Unpaid overtime
Author
Discussion

Parsnip

Original Poster:

3,260 posts

217 months

Wednesday 27th February 2013
quotequote all
Have been advised today that I will be moving to a different department for the next 4 months. As part of this, I will end up having to work 12 (ish) extra hours per week (my current contract is 37.5 hours)

My contract states that I will be expected to do some unpaid overtime as the business requires (which I have done) - but is 12 hours a week for 4 months seen as reasonable? Is it seen as overtime or a change of contract?

Short of negotiating more holiday/pay, is there anything I can do?

The work doesn't bother me and neither do the extra hours (to a point), but I am basically being forced into giving up a decent chunk of my home life and getting nothing back.

WhereamI

6,887 posts

246 months

Wednesday 27th February 2013
quotequote all
49.5 is above the legal maximum according to the working time directive, of course you might have opted out...


TonyTony

1,882 posts

187 months

Wednesday 27th February 2013
quotequote all
Sounds like your being bent over if you are getting moved to a different department and having to work 12 hours extra for nothing, not even of your own accord. Unless it is a move you want?

Spitfire2

1,968 posts

215 months

Wednesday 27th February 2013
quotequote all
An extra day and a half per week unpaid on a permanent basis is not fair and reasonable overtime.


Sir Fergie

795 posts

164 months

Wednesday 27th February 2013
quotequote all
Parsnip said:
Have been advised today that I will be moving to a different department for the next 4 months. As part of this, I will end up having to work 12 (ish) extra hours per week (my current contract is 37.5 hours)

My contract states that I will be expected to do some unpaid overtime as the business requires (which I have done) - but is 12 hours a week for 4 months seen as reasonable? Is it seen as overtime or a change of contract?

Short of negotiating more holiday/pay, is there anything I can do?

The work doesn't bother me and neither do the extra hours (to a point), but I am basically being forced into giving up a decent chunk of my home life and getting nothing back.
I would have thought that the "unpaid overtime" thing would be to do say a couple of extra hours once in a blue moon if the boss was stuck - or you were extremely busy or something.

Are you certain you won't be getting paid for these extra 12 hours a week for 4 months???.

Unbelievable stuff - if thats the case - im sorry to say ive no advice - except perhaps to look at future career/employment opportunities - if your company wants 12 hours unpaid work a week for 4 months - then they are a bunch of tossers imo - and the sooner you can get finished up with them - the better imo.

Best of luck - if i were in that situation - the toys would be leaving the pram - and the pram would be landing into the bosses desk with some force rage

Sir Fergie

davepoth

29,395 posts

228 months

Wednesday 27th February 2013
quotequote all
Yup. The unpaid overtime bit in the contract is for ad hoc stuff; a formal arrangement throws that out the window.

Parsnip

Original Poster:

3,260 posts

217 months

Thursday 28th February 2013
quotequote all
That's kind of how I interpret the unpaid overtime thing - to provide cover when things are really busy or a deadline is looming. The problem is that the extra hours aren't written anywhere, but from the extra workload and from speaking to others, that will be the ballpark figure.

MagicalTrevor

6,481 posts

258 months

Thursday 28th February 2013
quotequote all
We have a policy where the first 7.5 hours of overtime are unpaid and then we're paid 1.5x (2.0x Sundays). This is really for ad-hoc overtime. If we have scheduled work outside of normal hours then we get paid for it as its normally charged to a project.

KingNothing

3,336 posts

182 months

Thursday 28th February 2013
quotequote all
Unpaid overtime? What's this then? Sometimes I get pissed off with my job, but its not that bad when looking at other people's jobs, working for free? fk that for a laugh, employers don't own people, some seem to think they do though, wkers.

WhereamI

6,887 posts

246 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
KingNothing said:
Unpaid overtime? What's this then? Sometimes I get pissed off with my job, but its not that bad when looking at other people's jobs, working for free? fk that for a laugh, employers don't own people, some seem to think they do though, wkers.
Hmm, the words of a man who is going to get far in life!

anonymous-user

83 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
WhereamI said:
Hmm, the words of a man who is going to get far in life!
Although, if what the OP says is correct, the employer in this case is taking the piss.

WhereamI

6,887 posts

246 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
garyhun said:
WhereamI said:
Hmm, the words of a man who is going to get far in life!
Although, if what the OP says is correct, the employer in this case is taking the piss.
In this case, if they are really expecting that much then, yes, they are. But the mindset displayed is more what I was commenting on.

Gaspode

4,167 posts

225 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
So much of the decision is going to have to be based on the situation, your skill set, and employment opportunities, but the essentially, there's a simple choice, the good old "Three L" principle: Like it, Lump it, or Leave...

anonymous-user

83 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
WhereamI said:
In this case, if they are really expecting that much then, yes, they are. But the mindset displayed is more what I was commenting on.
Understood.

STW2010

5,918 posts

191 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
WhereamI said:
KingNothing said:
Unpaid overtime? What's this then? Sometimes I get pissed off with my job, but its not that bad when looking at other people's jobs, working for free? fk that for a laugh, employers don't own people, some seem to think they do though, wkers.
Hmm, the words of a man who is going to get far in life!
Completely agree

Fat hippo

741 posts

163 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
For all the banking jobs i've had, the condition of an employment offer is subject to me signing the 48hour opt out.

anonymous-user

83 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
WhereamI said:
KingNothing said:
Unpaid overtime? What's this then? Sometimes I get pissed off with my job, but its not that bad when looking at other people's jobs, working for free? fk that for a laugh, employers don't own people, some seem to think they do though, wkers.
Hmm, the words of a man who is going to get far in life!
A lot depends on the work situation, if you are working minimum wage in a burger bar unpaid O/T is taking the proverbial and likely illegal, a middle manager working their way up then it's part of the game.

Flipping the original premise on it's head, if you said to an employer that every now and then you would be taking a couple of hours off outside of holiday paid because it was "important" and for the next 4 months you'd be working 12 hours a week less but still expect to be paid the same they would be showing you the door.

MagicalTrevor

6,481 posts

258 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
I think that quite a few 'professional'/white collar jobs would expect that you're being paid to 'do a job' so a certain amount of overtime will be unpaid. Whether you see this as right or not is another matter.

As I said in my example above, if I'm asked to specifically do project work outside of normal hours than it's a straight 1.5x OT. We accomodate this as much as possible, partly because of the money but mainly because it's part of my job to do this where I can.

On the other hand, a mate of mine works in a struggling manufacturing industry. If the shop-floor staff refused to do any unpaid overtime then the company would likely go under right now. The company relies on the goodwill of the staff to stay afloat and in turn, this keeps those people in a job. However, he makes sure that his staff are able to take TOIL during the quiet periods where the company can afford to not have the staff in.

Somewhere in the middle is the OP, it's wrong to be expected to do so many hours overtime. Even if they were paying you I'd say that they had an obligation to ensure you weren't exposed to doing so many additional hours as it's bad for your health.


KingNothing

3,336 posts

182 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
WhereamI said:
Hmm, the words of a man who is going to get far in life!
Glad I don't work for you then. If you're good at something you don't do it for free, simple as that really, expecting 12 hours free a week, middle management or not? That's a piss take.

Edited by KingNothing on Friday 1st March 08:58

snowy

541 posts

310 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
This always grates me, people doing overtime for nothing, to benefit the company that will be rewarded, and also management rewarded in the way of bonuses, but they expect people to do overtime for nothing.
Why should people give up their time for free? For many years now probably going back to when Thatcher was PM, the UK mind set has been live to work, not work to live