Which Umbrella Company
Author
Discussion

Venisonpie

Original Poster:

4,949 posts

113 months

Friday 7th August
quotequote all
I've unexpectedly been offered a 6 month contract (probably end up longer) supporting an ex employer via an agency and will be paid a day rate through an umbrella company. The recruitment agent has provided the names below as potential options - has anyone any experience of dealing with any of them, pro's/con's?

Parasol
Paystream
Focussed
Nasa
Sapphire
Workwell
Trafalgar
Giant

I've never done this before and so any experiences good/bad would be welcome.

JoeRRS

197 posts

189 months

Friday 7th August
quotequote all
Don't do it, whatever they promise it will save its almost guaranteed to come back and bite you later on and cost you more.

Go PAYE or if its going to be longer than 6 months go LTD.

Venisonpie

Original Poster:

4,949 posts

113 months

Friday 7th August
quotequote all
JoeRRS said:
Don't do it, whatever they promise it will save its almost guaranteed to come back and bite you later on and cost you more.

Go PAYE or if its going to be longer than 6 months go LTD.
OK, I'm ignorant here. I thought the umbrella company employed me paye? I've no interest in trying to avoid or minimise paying tax, just want a simple solution.

Semmelweiss

1,842 posts

227 months

Friday 7th August
quotequote all
JoeRRS said:
Don't do it, whatever they promise it will save its almost guaranteed to come back and bite you later on and cost you more.

Go PAYE or if its going to be longer than 6 months go LTD.
That's not the case, if you use a reputable one. Just stay away from any that are based in Isle of Man, owned by Baroness Mone's husband, or offer expenses, or loans.

I've used Clarity Umbrella for years when I was inside IR35. Just make sure it's https://www.clarityumbrella.co.uk/

lucy.smith@clarityumbrella.co.uk

Venisonpie

Original Poster:

4,949 posts

113 months

Friday 7th August
quotequote all
Semmelweiss said:
That's not the case, if you use a reputable one. Just stay away from any that are based in Isle of Man, owned by Baroness Mone's husband, or offer expenses, or loans.

I've used Clarity Umbrella for years when I was inside IR35. Just make sure it's https://www.clarityumbrella.co.uk/

lucy.smith@clarityumbrella.co.uk
Super, thanks for that. I suspect I will end up doing this sort of thing for several years and want to be totally above board.

JoeRRS

197 posts

189 months

Friday 7th August
quotequote all
Agree there for sure is some companies that are all above board, the company that I used was above board fully based in the UK etc but as Government changes laws and back dates certain aspects and 5 years later (in my case) you get hit with a huge bill, then pay accountants over 10k to argue the case to then get the bill halved I really dont think its worth it.

esuuv

1,421 posts

236 months

Friday 7th August
quotequote all
JoeRRS said:
Don't do it, whatever they promise it will save its almost guaranteed to come back and bite you later on and cost you more.

Go PAYE or if its going to be longer than 6 months go LTD.
This is completely back to front - if they formerly worked for them - and they go limited that's pretty much why IR35 exists.

Umbrella is PAYE - just remember in whatever rate you agree - you'll be paying your own employers NI.....

I used parasol for a few years while on an inside IR35 contract - was all pretty straightforward.

Venisonpie

Original Poster:

4,949 posts

113 months

Tuesday 13th October
quotequote all
Been a couple of months since starting the thread and my contract starts in a few weeks. The suggested umbrella companies have said their margin includes professional indemnity cover and public liability insurance for me however I'm confused as to why I need them if I'm an employee of said company. I'm waiting for sample employment contracts but don't want to be on the hook for anything as if I were a Ltd company.

Can anyone shed any light on this? TIA

danb79

13,966 posts

103 months

Tuesday 13th October
quotequote all
Can highly recommend Danbro - I've used them for years and put numerous contractors through them

https://www.danbro.co.uk/

Freakuk

4,897 posts

182 months

Tuesday 13th October
quotequote all
Paystream for me, been with them around 18 months and it's been seamless

theboss

7,570 posts

250 months

Tuesday 13th October
quotequote all
Venisonpie said:
Been a couple of months since starting the thread and my contract starts in a few weeks. The suggested umbrella companies have said their margin includes professional indemnity cover and public liability insurance for me however I'm confused as to why I need them if I'm an employee of said company. I'm waiting for sample employment contracts but don't want to be on the hook for anything as if I were a Ltd company.

Can anyone shed any light on this? TIA
You don’t become an employee of the end client - you’re an off-payroll worker to them - they get the flexible engagement upside without any employer obligations and the payroll formalities are taken care of by the umbrella. You’re “employed for tax purposes” as far as HMRC are concerned yet still a contractor as far as the engager is concerned.

dibblecorse

7,668 posts

223 months

Tuesday 13th October
quotequote all
ive recruited hundreds of contractors, many used Parasol, so many that when I went contracting they were my first port of call, well established, easy to use portal, no problems at all.

dibblecorse

7,668 posts

223 months

Tuesday 13th October
quotequote all
Venisonpie said:
Been a couple of months since starting the thread and my contract starts in a few weeks. The suggested umbrella companies have said their margin includes professional indemnity cover and public liability insurance for me however I'm confused as to why I need them if I'm an employee of said company. I'm waiting for sample employment contracts but don't want to be on the hook for anything as if I were a Ltd company.

Can anyone shed any light on this? TIA
You're only technically an employee and the end client will want you insured, that comes at a cost to Parasol, they pass a v small part of that cost onto you via their fee, its normal, in the same way if yiu work for Accenture and they send you outvto a client, they will have your activities insured but its built into their fee.

Ranger 6

7,740 posts

280 months

Wednesday 14th October
quotequote all
Freakuk said:
Paystream for me, been with them around 18 months and it's been seamless
4 years with them on various contracts - recommended

Austin Prefect

2,810 posts

23 months

Wednesday 14th October
quotequote all
I've used Trafalgar several times, no problems at all.

Venisonpie

Original Poster:

4,949 posts

113 months

Wednesday 14th October
quotequote all
dibblecorse said:
Venisonpie said:
Been a couple of months since starting the thread and my contract starts in a few weeks. The suggested umbrella companies have said their margin includes professional indemnity cover and public liability insurance for me however I'm confused as to why I need them if I'm an employee of said company. I'm waiting for sample employment contracts but don't want to be on the hook for anything as if I were a Ltd company.

Can anyone shed any light on this? TIA
You're only technically an employee and the end client will want you insured, that comes at a cost to Parasol, they pass a v small part of that cost onto you via their fee, its normal, in the same way if yiu work for Accenture and they send you outvto a client, they will have your activities insured but its built into their fee.
Ta, makes sense. I just don't want to be on the hook for anything, not that I intend to cock anything up.

127Sport

591 posts

3 months

Wednesday 14th October
quotequote all
esuuv said:
I used parasol for a few years while on an inside IR35 contract - was all pretty straightforward.
Me too. Seconded.

LemonParty

619 posts

267 months

Wednesday 14th October
quotequote all
Ranger 6 said:
Freakuk said:
Paystream for me, been with them around 18 months and it's been seamless
4 years with them on various contracts - recommended
Similar for me too, been with Paystream through three contracts back to back over the last few years. Seem to do the job - not great, not bad - just do what they're supposed to do.

Only payroll I had that went above and beyond was when the agency (TEKSystems) ran their own, and made everything seamless.

Venisonpie

Original Poster:

4,949 posts

113 months

Thursday 15th October
quotequote all
Ok, Parasol are unable to provide a sample contract ahead of signing up which is a no go unfortunately. My other option is Focused Group who do exactly the same thing and their t's and c's are agreeable. Has anyone any experience of using them?