What would you do ?

What would you do ?

Author
Discussion

360stimo

Original Poster:

701 posts

230 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Before my M3 got stolen i was thinking about changing my everyday car. Now its been stolen i have deff decided that when it comes back, in perfect condition, i will sell it straight away. My choice now is what to replace it with.

1) Buy a black M3 CSL straight away

2) Use a B3 3.3 Alpina for 6 months and then think about M6, M5, Audi RS4

I guess the obvious answer is that i need to drive a CSL, M5, M6 and see which one i would prefer. Im leaning towards the M6 as it would be different to what i have had before, but for the same reason, not sure if i want a big heavy car.

What would you do ?


Edited by 360stimo on Friday 2nd February 10:45

Jason_W

905 posts

209 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
I'd probably go with the black CSL as I've no experience of the others, although in my opinion the M5 is the ultimate 'sleeper' and the current M3 is coming up for replacement.

I agree with your decision to bin your current vehicle - too much like sloppy seconds for my liking. Nice decision to have to make though.

snooglefinder

63 posts

227 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Personally I would also go for the black CSL - huge fan of these.

I do also massively respect the M5 and if I had kids this might sway me put otherwise what advantage does it have over the M3 CSL?

New M3 in March though so you could get caught if you buy one now..........

Zod

35,295 posts

260 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
buy the CSL.

I bought the M5 when I became a father and I love it, but the cSL is the one that really makes the heart race.

Brink

1,505 posts

210 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
RS6 and put a big "M" on the back.

:joke:

360stimo

Original Poster:

701 posts

230 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Interesting that no one has said go for the M6 or mentioned it.

How will the new M3 effect CSL prices, anyone have an opinion ?

spicjt

192 posts

210 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
mate, go for the M5. All of them are nice motors, and it is a hard one. If I was lucky enough to have the choice, the M5 would be the one however!! Black of course!

I drove the RS4 at Silverstone recently, and nice motor, but I found it lacked that 'rush' my older E36 M3 gave me!

Jase

M5Dave

829 posts

211 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
As you can probably tell I'm an M5 fan, but out of that lot I'd definately go for the CSL.
I think it has a real sense of purpose about it, and looks absolutely fantastic in black.

Another advantage is that prices seem to have levelled out, so you might not lose much over a couple of years. I don't think that will be the case with an M5 or M6.

john_r

8,353 posts

273 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
360stimo said:
Interesting that no one has said go for the M6 or mentioned it.

How will the new M3 effect CSL prices, anyone have an opinion ?


When I was in the showroom a couple of days before collecting the M5 (they remembered I had to pay - damn!!), I was looking around a brand new M3 Cab; all shiny and stunning under the lights - told the sales guy I thought it was gorgeous and his off the cuff comment was "yeah but the arse'll fall out of the value when the new one comes out..."

M5Dave

829 posts

211 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
john_r said:
360stimo said:
Interesting that no one has said go for the M6 or mentioned it.

How will the new M3 effect CSL prices, anyone have an opinion ?


When I was in the showroom a couple of days before collecting the M5 (they remembered I had to pay - damn!!), I was looking around a brand new M3 Cab; all shiny and stunning under the lights - told the sales guy I thought it was gorgeous and his off the cuff comment was "yeah but the arse'll fall out of the value when the new one comes out..."


I dont think the arrival of the new M3 will hit the CSL as hard as it will the standard car.
The CSL was a limited production run, and is a more raw and driver focused car that appeals to a very particular audience.

The new car is likely to add more equipment and refinement, and as a consequence weight than the current car, in order to make it easier to drive and to appeal to as wide an audience as possible.

I think CSL prices will remain steady until such times as BMW build a lightweight version of the new car. Even then the CSL's rarity will ensure prices never hit rock bottom.

Ashok

602 posts

261 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Depends on your budget and needs.

If you've 50k then get a used M6 - a bargain and an absolute stonker of a car (and a "current" model unlike the CSL).

I like the CSL a lot but it's a bit too hardcore as a daily driver.

The M5 is perfect if you need the space like me.

360stimo

Original Poster:

701 posts

230 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Doesn't seem to be many black CSL's around.

Belleair302

6,879 posts

209 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Buy an M5 or M6 and put on a decent aftermarket set of brakes, ie AP or Mov'it.de! If you want a fast track car go and buy a 911 or an Ultima! CSL's are hard to live with on a day to day basis and cost a fortune to run.

DoctorD

1,542 posts

258 months

Saturday 3rd February 2007
quotequote all
360stimo said:
Doesn't seem to be many black CSL's around.


Around 25% of the 422 cars imported were saphire black.