Hydraulic discs problem
Hydraulic discs problem
Author
Discussion

Nevin

Original Poster:

2,999 posts

290 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
I've got a set of Shimano hydraulic disc brakes and recently replaced the pads on them as they are knackered. After few rides with them to bed them in the fronts now feel fine but the back is very weak and needs a lot of pull on the lever to start braking.

With the old pads I could lock the back wheel up with one finger, now I can't do it at all. I have bled the system front and rear too (and I'm pretty sure there can't possibly be any more air in there) but it isn't helping.

Any suggestions as to how to improve braking at the rear would be gratefully received.

TheDetailDoctor

9,073 posts

239 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
In the event of any disc issues, (especially on my Shimano XT ones), I always start with a bleed of the system. 95% of the time it sorts it.

Nevin

Original Poster:

2,999 posts

290 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
TheDetailDoctor said:
In the event of any disc issues, (especially on my Shimano XT ones), I always start with a bleed of the system. 95% of the time it sorts it.
Yup, but done that 3 times and its not helping unfortunately.

TheDetailDoctor

9,073 posts

239 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
Nevin said:
TheDetailDoctor said:
In the event of any disc issues, (especially on my Shimano XT ones), I always start with a bleed of the system. 95% of the time it sorts it.
Yup, but done that 3 times and its not helping unfortunately.
Have you tried back bleeding them?

Nevin

Original Poster:

2,999 posts

290 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
TheDetailDoctor said:
Nevin said:
TheDetailDoctor said:
In the event of any disc issues, (especially on my Shimano XT ones), I always start with a bleed of the system. 95% of the time it sorts it.
Yup, but done that 3 times and its not helping unfortunately.
Have you tried back bleeding them?
You mean pushing the air out from the other end with a syringe? Not yet. Think that would help? Or do you mean something else?

Edited by Nevin on Tuesday 1st June 14:23

TheDetailDoctor

9,073 posts

239 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
Yep, push the fluid from the bleed nipple to the reservior, sometimes they can be a PITA to get clear. Also, try tapping the lines/calipers/levers when bleeding as it can help free the trapped air also.

Nevin

Original Poster:

2,999 posts

290 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
TheDetailDoctor said:
Yep, push the fluid from the bleed nipple to the reservior, sometimes they can be a PITA to get clear. Also, try tapping the lines/calipers/levers when bleeding as it can help free the trapped air also.
Cheers, will give that a go. Just need to find somewhere to get a syringe now.

TheDetailDoctor

9,073 posts

239 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
Nevin said:
TheDetailDoctor said:
Yep, push the fluid from the bleed nipple to the reservior, sometimes they can be a PITA to get clear. Also, try tapping the lines/calipers/levers when bleeding as it can help free the trapped air also.
Cheers, will give that a go. Just need to find somewhere to get a syringe now.
Make sure you use mineral fluid too otherwise you'll need to flush clean.

Nevin

Original Poster:

2,999 posts

290 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
TheDetailDoctor said:
Nevin said:
TheDetailDoctor said:
Yep, push the fluid from the bleed nipple to the reservior, sometimes they can be a PITA to get clear. Also, try tapping the lines/calipers/levers when bleeding as it can help free the trapped air also.
Cheers, will give that a go. Just need to find somewhere to get a syringe now.
Make sure you use mineral fluid too otherwise you'll need to flush clean.
No problem, have a huge bottle of Shimano mineral fluid.

BliarOut

72,863 posts

268 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
Pop the pads out and look at the contact faces, they probably aren't making full contact across the entire surface. Either dress them with a file or wait till they bed in if that's the case.

P-Jay

11,400 posts

220 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
Hmmm, we if the bite point is good / lever doesn't come to the bar it could be: caliper needs a centre, or pads are contaminated - happens or they're just not bedded in yet.

Experienced riders use little rear brake, could be they're just still 'green' try a few big stops using the rear only.

shalmaneser

6,420 posts

224 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
I'd be tempted to swap the pads front and rear, just to confirm that it's the hydraulics not the pads that are at fault.

TBH it sounds like contaminated pads to me, but presumably you know your onions if you're happy to rebleed your brakes and you know the classic symptoms (ie. squealing!).

How's the lever feel, is it spongey or as it should be?

Word of warning: when you swap the pads over clean the rotor thoroughly to prevent any cross contamination if present!

Nevin

Original Poster:

2,999 posts

290 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
P-Jay said:
Hmmm, we if the bite point is good / lever doesn't come to the bar it could be: caliper needs a centre, or pads are contaminated - happens or they're just not bedded in yet.

Experienced riders use little rear brake, could be they're just still 'green' try a few big stops using the rear only.
May have to look at it all again. Caliper was sticking but I thought I had sorted that so will take it apart.

Experienced riders weighing as much as I do need as much braking power as they can get, both front and rear.

Pads could be contaminated but shouldn't be. I'll pull it apart in the shop again tomorrow.

Brake lever is very spongy thougfh.

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

263 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
If the lever action is progressive (ie slowly gets harder and harder to pull) then you've still got air in there.

If, however, the lever is nice and solid the moment the pads hit the discs, then your problem is elsewhere.

Nevin

Original Poster:

2,999 posts

290 months

Wednesday 2nd June 2010
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
If the lever action is progressive (ie slowly gets harder and harder to pull) then you've still got air in there.

If, however, the lever is nice and solid the moment the pads hit the discs, then your problem is elsewhere.
It doesn't really get hard to pull at all, which I suspect may mean there is still air in there.

TheDetailDoctor

9,073 posts

239 months

Wednesday 2nd June 2010
quotequote all
Nevin said:
Parrot of Doom said:
If the lever action is progressive (ie slowly gets harder and harder to pull) then you've still got air in there.

If, however, the lever is nice and solid the moment the pads hit the discs, then your problem is elsewhere.
It doesn't really get hard to pull at all......
fnarr fnarr

Nevin

Original Poster:

2,999 posts

290 months

Wednesday 2nd June 2010
quotequote all
TheDetailDoctor said:
Nevin said:
Parrot of Doom said:
If the lever action is progressive (ie slowly gets harder and harder to pull) then you've still got air in there.

If, however, the lever is nice and solid the moment the pads hit the discs, then your problem is elsewhere.
It doesn't really get hard to pull at all......
fnarr fnarr
Yoiks

neil_bolton

17,113 posts

293 months

Wednesday 2nd June 2010
quotequote all
Sometimes a brake caliper or brake resevoir will have a bad casting which makes bleeding the brake nigh on impossible.

I have a set of XTR's which I simply can never ever get bled the way I like them, yet a set of XT levers I got done in 3 seconds flat.

Therefore it's worth taking a close look at the casting underneath the top hats, and/or ensuring that you have all of the correct seals, washers and o-rings in the assembly.

Short of that, look at your cables, and ensure no kinks or undue tight bends.

After that, try sacrificing a small child.

Or do it drunk, as you tend to go 'ahhh feck it. that'll do'.

Nevin

Original Poster:

2,999 posts

290 months

Wednesday 2nd June 2010
quotequote all
neil_bolton said:
Sometimes a brake caliper or brake resevoir will have a bad casting which makes bleeding the brake nigh on impossible.

I have a set of XTR's which I simply can never ever get bled the way I like them, yet a set of XT levers I got done in 3 seconds flat.

Therefore it's worth taking a close look at the casting underneath the top hats, and/or ensuring that you have all of the correct seals, washers and o-rings in the assembly.

Short of that, look at your cables, and ensure no kinks or undue tight bends.

After that, try sacrificing a small child.

Or do it drunk, as you tend to go 'ahhh feck it. that'll do'.
I have bled it previously though and its been fine so that seems less likely, but who knows. Tis a black art and no mistake.

neil_bolton

17,113 posts

293 months

Wednesday 2nd June 2010
quotequote all
Nevin said:
neil_bolton said:
Sometimes a brake caliper or brake resevoir will have a bad casting which makes bleeding the brake nigh on impossible.

I have a set of XTR's which I simply can never ever get bled the way I like them, yet a set of XT levers I got done in 3 seconds flat.

Therefore it's worth taking a close look at the casting underneath the top hats, and/or ensuring that you have all of the correct seals, washers and o-rings in the assembly.

Short of that, look at your cables, and ensure no kinks or undue tight bends.

After that, try sacrificing a small child.

Or do it drunk, as you tend to go 'ahhh feck it. that'll do'.
I have bled it previously though and its been fine so that seems less likely, but who knows. Tis a black art and no mistake.
Have you damaged any of the seals, or forgotton any of the o-rings that sit between the hose and the caliper/lever housing?