If mx5's didn't exist......
If mx5's didn't exist......
Author
Discussion

Dave^

Original Poster:

7,787 posts

275 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
.....what would you have instead?

NiceCupOfTea

25,527 posts

273 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
Chimaera or TVR S. Or 944 Turbo/S2

I would have changed for one already but I have a niggling suspicion they might not handle so well frown Also I think I would miss wringing the last 0.5 bhp out of it and flinging it around corners. I would end up buried in a hedge if I tried that in a Tiv frown

Haze

1,531 posts

252 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
MR2 Roadster for me.

Dan_1981

17,937 posts

221 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
Ridiculous as it sounds probably either an Evo 5/6 or Legacy GTB.

Odd eh?

Fruitcake

3,850 posts

248 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
An MGF or a FIAT Barchetta, as I've a real soft spot for both cars.

snotrag

15,468 posts

233 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
Good thread.

I'd like to say the same as NCOT. Those are certainly the 2 main contenders I'd like to update to one day.

But realistically...

The MX5 is like 'my first sportscar', its accessible. if that option hadnt been available to me, I may never have understood that driving a proper sports car is about more than the numbers. The spur of the moment, roof down, radio up, clear road ahead moments.

without experiencing that I would be like the vast majority of people (the typical 'its a girls car' people) who just dont get it.

Thus, I'd probably be driving some form of regular, boring old car, a fast hatchback or something.



Fruitcake

3,850 posts

248 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
The other side of this is, how many subsequent sports cars owe their existence to the Mazda? Would Rover have made the MGF like they did if the MX-5 didn't exist?

What would other sports car manufacturers (e.g. Lotus) be doing if the Mazda hadn't come along?

I don't really like 'what ifs' but if things were the same, sans MX-5, then probably an MGF. And having never driven an MX-5, I'd probably be very happy with it.

snotrag

15,468 posts

233 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
Fruitcake said:
Probably an MGF. And having never driven an MX-5, I'd probably be very happy with it.
:cringe:

hehe

Edited by snotrag on Sunday 13th September 15:36

OnlyMX5ives

1,142 posts

214 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
MR2 Roadster
Boxster
Supercharged S2000
Chimera
968 Cabrio

As thay are all cars I've considered getting at various times over the years I've had my SC'd 5.

BCA

8,651 posts

279 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
Clio 172.

trooperiziz

9,457 posts

274 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
Or 944 Turbo/S2
Doesn't have to be a replacement...

The new addition to Trooper Towers: biggrin





She needs a bit of work, as she is a little tatty inside and the idle speed is all over the shop, but a trip to promax should sort that.
Currently running a verified 281.4 BHP and 325 ft/pounds, and I have the link kit and a bigger turbo from the T250 model which should pump it up to close to around 330-350 BHP biggrin

Just driven her down from Manchester today and she certainly shifts!

Perfect companion to an MX5 I think.

GravelBen

16,316 posts

252 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
Dan_1981 said:
Ridiculous as it sounds probably either an Evo 5/6 or Legacy GTB.

Odd eh?
hehe

I have a GTB and an MX5 which is a great combination, but a single-car alternative would be an STi-RA or Spec-C Impreza.

The other car I considered for the same job when I bought the MX5 was an MR2, still wouldn't mind one to try the mind-engined 'thing' at some stage. A 944 would be nice too but even older 2.5s are a price bracket above in NZ, and S2/turbos much more again.

MX-5 Lazza

7,954 posts

241 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
Difficult one to answer that. My current car was bought with the intention of adding the mods I have because I knewi over these cars after owning a Mk1 for 7 years. If I changed the question a bit to say what car I might have if my current car wasn't available ie they stopped making 5s after the Mk1 then I'd have to say Boxster or more likely Elise.

If the MX5 was never available then I'd probably have started with a Mk1 or Mk2 MR2 and have moved on to a Boxster or Elise by now.

Mr POD

5,153 posts

214 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
Fiat X19 with lancia engine.
Spitfire with XE
Midget with Metro Turbo Engine

Quick silver

1,387 posts

221 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
If the MX5/Roadster didn't exist I wouldn't have bothered with anything other than my 4x4's & motorcycles...........it's the only reason I went after a small sports car in the first place.


ETA: I take that back - I've always fancied an AC Cobra but they're hardly 10 a penny are they!


Edited by Quick silver on Monday 14th September 00:09

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

231 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
PGO Cevennes smile

OllieWinchester

5,694 posts

214 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
God knows.

If my car disappeared tomorrow I've got a bit of an urge for a Swedish turbo barge, so either some sort of Saab (probably a 9000 or a 9-3) or a V70/S70 T5 or maybe even a 740 Turbo.

paulmurr

4,203 posts

234 months

Monday 14th September 2009
quotequote all
An Elise.

Gizmo!

18,150 posts

231 months

Monday 14th September 2009
quotequote all
Probably an MR2 Turbo T-Bar...

franv8

2,212 posts

260 months

Monday 14th September 2009
quotequote all
Probably an MR2 Turbo non T Bar!