Advice on track car
Advice on track car
Author
Discussion

James Taylor

Original Poster:

137 posts

263 months

Wednesday 3rd June 2009
quotequote all
Looking to get a track car and seen a 205 with 240 bhp
Suspension and brakes are all sorted.

Will need to get some decent tyres......so any recomendations will be helpfull.

My only worry is getting the power down and understeer.

Can anyone give me some advice......

Recently done a trackday in an exige (190 bhp)and it was amazing fun.......would the 205 be competetive with an Exige with the same driver?

Cavey

522 posts

255 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
James Taylor said:
Recently done a trackday in an exige (190 bhp)and it was amazing fun.......would the 205 be competetive with an Exige with the same driver?
Unlikely. You will still have a great time in the 205 though. biggrin

thequietone

170 posts

225 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
Behave! A 205 with 240bhp...more poke than the Exige and lighter too(depending on the model - 1600 with nothing on it was around 750kgs), driven well it will see off an awful lot of more exotic machinery. Dont worry about understeer, barrel in a little fast and lift off as you turn in, that ought to see the back joining in the fun.


You'll have a riot!

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

306 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
Behave yourself smile Exige is about 780KG and has bags more grip than a 205 - the Pug won't see which way it went.

Agree that a Pug on track is an absolute hoot though.

Keefyboy

17 posts

271 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
Agree with Matt.

Although the 205 may sound impressive on paper the Lotus is a far more competent car around a lap. Got to say though, the 205 is a fantastic toy smile - even more so with a full roll-cage.

As for tyres - the choice depends on what you really want? For lap times (and keeping it road legal) I'd look into Toyo R888 track rubber. For fun (but still grippy enough), Yokohama A539s aren't a bad bet (its the controlled tyre for Stock Hatch and Locost racing, too).

Keith

James Taylor

Original Poster:

137 posts

263 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
I was told that an Exige was 900+kg with 190bhp
And that the 205 once stripped out can get to 750-800kg with 240bhp.

If i had the koni suspension 4 pot brakes with discs on the rear and decent track tyres do you think it would be competetive with an Exige..

Had so much fun in the Exige i had i just want something that is not permanantly lapped.

jleroux

1,511 posts

284 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
speed is not the same as fun - i'd argue a standard MX5 or MR2 will be more fun than a souped up 205 to be honest. don't get me wrong - the 205 is a great bit of kit, cheap to buy and run and plenty quick enough - but it's inherrently flawed for track use by being FWD.

Jonny
BaT

fergus

6,430 posts

299 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
jleroux said:
- but it's inherrently flawed for track use by being FWD.
Just like all the current touring cars (bar the BMWs) and all the old super tourers of old. How flawed they were.... rolleyes

My old Clio cup could keep a GT3 honest a Bedford. I'm not quite sure where you've got that opinion from Johnny?

philmorris

23 posts

208 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
But then i read in a magazine that the 911 is "flawed" because its weight distribution isn't 50:50. And someone told me that mid engined cars are "flawed" by their low moment of polar inertia making them prone to liftoff oversteer. On the other hand, front engined RWD cars have traction "flaws" in the wet (i think i got that off Top Gear, so it must be true). And Caterfields are "flawed" because they're unreliable junk. That's what i heard.

And now FWD is "flawed" you say? Oh well, another config bites the internet dust.

Cavey

522 posts

255 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
My problem is that I'm flawed. Car usually a secondary issue!

James - you won't get lapped by much in a well driven version of either of these (apart from by the Caterfield brigade but if you want to go there then do), unless you go to days like Goldtrack at Silverstone where there is serious kit. I'd go for the one you think you'd prefer to own, which would be the Exige for me

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

306 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
TBH if being lapped on a trackday means you dont have fun then you fundamentally misunderstand what trackdays are about!

James Taylor

Original Poster:

137 posts

263 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
The only trackday i have done was in an exige and i was passed by numerous cars....

I am not looking to be the quickest i just want to be competetive and have fun

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

306 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
If you want to be competitive, do a test day.

Trackdays are not competitions.

Birdthom

790 posts

249 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
fergus said:
jleroux said:
- but it's inherrently flawed for track use by being FWD.
Just like all the current touring cars (bar the BMWs) and all the old super tourers of old. How flawed they were.... rolleyes

My old Clio cup could keep a GT3 honest a Bedford. I'm not quite sure where you've got that opinion from Johnny?
It's perfectly possible for an FWD car to be a fast car, but whether it's as much fun as a RWD car is an entirely different matter.

I'm glad your Clio cup was as fast as a GT3. Mine certainly wasn't.

Edited by Birdthom on Friday 5th June 09:27

fergus

6,430 posts

299 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
Birdthom said:
fergus said:
jleroux said:
- but it's inherrently flawed for track use by being FWD.
Just like all the current touring cars (bar the BMWs) and all the old super tourers of old. How flawed they were.... rolleyes

My old Clio cup could keep a GT3 honest a Bedford. I'm not quite sure where you've got that opinion from Johnny?
It's perfectly possible for an FWD car to be a fast car, but whether it's as much fun as a RWD car is an entirely different matter.

I'm glad your Clio cup was as fast as a GT3. Mine certainly wasn't.
The sequential box and slicks help a lot! Are you talking about a 182 Cup road car?

jleroux

1,511 posts

284 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
Just to clarify - I meant "flawed" in terms of fun, not performance. Happy to accept that's entirely subjective - but IMHO there's no place for a FWD sports car on the road, let alone the track.

Jonny
BaT

Keefyboy

17 posts

271 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
Ahh, the age-old classic front-wheel drive versus rear-wheel drive debate smile

I used to play the old 'rear-wheel drive only' card a few years ago… however, the latest range of front-wheel drive sport hatches (especially from Renaultsport) has certainly flipped my stubborn views somewhat.

Turning this thread back onto the subject of the 205 - out of any of the older hot hatches this is by far one of the better models to have fun in on track. I raced a 1.6 GTi Stockhatch Rallycross variant and (although I got bumped, barged and bruised!) I enjoyed every minute. In terms performance they still win today against the newer Saxos… plus they're cheap to repair too smile

Keith

Birdthom

790 posts

249 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
fergus said:
The sequential box and slicks help a lot! Are you talking about a 182 Cup road car?
Ahhh - if you're talking about cup race cars then that's a different kettle of herrings. Apologies.

However, if we're comparing like for like then a stripped race-prepped GT3 will be rather different matter too. The clios do look like great fun, but they are one of the few exceptions to the pub/forum rule about FWD IMHO.

edh

3,498 posts

293 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
James Taylor said:
The only trackday i have done was in an exige and i was passed by numerous cars....

I am not looking to be the quickest i just want to be competetive and have fun
If you're being passed all the time in an Exige, then it's probably nothing to do with the car....

Driver training & seat time is what you need - decide what sort of car you want & then learn how to drive it. Start off with something that is reasonably forgiving, and light (much cheaper on tyres & brakes that way).

GC8

19,910 posts

214 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
mattdaniels said:
If you want to be competitive, do a test day.

Trackdays are not competitions.
Too right.