Pay rate between shifts night into day
Pay rate between shifts night into day
Author
Discussion

Type R Tom

Original Poster:

4,202 posts

170 months

Monday 12th January
quotequote all
I think I know the answer to this but was wondering what others thought.

My wife works overnight on a Sunday to Monday morning. She gets a better rate for the night shift, even though arguably the work is easier overnight than during the day. Sometimes she is asked to continue working into the morning to cover sick/leave etc. When this happens she drops back to the day rate.

Me wanting the best for her, feel that she should be paid those morning hours at the night rate as it's one long shift and she's tired, obviously her work don't agree.

Am I being unreasonable, probably are?

FlyVintage

315 posts

12 months

Monday 12th January
quotequote all
Look at it from the perspective of the people she is working alongside during the day shift portion. Should she be getting paid more for the same work they are doing? You can probably see what position that would put her employer in.

JPC63

82 posts

5 months

Monday 12th January
quotequote all
She should be paid an overtime rate regardless.

When i did shifts it was:

1.3x for regular OT
1.5x Friday night and Saturday
2.0x Saturday night, Sunday and Sunday night

Monday day would be 1.3x, but with 12hr shifts, not be allowed to work into next day after nights.

98elise

31,128 posts

182 months

Monday 12th January
quotequote all
JPC63 said:
She should be paid an overtime rate regardless.

When i did shifts it was:

1.3x for regular OT
1.5x Friday night and Saturday
2.0x Saturday night, Sunday and Sunday night

Monday day would be 1.3x, but with 12hr shifts, not be allowed to work into next day after nights.
It depends on the job. Supermarkets for example just pay a flat rate for every hour worked.

MDMA .

9,998 posts

122 months

Monday 12th January
quotequote all
98elise said:
It depends on the job. Supermarkets for example just pay a flat rate for every hour worked.
They don't.

s p a c e m a n

11,537 posts

169 months

Monday 12th January
quotequote all
With us it's unsociable hours payment, if you're working nights or weekends you get a higher rate. If you continued from nights into normal working time I'd argue that it was all one shift and should be paid at the higher rate or I wouldn't do it.

I know that at Argos it was specified what the unsociable hours were and you were only paid the rate for those particular hours, so if you started in the afternoon you'd get half normal half unsociable pay.

Basically it's company dependent.

Jamescrs

5,766 posts

86 months

Monday 12th January
quotequote all
It comes down to what does the conditions of employment say?

If I was working on past my normal working hours I would be working at a specific overtime rate but I don't think there is a national standard for it.
Clearly some people have a fixed salary and there is no hourly rate at all.

98elise

31,128 posts

182 months

Monday 12th January
quotequote all
MDMA . said:
98elise said:
It depends on the job. Supermarkets for example just pay a flat rate for every hour worked.
They don't.
To be pedantic some do, other may not. The one my son works at pays a flat hourly rate. You're contracted for x hours, which is in effect the minimum hours, but you work as many as you want. If you work beyond your contracted hours it's the same rate, and the same for working beyond what would be full time hours.

Type R Tom

Original Poster:

4,202 posts

170 months

Monday 12th January
quotequote all
Thanks for the input. It appears that there is no strong consensus, and this is likely a local agreement/policy issue.

As I said, I can see it from both sides, but just trying to get the best for her.

fooman

1,021 posts

85 months

Monday 12th January
quotequote all
I think it would be complex for many reasons to start paying rates based on when you started not the hours worked, it's probably fairer all round the supermarkets way.

MustangGT

13,631 posts

301 months

Sunday 18th January
quotequote all
With my company it is flat rate for any extra hours. If they work on a Sunday they get a flat £8 extra payment. For the OP, what does her contract say?

Countdown

46,828 posts

217 months

Monday 19th January
quotequote all
Type R Tom said:
Thanks for the input. It appears that there is no strong consensus, and this is likely a local agreement/policy issue.

As I said, I can see it from both sides, but just trying to get the best for her.
You're right. Another thing to mention is that over the last 20-30 years Supermarkets have cut and re-cut rates and contracts.

When I used to work at Asda back in the 80's you would get

Enhanced rates for eveining work (x1.3 between 7pm-10pm)
Enhanced rate for nights (x1.5 between 10pm and 7am)
Enhanced rates on Sundays and bank holidays (x2 plus TOIL)

Gradually these have been reduced and AIUI its minimal enhancements now for evening/night work.

mattvanders

421 posts

47 months

Monday 19th January
quotequote all
I’ve worked in heavy engineering in a maintenance role for the last 20 years. All the companies I work for were a standard day role with the ability to do overtime. General rule of thumb has been 1.5 pay for any midweek ot, and 2.0 for weekend work with bank holiday day still being paid regardless so would be 3.0 pay. When it comes to working a night shift some companies would pay extra and others wouldn’t which would reflect on who would be willing to stay late or go on to nights for a period of time. One place I worked paid an extra 25% for shift pay for working rotating 12 hour days and nights over the day worker role.

What I have found when looking else where for new jobs is that companies now days are less likely to offer a higher rate for ot work or with other caveats. Always an interesting interview when you say no to a job offer.

Gary C

14,569 posts

200 months

Monday 19th January
quotequote all
I just get paid a shift rate and am (well was) expected to work any extra shifts at an overtime rate.

Didn't matter if I did all nights or all days or weekends, all at the double time rate.