Elise vs 911 (996 CS)
Elise vs 911 (996 CS)
Author
Discussion

bing

Original Poster:

1,946 posts

269 months

Wednesday 25th July 2007
quotequote all
Discuss!!!!

My mate just spent £38k on one, looks very nice GT3 pack etc, but it's not a real GT3; I'd rather sell my R and buy and Exige S or 240 for that kinda money!!!

Pro and Cons

Running costs

Depreciation

Which would handle better?

Which would be the fastest in the real world and on a semi-twisty track.

thanks

Bing

kambites

71,701 posts

252 months

Wednesday 25th July 2007
quotequote all
Running costs - Lotus
Depreciation - Lotus
Handling - Probably the Lotus
Fastest in the real world. Depends on how twisty the road/track is.

The Porsche will however do 99% of what the Lotus will in a far more comfortable way. Personally I'd have the Lotus but I can fully understand why someone would choose the Porsche (although I'd buy an NSX if I was after that kind of car).

espresso

177 posts

243 months

Wednesday 25th July 2007
quotequote all
To be fair, the Porsche is far batter on a motorway.
I've not had a 996, but I've had a 997 and long journeys are much less taxing than an Exige - top end power is greater and the engine is nicer too (the flat sixes do sound lovely).

You get two (feeble) back seats, the Porsche air con works better and..

No, that's about it - the Exige is better in every other way.

redevil

1,242 posts

237 months

Wednesday 25th July 2007
quotequote all
I would have thought at motorway speeds the Porsche will be in a different league for performance/comfort.

As for handling, track performance and costs, Lotus is a better bet.

At that price level i would expect the Lotus to depreciate faster though.

Edited by redevil on Wednesday 25th July 15:17

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 25th July 2007
quotequote all
At £38k he should have borrowed another 5 grand and got a real GT3. Discuss.

subaqua

892 posts

243 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
At £38k he should have borrowed another 5 grand and got a real GT3. Discuss.
Think you've covered it there Tim

SimonK

908 posts

256 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
Yup no discussion needed there

pgn340r

114 posts

238 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
Having sold my GT3 and bought an Exige would have to agree. Porsche a much better allround package with an amazing soundtrack, but if like me you do a lot a track days a very expensive car to maintain (I'm talking consumables here) However the Lotus people imo are a much nicer/friendlier bunch

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
pgn340r said:
Having sold my GT3 and bought an Exige would have to agree. Porsche a much better allround package with an amazing soundtrack, but if like me you do a lot a track days a very expensive car to maintain (I'm talking consumables here) However the Lotus people imo are a much nicer/friendlier bunch
Very kind of you to say so, thanks. wavey

Shnozz

30,689 posts

302 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
interesting as I am thinking of swapping the elise and celica for a 996 with aerokit to use as a daily drive.

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
kambites said:
Running costs - Lotus
Depreciation - Lotus
Handling - Probably the Lotus
Fastest in the real world. Depends on how twisty the road/track is.

The Porsche will however do 99% of what the Lotus will in a far more comfortable way. Personally I'd have the Lotus but I can fully understand why someone would choose the Porsche (although I'd buy an NSX if I was after that kind of car).
i had a 996 C2 (sport chassis version) for almost 2 years before my elise.

ive had the elise (S1) for near 3 months now.

Running costs - Lotus (I spent 10 grand in 12 months getting the porsche right, although I bought the first one I saw and it was a garage queen, lots of little probs that once ironed out the car was fantastic)
Depreciation - lotus will depreciate more if you buy the right car, at 37k you will loose more with the porsche, I lost 500 pound in almost 2 years and 42k miles with the porsche (thats not including the minus 10 grand putting it right but if I'd have had it checked propper before the purchase this would not have happend)
Handling - against a sport chassis C2 or a GT3 the lotus may just have a little higher corner speed but it wouldnt be very noticalbe. against a non sport chassis car that has LSD uprated suspension etc etc etc, the non sport chassis car would be left a little behind although it would take it on the exit with no questions.
Fastest in the real world. Depends on how twisty the road/track is.

for everyday use as a complete package the 996 wins hands down, no contest.

the elise is a totally different kind of car though, its great fun up to 60 but doesnt really have much after that, the 911 will pull like a train to 180 all day long.

you say a 996 CS, you mean a GT3 CS?

there is no such thing as a 996CS unless he means the sport chassis version and they are all pre 2000 and very very very rare. not to mention wont be worth 37 grand.