Hurricane or 57i?
Discussion
My journey towards Elise ownership continues.
Am going to book for Jude Performance to come and have a look at the Elise 111s I've been very tempted by.
So hopefully if he gives the all clear then the car will be mine.
AS it is standard spec I was wondering what peoples thoughts were on induction. Most I read about have the Hurricane kit instead of the standard when they ahve been upgraded. In the past on other cars though I have always had the K&N 57i kits.
Whats the difference?
Is one better than the other or just down to taste?
Cheers
Am going to book for Jude Performance to come and have a look at the Elise 111s I've been very tempted by.
So hopefully if he gives the all clear then the car will be mine.
AS it is standard spec I was wondering what peoples thoughts were on induction. Most I read about have the Hurricane kit instead of the standard when they ahve been upgraded. In the past on other cars though I have always had the K&N 57i kits.
Whats the difference?
Is one better than the other or just down to taste?
Cheers
Why not 57i?
And by enclosed do you mean one like this from Elise Shop?
http://www.elise-shop.com/index.php?main_page=prod...
And by enclosed do you mean one like this from Elise Shop?
http://www.elise-shop.com/index.php?main_page=prod...
Pumpkinheeed said:
Why not 57i?
And by enclosed do you mean one like this from Elise Shop?
http://www.elise-shop.com/index.php?main_page=prod...
1) Because they suck in hot air from the engine bay, potentially reducing power.And by enclosed do you mean one like this from Elise Shop?
http://www.elise-shop.com/index.php?main_page=prod...
2) Yes, exactly like that.
Ive got a 57i. Perfectly happy with it. Makes an ace noise, plus dont notice any performance difference. In all honesty, if you have the cold air ducting pipe, I cant imagine the differences would be that great. Obviously, ideally, the Hurricane is better, but in real world, you buy induction kits for the noise. You get little, if any performace increases, and with the 57i being half the cost of a Hurricane, it was a pretty simple choice for me. You can get the cleaning kit for a tenner, and they will do a fair few washes, and it isnt a big thing cleaning them.
Just a comment on the 57i.
I've got one fitted to my car and although well aware of its limitations with regards pulling in warm air from the engine bay a recent good clean has helped my car to rev more cleanly to 7k rpm. I only change up 'cos the combined noise of the 57i, exhaust and engine sounds like a hammer drill on speed.
Great fun though
One of these days I'll get around to replacing it either with a Hurricane or ITG if I can find one second hand. I've also got some bits and bobs I've assembled with a view to making a sealed enclosure for the 57i - if only I had some time!
Final point: One of the MG sites has tested various induction kits (unfortunately the Hurricane and ITG weren't on the test) and on the dyno the K&N showed a 7bhp power increase! Might not be the case in the real world though.
I've got one fitted to my car and although well aware of its limitations with regards pulling in warm air from the engine bay a recent good clean has helped my car to rev more cleanly to 7k rpm. I only change up 'cos the combined noise of the 57i, exhaust and engine sounds like a hammer drill on speed.
Great fun though

One of these days I'll get around to replacing it either with a Hurricane or ITG if I can find one second hand. I've also got some bits and bobs I've assembled with a view to making a sealed enclosure for the 57i - if only I had some time!
Final point: One of the MG sites has tested various induction kits (unfortunately the Hurricane and ITG weren't on the test) and on the dyno the K&N showed a 7bhp power increase! Might not be the case in the real world though.
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



