Back protection for trail riding

[Craikeybaby]

I'm looking at new hydration packs for riding, after my Camelbak Mule died and their "lifetime warranty" doesn't cover a three year old bag I like the look of the evoc bags and trying to work out if I need a back protector or not. The choice seems to be between the Stage 12 and the FR Enduro, which has the built in back protection.

Most my riding is fairly gentle trails, with about 15 days of trail centre riding a year (not uplift). I don't wear a full face helmet, or race etc. I probably don't need back protection, but are there any downsides to having it, other than the slight increase in cost of the bag? Is the back ventilation better on the bags without back protection etc?

Has anyone got either of the evoc bags I'm looking at?

[gp1699]

I have the Evoc enduro backline. its great, I figured I may as well get the one with protection just incase.... cant think of any down sides to it.

the back protector is fitted to the inside of the pack and is removable so ventilation isn't really an issue.

Its very well made and the quality of the zips are excellent, storage compartments are also very well though out.

camelback have just released a pack with protection that might be worth a look too.

[Craikeybaby]

Thanks, you have the one I have been looking at. Given my experience with my current Camelbak I'm not looking to get another.

[joema]

Can't hurt to have it but I would question the effectiveness of it. If the protector is not strapped properly to your back what use will it be?

Most people I know who have back injuries got them from compression type impacts, not landing on the spine. including me.

I wouldn't get too hung up on the feature.

[The_Jackal]

Agree, knee and elbow pads before back.
The backpack alone will provide a little protection on its own anyway. I've rolled over mine several times.

[Craikeybaby]

I’ve got decent knee pads already. The question really is, are there any downsides to having back protection built in to a rucksack?

[Craikeybaby]

Unfortunately my frame doesn't have a bottle cage. I do need to ride with less though, certainly on shorter local rides.