111r - reliable?
Author
Discussion

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
Having owned the k series engine in the 111s, it provided me with over 24,000 miles that were totally trouble free.

I changed the 111s to get a 111r and believed that in terms of reliablity it was a step forwards. Toyota engine is 'unbreakable' as I was told. Bit disappointed then to get in the car this morning, turn the key and find the car is totally dead - think it's a starter motor but could be wrong?

Currently carless, sitting in work, extensive phone calls to the AA [covered under warranty] and hopefully getting the car picked up in the morning and delivered to Formula One in Newcastle.

Bugger!

May have to join the k-series supporters group now.

Zebra

Boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
zebra said:
Having owned the k series engine in the 111s, it provided me with over 24,000 miles that were totally trouble free.

I changed the 111s to get a 111r and believed that in terms of reliablity it was a step forwards. Toyota engine is 'unbreakable' as I was told. Bit disappointed then to get in the car this morning, turn the key and find the car is totally dead - think it's a starter motor but could be wrong?

Currently carless, sitting in work, extensive phone calls to the AA [covered under warranty] and hopefully getting the car picked up in the morning and delivered to Formula One in Newcastle.

Bugger!

May have to join the k-series supporters group now.

Zebra
I don't think that you can judge a engine/car on one problem, sound's to me like your battery is flat it's up to you but I'd have a Toyota engine over Rover any day your post did make me laugh

Boggy

tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
If its totally dead, ie no ignition lights or interior power then its more likely your battery .

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
Hi Boggy

Wasn't being serious - would not go back to k series.

No, it's not the battery - drove it 10 minutes earlier and it was fine, remembered that my office keys were in the house so turned back. Parked up on the road, went into the house, came back out - nothing.

The liz is my everyday drive so a flat battery would be unusual. Don't think it's electrical either unless a loose connection somewhere - dash lights up with all the symbols, but the engine light stayed on? Now in 20-odd thousand miles in this car I cannot remember whether the engine light stays on until the engine has started or not?

Last piece of info - the MIL light did flash on the return journey to the house.

Zebra

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
tricky 100 said:
If its totally dead, ie no ignition lights or interior power then its more likely your battery .
No got lights.

Boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
zebra said:
tricky 100 said:
If its totally dead, ie no ignition lights or interior power then its more likely your battery .
No got lights.
That is strange it can't be the immobiliser either then (Light's would come on) it's something to do with power that's for sure, normally the Alarm would go off if you tried to open the door's as it's got a battery back up

Boggy

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
Boggy said:
zebra said:
tricky 100 said:
If its totally dead, ie no ignition lights or interior power then its more likely your battery .
No got lights.
That is strange it can't be the immobiliser either then (Light's would come on) it's something to do with power that's for sure, normally the Alarm would go off if you tried to open the door's as it's got a battery back up

Boggy
My post should have read "No, got lights"

Snapper7

990 posts

290 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
Sounds like a flat battery. Lights take next no power at all and you might still get them if the battery is next to flat. To start the car will need about 12volts. You could have 5or6 volts left.

Does the immobiliser still come on and off? If not very low battery.

Does the starter turn over? If not I would say that it is a very weak battery.

If you get a ticking sound only, when you try and start her up. That would also suggest a very weak battery.

If it is the battery then it could be the following: Battery has gone? Interior light or something was left on and flattened it. Alternator has gone and not charged up the battery (I have an S2 Exige and although I garage it, when touring it is in the open and it does concern me with all the rain that goes straight in the engine bay and onto the alternator).

I don't think that it is you immobiliser because the car will turn over but won't fire.



NathanE

539 posts

233 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
No engine and its ancillaries are faultless. And nobody said the 111R engine is unbreakable. It's just that it tends to be inexpensive and rare things that happen to it. Every now and then you'll hear of one blowing up in spectacular style but then you also occasionally see a Ferrari or Porsche with smoke pooring from the engine bay on the hard shoulder...

Beachbum

2,610 posts

262 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
A flashing MIL is a big no-no. If it comes on and remains on, then you can continue to drive and get it looked at soonest.
Flshing MIL means pull over immediately. Not sure what the EMS does once the ignition is turned off after the MIL starts to flash, it maybe a safety feature that it does not allow the car to be restarted until the ECU has been reset.

Just my 2p's worth

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
Snapper7 said:
Sounds like a flat battery. Lights take next no power at all and you might still get them if the battery is next to flat. To start the car will need about 12volts. You could have 5or6 volts left.

Does the immobiliser still come on and off? If not very low battery.

Does the starter turn over? If not I would say that it is a very weak battery.

If you get a ticking sound only, when you try and start her up. That would also suggest a very weak battery.

If it is the battery then it could be the following: Battery has gone? Interior light or something was left on and flattened it. Alternator has gone and not charged up the battery (I have an S2 Exige and although I garage it, when touring it is in the open and it does concern me with all the rain that goes straight in the engine bay and onto the alternator).

I don't think that it is you immobiliser because the car will turn over but won't fire.
Alarm working - no immobiliser light.

Interior light not left on.

Car was driven for approximately 10 miles prior to stopping [in daylight] no lights or stereo on.

Car is garaged - weather was dry [unusally so].

Zebra

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
Beachbum said:
A flashing MIL is a big no-no. If it comes on and remains on, then you can continue to drive and get it looked at soonest.
Flshing MIL means pull over immediately. Not sure what the EMS does once the ignition is turned off after the MIL starts to flash, it maybe a safety feature that it does not allow the car to be restarted until the ECU has been reset.

Just my 2p's worth
Could well be a possibility.

zebra

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
NathanE said:
And nobody said the 111R engine is unbreakable.
Sorry, that was a tongue in cheek comment based upon the k-series v yamaha v honda debate that sometimes ensues on here.

Zebra

rfoster

1,482 posts

285 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
Does fuel pump prime when you turn the key to ignition on (not cranking)? You'll hear the whine. If not, check the interia switch hasn't popped. If it is, the start *could* be stuck. Pop the car in 4th gear and get out of the acar, handbrake off, and rock the car back & forwards. This will usually pop the spindle back into the starter motor - it's not unheard of for it to get stuck. Happened frequently on my old S1.

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
rfoster said:
Does fuel pump prime when you turn the key to ignition on (not cranking)? You'll hear the whine. If not, check the interia switch hasn't popped. If it is, the start *could* be stuck. Pop the car in 4th gear and get out of the acar, handbrake off, and rock the car back & forwards. This will usually pop the spindle back into the starter motor - it's not unheard of for it to get stuck. Happened frequently on my old S1.
Fuel pump is priming.

AA visiting tonight at 6.00pm after I have blagged a lift home.

Zebra


Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
zebra said:
Toyota engine is 'unbreakable' as I was told.
Hmm you didn't ask them about oil starvation on hard cornering then?

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
AA have been round at the house or two hours without joy - car due to be put on flat bed tomorrow morning to go to the lotus hospital - will find out a bit more then.

Zebra

NathanE

539 posts

233 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
Paul RN said:
zebra said:
Toyota engine is 'unbreakable' as I was told.
Hmm you didn't ask them about oil starvation on hard cornering then?
That's not the fault of the engine, but more the *implementation* of it.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
NathanE said:
Paul RN said:
zebra said:
Toyota engine is 'unbreakable' as I was told.
Hmm you didn't ask them about oil starvation on hard cornering then?
That's not the fault of the engine, but more the *implementation* of it.
IIRC it wasn't designed to cope with over 1G of cornering force?

Edited by kevin ritson on Monday 20th August 21:23

Crowley

524 posts

242 months

Monday 20th August 2007
quotequote all
zebra said:
Having owned the k series engine in the 111s, it provided me with over 24,000 miles that were totally trouble free.

I changed the 111s to get a 111r and believed that in terms of reliablity it was a step forwards. Toyota engine is 'unbreakable' as I was told. Bit disappointed then to get in the car this morning, turn the key and find the car is totally dead - think it's a starter motor but could be wrong?

Currently carless, sitting in work, extensive phone calls to the AA [covered under warranty] and hopefully getting the car picked up in the morning and delivered to Formula One in Newcastle.

Bugger!

May have to join the k-series supporters group now.

Zebra
Get an M100. Much more reliable and just a quick.