No more Z4M's only the 3.5 petrol - comments
No more Z4M's only the 3.5 petrol - comments
Author
Discussion

oblio

Original Poster:

5,573 posts

251 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2011
quotequote all
Hi

Does anyone have any views on this?

I believe that the 'new' Z4 does not come as an M variant and the 3.5l engine is the top spec. Has anyone driven both and can they comment on this - speed,accelaration, handling etc?

ta


clabcon

325 posts

229 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2011
quotequote all
oblio said:
Hi

Does anyone have any views on this?

I believe that the 'new' Z4 does not come as an M variant and the 3.5l engine is the top spec. Has anyone driven both and can they comment on this - speed,accelaration, handling etc?

ta
You can't spell, realise that it's actually a 3.0 twin turbo engine and fail to comment on the 100kg+ weight gain.

oblio

Original Poster:

5,573 posts

251 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2011
quotequote all
Ok - acceleration (pedant rolleyes)

Apologies on the engine size - my error

In your opinion what difference does the weight make?


Edited to add: Have I got this right? I was told by a dealer that the Z4 was no longer available in an M version however various BMW websites still have them on? I'm confused...frown

Edited by oblio on Tuesday 22 February 13:14

AliV6

685 posts

212 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2011
quotequote all
Think 08 was the last Z4M. Maybe a few to escape that...58'

carl_w

10,490 posts

282 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2011
quotequote all
I believe the weight gain is some 200kg, particularly when comparing to the alloy-engined non-M E85/6 Z4.

sixspeed

2,062 posts

296 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2011
quotequote all
They also said there would be no E85/86 Z4M....

M5Dave

829 posts

233 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2011
quotequote all
oblio said:
Edited to add: Have I got this right? I was told by a dealer that the Z4 was no longer available in an M version however various BMW websites still have them on? I'm confused...frown

Edited by oblio on Tuesday 22 February 13:14
I suspect what the BMW website is listing is the 'M Sport' version of the Z4, which usually consists of a bodykit, uprated wheels and suspension, and a couple of other bits and pieces.

There is definately no actual M Power version of the new Z4 as yet. The closest you'll get is the 35iS version which has the engine uprated to 340bhp and the DCT gearbox.

I don't think it will lose much, if anything, in straight line speed to the old Z4M, but I think it will major on ease of use and refinement, and lack the raw, back to basics feel that people loved about the old car.

Wiggwam

92 posts

225 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2011
quotequote all
carl_w said:
I believe the weight gain is some 200kg, particularly when comparing to the alloy-engined non-M E85/6 Z4.
Yup. Z4m Coupe = 1,425kg or Z4 roadster = 1,450kg. New Z4 sDrive 35i = 1,600kg.

Will be close in a straightline due to the extra torque and flatter power band in the new Z4, but that amount of weight when it gets twisty is going to really hurt in comparison... Oh and the noise is on a whole different planet for the old M's.. :-)

The only way I see the Z4 making its way into the M line up is for them to make it a fixed coupe and drop a load of weight and maybe sneak a bit more power from the current engine. We know with the new 1 Coupe M thing that the old na engines are a thing of the past now :-(

Having said that, with the X5 and X6M's in the line up, maybe they will just turn up the power even more and just slap a load of M badges on it...

pilchardthecat

7,483 posts

203 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2011
quotequote all
Wiggwam said:
Yup. Z4m Coupe = 1,425kg or Z4 roadster = 1,450kg. New Z4 sDrive 35i = 1,600kg.
...
Almost, but the Z4M Roadster is actually 22kg lighter than the coupe version.

carl_w

10,490 posts

282 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2011
quotequote all
pilchardthecat said:
Almost, but the Z4M Roadster is actually 22kg lighter than the coupe version.
Not with the hair straighteners and the peroxide on board it isn't

playalistic

2,270 posts

188 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2011
quotequote all
carl_w said:
ot with the hair straighteners and the peroxide on board it isn't
You can borrow my can opener if it bothers you that much thumbup

KENZ

1,229 posts

217 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2011
quotequote all
Most important no mechanical diff on any of the new Z4's.

oblio

Original Poster:

5,573 posts

251 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2011
quotequote all
M5Dave said:
I suspect what the BMW website is listing is the 'M Sport' version of the Z4, which usually consists of a bodykit, uprated wheels and suspension, and a couple of other bits and pieces.

There is definately no actual M Power version of the new Z4 as yet. The closest you'll get is the 35iS version which has the engine uprated to 340bhp and the DCT gearbox.

I don't think it will lose much, if anything, in straight line speed to the old Z4M, but I think it will major on ease of use and refinement, and lack the raw, back to basics feel that people loved about the old car.
Thanks M5Dave

That does help explain my confusion getmecoat

Wiggwam

92 posts

225 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2011
quotequote all
pilchardthecat said:
Wiggwam said:
Yup. Z4m Coupe = 1,425kg or Z4 roadster = 1,450kg. New Z4 sDrive 35i = 1,600kg.
...
Almost, but the Z4M Roadster is actually 22kg lighter than the coupe version.
Ah... just lifted those numbers straight from the 'Knowledge' Section of Evo... still 22kg is no biggy and still at least 150kg lighter than the new version...

physprof

996 posts

211 months

Sunday 27th February 2011
quotequote all
I said this a while back... look at list + desireable options on Z4-35i whatever it is... to then segment a proper M version your into 50K territory. so unlikely to see a new Z4M.

also bear in mind the old Z4M was substantially differentiated from the other z4s ..... the engine, the M diff, non runflats, non-electric steering, CSL dervied suspension, floating cross-drilled large brakes...

tjlazer

875 posts

198 months

Monday 28th February 2011
quotequote all
The owner's manual quotes weights of 1453kg on the MR and 1465kg on the MC. I'm not sure where EVO gets any of its info from but basically there's not much in it. Shame BM didn't try and get near or better than this weight for the new model, I think that's why the E89 seems to be struggling to win over the existing z4 owners like me. Most of the reviews indicate that the weight gain has blunted the handling even if ride comfort is meant to be considerably improved.

sixspeed

2,062 posts

296 months

Monday 28th February 2011
quotequote all
physprof said:
I said this a while back... look at list + desireable options on Z4-35i whatever it is... to then segment a proper M version your into 50K territory. so unlikely to see a new Z4M.

also bear in mind the old Z4M was substantially differentiated from the other z4s ..... the engine, the M diff, non runflats, non-electric steering, CSL dervied suspension, floating cross-drilled large brakes...
Really? A Z4 with the new 4.0 V8 isn't worth 50k? I'm sure if it were to go ahead it would also carry across some of the M3 running gear like the original Z4M did.

What was the E46 M3 list price... somewhere ITRO £48k when new? The Z4M/C around £42k?

So if the E90/2 M3 is pushing the high 50s, then a Z4M would quite easily sit in the low 50k bracket.




physprof

996 posts

211 months

Monday 28th February 2011
quotequote all
sixspeed said:
physprof said:
I said this a while back... look at list + desireable options on Z4-35i whatever it is... to then segment a proper M version your into 50K territory. so unlikely to see a new Z4M.

also bear in mind the old Z4M was substantially differentiated from the other z4s ..... the engine, the M diff, non runflats, non-electric steering, CSL dervied suspension, floating cross-drilled large brakes...
Really? A Z4 with the new 4.0 V8 isn't worth 50k? I'm sure if it were to go ahead it would also carry across some of the M3 running gear like the original Z4M did.

What was the E46 M3 list price... somewhere ITRO £48k when new? The Z4M/C around £42k?

So if the E90/2 M3 is pushing the high 50s, then a Z4M would quite easily sit in the low 50k bracket.
sixspeed the 35is is 45.2K without options, a 3K premium on the 35i.

so at a minimum you, as noted, are looking at mid 50's for a V8 Zed plus what you'd option... attractive as such a car would be I'd wager BMW are trying to square off demand for a near 911 price rivalling zed with size of market for such a car. The relatively few ZedMs that there were that lead to the excellent window as a second hand car circa 2008 (Mine was 22.5K with 24k mile AUC and loaded - original invoice 49K) showed that as a new propositon market was heavily constrained and in all liklihood would lead to loss of sales from M3 coupe/cab rather than securing sales from eqivalents e.g SLK55 or Carerra 2s Once your in the mid to high fifties - is it that much of a stretch to a carerra 2... my guess that was part reason M£ drifted in price was to get downsizers who saw V8 at 10K discount as attractive for the slightly less prestige badge