Gearboxes for turboed fives
Gearboxes for turboed fives
Author
Discussion

piefacemate

Original Poster:

592 posts

194 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
I know that the standard engine internals are good for around 250bhp before swapping out pistons and conrods, but how do gearboxes stand?

My car has around 120k miles on it's gearbox, which has had a fluid change but is otherwise standard. How further can the gearbox be pushed? What options are available to replace it? I've seen that Quaife do a box, but they're not exactly cheap.

Cheers,

Chris

Gizmo!

18,150 posts

232 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
I've never heard of anyone needing to change one. People upgrade clutches to the 1.8 unit, but apart from that...

MX-5 Lazza

7,954 posts

242 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
As Gizmo (one of my cats is called Gizmo - you aren't a small black & white female short hair with a habit of rolling in the litter tray are you?) said, the weakest link will be the 1.6 clutch followed by the dif. If you aren't breaking either of them I wouldn't worry about it.

MixxyMatosis

388 posts

192 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
Out of curiosity, is the torsen LSD diff any stronger that the normal one?

piefacemate

Original Poster:

592 posts

194 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies so far.

I'm not worried about my clutch as I'm running an updated ACT unit rated at circa 350ft/lbs of torque; the standard clutches will take mild boost (150bhp ish) but don't work with 200bhp applications for very long!

I'm not convinced by the 'don't worry about it till it breaks' approach; doesn't an explosive gearbox take other bits of the car with it?

Since the handling, brakes etc. are all suitable for taking the car much faster, I'm curious what the next bottleneck would likely be. An engine rebuild with uprated pistons and conrods is expensive, but affordable, provided I don't have to replace gearboxes, diffs, clutches etc. after the powerboost. I would love to attempt to break the 300bhp mark, but I'd only got for it fully understanding the costs and risk involved.

Hope this clarifies the question a little!

Gizmo!

18,150 posts

232 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
I've not spent much time there myself, but miataturbo.net and the FI forum on MX5Nutz will probably be helpful.

piefacemate

Original Poster:

592 posts

194 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
Good shout on miataturbo, hadn't looked there.

Seems the general consensus is the 5 speed holds till 300ish, the 6 speed after that... Until you get to silly speeds then you're onto Quaife dogboxes!

Still interested in what turbo ph member real world experience looks like?

The Tea Boy

4,129 posts

258 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
Could be worth giving Steve at 5 Speed in Nottingham a call (01159 64 21 02)about his project car 'Christine' running silly bhp and has done the full learning curve, very nice chap and very knowledgeable.

MrV

2,748 posts

251 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
piefacemate said:
Good shout on miataturbo, hadn't looked there.

Seems the general consensus is the 5 speed holds till 300ish, the 6 speed after that... Until you get to silly speeds then you're onto Quaife dogboxes!

Still interested in what turbo ph member real world experience looks like?
The problem with the FI MK1 is your run out of gears/diff before your engine will run out of puff smileor thats the problem I have at the moment 135mph is the max mine hits,thats running on a standard gearbox but uprated diff and after 3 years its still fine

I am not running that high HP about 190/95 though so maybe the extra 100 on top will kill it quicker.

GravelBen

16,326 posts

253 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
There are a good few in NZ running 250+bhp reliably through standard 5-speed boxes and 1.6 diffs, they're really not as weak as the internet rumour mill would suggest! One bloke gives his absolute death (drags, burnout comps! etc) to see how much it takes to kill the 1.6 diff but hasn't succeeded yet. I wouldn't mind an LSD with a bit more locking action though.

Mine has a low-miles 5-speed from an NB but tbh I preferred the shift action of my old '89 (140k miles) with its original box, this one doesn't seem to like being rushed.

Edited by GravelBen on Monday 17th May 21:02

piefacemate

Original Poster:

592 posts

194 months

Monday 17th May 2010
quotequote all
Excellent, sounds like going mental might be more affordable than initially though!

If only my talent was as easily upgradable as a gearbox... biggrin

OnlyMX5ives

1,142 posts

215 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
Torque is what kills things rather than BHP.

But around 230lbs things start getting borderline - depending how much mechanical sympathy you have.

My FM2 is on its 3rd gearbox, albeit the second was probably due to the pi$$ poor fitting (before I bought it).