Warranty Claim (with Excess) or Indy Repair?
Warranty Claim (with Excess) or Indy Repair?
Author
Discussion

omniflow

Original Poster:

3,701 posts

177 months

Saturday 28th January 2012
quotequote all
I currently have 3 issues with my E61 M5:

1. Level Control System Failure - Caused by water ingress. It's either a faulty electronic module or dodgy connections to the relay due to electrolysis, possibly both. This was temporarily resolved, but has returned.
2. Randomly opening boot glass
3. Very weedy horn

I have an insurance backed "BMW" warranty with a £250 excess (not my choice, the guy I brought the car off chose that option).

My gut instinct is to take it to an Indy and just pay for the work, but would I be better off getting it done by a dealer? I'm really after the right balance of lack of hassle / stress, cost and long term stability.

Any advice welcome.

Thanks

ecain63

10,647 posts

201 months

Saturday 28th January 2012
quotequote all
As mentioned before: tailgate wiring.

Get it checked and covered by warranty. It's a fairly big job for an indy to replace the harnesses.

Eddie

sinizter

3,348 posts

212 months

Saturday 28th January 2012
quotequote all
If the excess will cover all of them at the same time, surely it is the best option ?

ecain63

10,647 posts

201 months

Saturday 28th January 2012
quotequote all
£1300 was the potential bill from BMW for the harness replacement last year. Just do you know.

Eddie

mblade123

533 posts

218 months

Saturday 28th January 2012
quotequote all
If you take it to BMW for all the problems in one go your excess will be £250 in total and not £250 per item.
Bargin when you consider just over 2 hours labour at most BMW garages would swollow £250

Bubba Zanetti

736 posts

173 months

Tuesday 31st January 2012
quotequote all
The only reason you would go to a specialist in this case is if they could fix everything for less than £250.

I doubt they could, so go to the dealer, pay £250 and they will/should pick up the rest of the cost.