Career pivot back to QS
Author
Discussion

Fusss

Original Poster:

294 posts

111 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
Currently working as Project Coordinator in manufacturing, been here approx. 10 years, earning 41k.

I originally trained and qualified as QS, but haven’t done this role day to day for over 15 years for various reasons. My last job I was Assistant QS, so never actually operated that much as a day to day fully fledged QS. Spent my days doing applications, variations, subby accounts etc.

I have the opportunity to go back into a manufacturing and installation company as QS for their commercial side for £50k plus bonuses. Same industry, so technically my knowledge of products is completely transferrable, but my hesitation is my lack of recent experience being a day to day QS.

Company is still local, so the commute is basically exactly the same as I currently do, so no issues there. Same hours.

Current job deals with accounts of projects I’m working on and variations etc, so im not completely going back in to alien territory here.

My knowledge of contract mechanism’s (JCT/NEC etc) is completely gone. I have expressed this to the potential new employer’s and they are still keen to get me on board. So raising variations in line with these contracts, EOT’s, delays etc I am not fully fledged at all.

They do not have any current QS’s and want someone to come in an oversee the commercial side of the business as they are now a bit overburdened and these tasks can’t effectively be done by the PM’s anymore.

Thoughts and advice, as an inexperienced QS am I walking into more than I can handle and deal with here? Or is this a great opportunity to go in and take control of something from scratch and make it work my way.

Career wise, I get that the move back in to this title is a no brainer, but there is also some pit falls and considerations to think about here.


_kitt_

2,572 posts

206 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
I'm not in your profession but can't you familarise yourself with the the parts of the role you're not so confident in? I am an accountant and spent 10 years out working in finance systems. I took a job as a Financial Controller leading systems, but also things like statutory audit production, the accounts to the various standards and managing operations... some of which I had no experience whatsoever in. I learnt quickly on the job and prepared as best I could before starting... 7 years later I am still doing this role and it's easy smile


_kitt_

2,572 posts

206 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
also to add the fact they want you, knowing your weakness, may be because they like you as a person and want you in their organisation. That is a great thing the behold, the job stuff can be learnt - go for it smile

Fusss

Original Poster:

294 posts

111 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
Yeah absolutely I've been reading back up on contracts and been looking at courses essentially for beginners again! Mulling it all over.

The pay increase is nice if not gigantic, but it's the potential future earnings and opportunities that are interesting me here also.

Very much maxed out my current position and progression.

Gary29

5,298 posts

130 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
If you have enthusiasm for the role, then go for it, sounds ideal.

Salary sounds like the lower end of the scale to me depending on what area you're in, so there may be some scope to ask for a better package if they really want you.

I deal with QS's on a daily basis, so I hate you all and it loathes me to wish you good luck, but I'll make an exception this time, good luck! biglaugh

Fusss

Original Poster:

294 posts

111 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
Hahaha thank you very much. I understand the hate!!

Yeah it's at the lower end but as I'm not a fully experienced QS I get it, and there is scope for improvement as I settle in to the role, plus bonuses as I originally asked for mid 50s.

What's helping me is also that they are probably not going to find a fully qualified experienced QS willing to go in for 50k.

smithyithy

7,952 posts

149 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
Sounds like a good move OP, especially as they seem keen to take you on knowing your relevant experience and background, I think that's a positive sign as it's not like you're fighting against a pool of 'current' QS applicants.

Is there any way you can fall back onto your qualification / training for a sort of top-up or refresher? Possibly through a professional body like RICS..

Lightweight79

34 posts

26 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
Sounds like a good move, with lots of opportunity to grow.

I wouldn't worry about the knowledge gap on contracts etc, I worked for the same company for 26 years, using bespoke in house contracts, never used an NEC / JCT etc in my life, when I left I just attended some on-line courses and learnt enough about the their individual mechanisms, ultimately AI can help you with this. Fundamentally most of the basic principles are the same - its the mechanisms, time periods etc that change.

The same with sector, some employers get fixated on you having past experience in the same sector, again the skills are the same you are just applying them differently.

Good luck if you do decide to move.

Fusss

Original Poster:

294 posts

111 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
I think I am baffling myself again with terminology and overthinking things regards contract mechanisms etc.

The fundamentals I know etc. Will just be slightly rusty.

The JCT NEC thing is the thing on my mind that worries me.

Walking in day one, getting one of those plonked on my desk and saying off you go.

Magic919

14,592 posts

232 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
A lot of techie types chronically overthink things.

You’ve told the new employer it’s a weak area and they have proceeded. Any sensible company will be supportive and help you get established. It’s quite normal to feel some nervousness with a new role, even without a company change. It’ll pass.

Focus on working out where your help and support comes from when you get through the door.

Fusss

Original Poster:

294 posts

111 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
All current sub contract work is currently "on a handshake"

Easy early win there. Set up a standard sub contract purchase order with generic T&Cs?

Fusss

Original Poster:

294 posts

111 months

Sunday 4th October
quotequote all
Curveball, interviewing for an Assistant QS position in a smaller firm but working under a Managing QS. 45k plus car allowance and bonus so could be a better way back in to with a bit of security above me, with a view to transitioning to QS ASAP

Will see how it goes

donnie85

139 posts

99 months

Sunday 4th October
quotequote all
Im a QS and tbh day to day your hardly ever have to get involved in contractual stuff so I wouldn't worry about it. Alot of contracts are bespoke anyway these days. JCT is easy peasy and NEC puts more responsibility on the project manager then the QS but like I say you will hardly ever get involved in contractual stuff....as long as you pay your subbies on time then you'll good. Only time need to get contractual is when kicking a subbie off the job if they are not performing.

It's a great career, very well paid and it's in such high demand as there is a massive shortage of QS's. It's really not a hard job at all. Can be argumentive at times but don't think it's particularly stressful. Take the job, do 18 months then get a much better paid QS job elsewhere as you'll be in demand. Good luck

Edited by donnie85 on Sunday 4th October 17:00

Sporky

12,570 posts

95 months

Sunday 4th October
quotequote all
_kitt_ said:
also to add the fact they want you, knowing your weakness, may be because they like you as a person and want you in their organisation. That is a great thing the behold, the job stuff can be learnt - go for it smile
I'd agree with this take.

Nice pay rise, and a company that's keen on you and knows where you'll need to pick things up again? Sounds grand.

Rob 131 Sport

4,984 posts

83 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
smithyithy said:
Sounds like a good move OP, especially as they seem keen to take you on knowing your relevant experience and background, I think that's a positive sign as it's not like you're fighting against a pool of 'current' QS applicants.

Is there any way you can fall back onto your qualification / training for a sort of top-up or refresher? Possibly through a professional body like RICS..
I am a Chartered Quantity Surveyor and would endorse the additional training suggestion.

donnie85

139 posts

99 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
smithyithy said:
Sounds like a good move OP, especially as they seem keen to take you on knowing your relevant experience and background, I think that's a positive sign as it's not like you're fighting against a pool of 'current' QS applicants.

Is there any way you can fall back onto your qualification / training for a sort of top-up or refresher? Possibly through a professional body like RICS..
RICS is one of the biggest scams ever. Absolute waste of time and he will learn nothing to make him ready to be a QS. Best way of learning is on the job

IAN1967

340 posts

201 months

Tuesday 6th October
quotequote all
If you originally trained as a QS then it sounds like you will know what your doing when/if you move.

I've been a QS, in construction, for 40 years and rarely had to rely on contractual matters, apart from setting up the initial contract etc, maybe that's due to who I worked for and their clients.

If you have told your employer that your rusty on contracts they may not see that as a problem, some people don't want to get bogged down with contractual issues, I never have done but when i've had to it doesnt take long to brush up or find the info online.


AlexC1981

5,859 posts

248 months

Tuesday 6th October
quotequote all
I imagine with AI these days you could feed it the entire contract and ask it questions.

I used it recently to help tidy up a pile of old enquiry documents that kept getting added to over the years. I fed it all the documents and told it to highlight the duplicated parts and discrepancies, which helped me to consolidate all the old stuff into a few new documents.

smithyithy

7,952 posts

149 months

Tuesday 6th October
quotequote all
IAN1967 said:
If you originally trained as a QS then it sounds like you will know what your doing when/if you move.

I've been a QS, in construction, for 40 years and rarely had to rely on contractual matters, apart from setting up the initial contract etc, maybe that's due to who I worked for and their clients.

If you have told your employer that your rusty on contracts they may not see that as a problem, some people don't want to get bogged down with contractual issues, I never have done but when i've had to it doesnt take long to brush up or find the info online.
I work in civils / construction, I find it's a bit of a mix and can depend on the specific industry, framework, company, client etc.

The majority of my work is design-based (civils / highways), as that's the core of my experience. I did a degree in construction quantity surveying and got chartered.

We tend to have Quantity Surveyors, and Commercial Managers as specific roles.. My design work tends to include QS activities anyway - take-offs, BoQs etc. Then I also do some commercial management on the side - sub-contracts, work orders etc.

I tend to find that nobody knows everything, but everybody knows something, if that makes sense laugh

You take on different responsibilities, gain experience etc. everyone has their own knowledge base then. It's rare that anyone does (or would need to) know one specific subject inside and out..

JuanCarlosFandango

9,873 posts

102 months

Thursday 8th October
quotequote all
On the face of it my first concern here would be that you got as far as Assistant QS last time and decided on something else. What has changed to make this now the career for you? Only you really know that. 

Second concern is that you are walking into a metaphorical minefield where the company will be in chaos commercially and it's getting out of hand as they grow. They want to hire someone to take all of that away and make it a smooth running cash machine, and they'll likely expect that to be done in 6 months. They are possibly also engaging more subcontractors and taking on bigger and more complicated contracts which sound great at the start but do place demands on the (currently non-existent) commercial function and provide the opportunity for potential mistakes. I know this story, but not how applicable it is in this situation.

It can be great, especially in a growing company where you get to build the processes and see the results. But it can also mean lots of headaches, lots of people saying it was all alright until that busy body showed up and some disappointment when the owners realise that making £30k on a £100k job doesn't mean you'll automatically make £300k on a £1m job. Things do get more complicated and contractual.  And you won't get there in 6 months. 

You have, by the sounds of it, the added difficulty of the fact that you have been out of it for 10 years and don't have a deep technical knowledge to fall back on. No doubt you're capable enough in the long run, but are they actually willing to bear with that and swallow the possibly costly mistakes. Part of me thinks they should be paying a bit more and hiring someone from the type of business they want to be in 5 years, and knows exactly what it looks like. That said, they've obviously seen something in you they like and that's a huge headstart. 

I'd be looking at a couple of things:

1. Are they prepared to engage a consultancy or someone else who really knows the detail, who can double check your documents and processes to make sure they're set up correctly.

2. Will you have the admin support so that you're not trying to do all this on top of chasing timesheets, processing orders and the myriad of other functions which can fall under commercial.