I am selling so forgive the shameless plug!

price is open to negotiation so pm me if interested.


71mb0

Original Poster:

6 posts

232 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
yeah, I kinda bundle a lot of questions in there, sorry.

Thanks for answering them so fully though, has helped a lot.

-- just makeing sure I got right end of the stick here --

So basically the 111s is a little more smoothed out (and some have more toys on) to make it more usable every day. The extra power is no doubt to overcome the extra weight of all the new toys, so a std or a 135 may be the more entertaining ones (but watch out for motorway use)?

--

Thanks,

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
Nearly - the extra power on the 111S is more than the weight added (bear in mind comfort is relative - 'carpets' means mats plus carpet under the seats and a few inches up the bulkhead). However the gearbox has wider ratios. It's certainly faster than a 120bhp model but the difference is not as pronounced as you think - test drive one of each and you'll see what I mean.

jb111s

393 posts

249 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
111s also has the improved hvac fan. You get (even without aircon option) 4 forward facing airvents which you don't get with the other models. Useful for when sitting in traffic to have a bit of a breeze on you.

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
Drive them all. I found that the 111S felt significantly faster than a standard car as it has a much wider spread of torque. The 120bhp model will only pull hard from about 4.5-6.5k rpm where as the 111S pulls a bit better from lower down and hits its red-line with a vengeance (on a rolling road, many 111S engines are actually still increasing in power as they hit the limiter).

The extra sound proofing on the 111S does make a bit of difference but it's still not exactly refined. The extra vents and stuff are nice but not really necessary.

IMO, whatever you buy, you're best off searching for a short-roof model if you're going to use it in the rain because they tend to leak less.

JTBUSH

629 posts

239 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
I have a long roof model, and it doesnt leak!

It only leaks if you open the windows when raining, then close them again. Water then seeps in between the seal and the window, but this would be the same on the short roof as well I would think!

siwil1

1,022 posts

262 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
I dont think long roofs have a reputation for leaking, as any leaks seem to come from the front corners of the roof which are the same for long and short.
Mine dosent leak at all as the rubber seal was replaced when I bot the car.
People seem to think long roofs take longer to put on/remove but if it does take longer it must only be seconds !

HTH

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
I don't know. I just know that my short-roof doesn't leak at all and the two people I know with long roof ones get wet sills when it rains hard. Maybe my windows are just better aligned.

JTBUSH

629 posts

239 months

Wednesday 18th July 2007
quotequote all
siwil1 said:
I dont think long roofs have a reputation for leaking, as any leaks seem to come from the front corners of the roof which are the same for long and short.
Mine dosent leak at all as the rubber seal was replaced when I bot the car.
People seem to think long roofs take longer to put on/remove but if it does take longer it must only be seconds !

HTH
I can get the roof off in about a minute and back on in a similar time!

AaronD

34 posts

232 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
of the different models im looking at a 111s, mainly due to the extra speed, same premium, all the extras (only bringing weight up to ~800kg), and little price difference to a std s2.

it has everything i want cloud9... (that is until im 25 and get an exige laugh)

siwil1

1,022 posts

262 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
JTBUSH said:
siwil1 said:
I dont think long roofs have a reputation for leaking, as any leaks seem to come from the front corners of the roof which are the same for long and short.
Mine dosent leak at all as the rubber seal was replaced when I bot the car.
People seem to think long roofs take longer to put on/remove but if it does take longer it must only be seconds !

HTH
I can get the roof off in about a minute and back on in a similar time!
Absolutely so it can only be seconds of difference !


siwil1

1,022 posts

262 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
[quote=AaronD]of the different models im looking at a 111s, mainly due to the extra speed, same premium, all the extras (only bringing weight up to ~800kg), and little price difference to a std s2.

it has everything i want cloud9... (that is until im 25 and get an exige laugh) [/quote

I really think you will find it hard to find any extra speed on a public road and on a track really only at the very top end (111s v 135).I'm sure someone will correct me if i'm wrong!


AaronD

34 posts

232 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
sure but its worth knowing its there! laugh


(tbh will probably do a couple of tracks as well hehe)

Zebede29

322 posts

254 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
I've just bought an 04-plate 111s as an upgrade from my 118hp S1 standard car, when I test drove it I found the extra torque to be of much more benefit that the extra BHP - more power in most every-day situations and easier to drive in traffic thanks to the revised gearing.

Also, the car i'm getting has a Lotus Sport genuine exhaust which gives the 111s the sound it should have had from the factory.....mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm!

The extra "luxuries" are nice but not the main reason for buying the car - a Lotus is all about how it drives, not what toys it has - and i' can't wait to pick it up on Monday.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
I like the idea of the 135 personally. With a good 4-2-1 you should see 140+ bhp achievable, and they are eminently tuneable if you want to fit cams and an emerald. I found the 111S engine somewhat 'lazy', but then that was compared to the hairy-arsed revvery of my Sport 160!