Discussion
Similar to the expression in Poker, is there a watch out there that could persuade you to go 'all in', in the sense that you'd sell your entire collection, or at least a vast majority of it, in order to fund one grail?
I suppose it's a difficult one to answer, as it all depends on the size and value of your collection, as well as the cost of your potential grail. So, in easier terms, is there one watch that you could live with day-to-day, for all occasions? If so, what would it be?
Has anyone downsized their collection to just 1 or 2 watches? Do you feel better for having less? Do you feel you miss out on the variety that other pieces bring? If so, did you get bored of your grail watch?
Just wondering, as you do at midnight!
I suppose it's a difficult one to answer, as it all depends on the size and value of your collection, as well as the cost of your potential grail. So, in easier terms, is there one watch that you could live with day-to-day, for all occasions? If so, what would it be?
Has anyone downsized their collection to just 1 or 2 watches? Do you feel better for having less? Do you feel you miss out on the variety that other pieces bring? If so, did you get bored of your grail watch?

Just wondering, as you do at midnight!

There's one particular Richard Mille i'd have in a heartbeat if I could afford it without worrying about having so much capital tied up in a watch.
I usually always p/ex when I upgrade a watch, but there's nothing that'd make me ditch my whole collection - for all it's pretty modest there's a few watches in there that I wouldn't part with for various reasons - largely sentimental ones.
I usually always p/ex when I upgrade a watch, but there's nothing that'd make me ditch my whole collection - for all it's pretty modest there's a few watches in there that I wouldn't part with for various reasons - largely sentimental ones.
A Sinn EZM1 LE would do me nicely as a half way realistic grail, though (I think) everything would have to go and then some in order to fund one and that's something I couldn't do, I get too much enjoyment through having the options that I have and knowing that I've got all bases covered - though I'm sure that there's a niche or two more I could think of if I put my mind to it
. An Omega 2252.50 is more of a possibility, I've admired these for a long time, though I'd have to sell on either a couple of watches I'm not prepared to sell or most of my others... If I was to slim down the collection, say to 5-6 watches from the 12 now, that'd probably be the route I'd go down. I don't think that I could ever go down to just the 1 watch and whilst I own a few, IMO, quality pieces I think it'd be fair to say that I'm choosing quantity over quality right now 
I've also sold on (with no regrets, yet) a watch or two that I'd previously attached the word "keeper" to, so I'm reluctant to ever use that phrase again. I'm also wary of obtaining a grail and it turning out to be a case of "never meet your hero/s", I'd hate to sell watches on that I enjoy only to end up regretting it.
. An Omega 2252.50 is more of a possibility, I've admired these for a long time, though I'd have to sell on either a couple of watches I'm not prepared to sell or most of my others... If I was to slim down the collection, say to 5-6 watches from the 12 now, that'd probably be the route I'd go down. I don't think that I could ever go down to just the 1 watch and whilst I own a few, IMO, quality pieces I think it'd be fair to say that I'm choosing quantity over quality right now 
I've also sold on (with no regrets, yet) a watch or two that I'd previously attached the word "keeper" to, so I'm reluctant to ever use that phrase again. I'm also wary of obtaining a grail and it turning out to be a case of "never meet your hero/s", I'd hate to sell watches on that I enjoy only to end up regretting it.
Edited by CardShark on Tuesday 17th April 03:18
A military submariner, with a traceable history to some interesting places. SAS or SBS.
or, Ed White's Speedmaster. Sold in the mid/late 1990s for $30k or so I think.
I dont think my collection would stretch to either of these though, all-in or not!
In terms of reducing collection size - I've promised myself I'll only have 7 proper watches (plus my Granddads gold watch, and my Riseman). One for every day of the week seems like a sensible place to stop! I might move my 21st birthday watch into the 'not counted' section though
or, Ed White's Speedmaster. Sold in the mid/late 1990s for $30k or so I think.
I dont think my collection would stretch to either of these though, all-in or not!
In terms of reducing collection size - I've promised myself I'll only have 7 proper watches (plus my Granddads gold watch, and my Riseman). One for every day of the week seems like a sensible place to stop! I might move my 21st birthday watch into the 'not counted' section though

Probably already have mine if I'm honest, as per CardShark, but if it was a watch to have apart from my 'wear every day' watch, so a collection of one as it were, it would probably be a Universal Geneve Cairelli Tipo HA-1.

24hr, military issued, astro-navigational, 16min mono-pusher chronograph.

24hr, military issued, astro-navigational, 16min mono-pusher chronograph.
Hoofy said:
What a ridiculous question. 1 watch. WTF???

CarkShark said:
I'm also wary of obtaining a grail and it turning out to be a case of "never meet your hero/s", I'd hate to sell watches on that I enjoy only to end up regretting it.
That would concern me greatly too. The problem is, several minutes in a boutique is nowhere near enough time to come to a decision as to whether the watch is for you ... Display windows and bright artificial lighting in jewelers is completely different being on your wrist, in everyday surroundings.I do like variety, but I can't help but think that a single watch would be rather nice ... I really fancy a JLC, but it would most likely be an 'all in' affair.
I doubt I could back to having one watch again.
If I did, I'd probably just stick on my well worn Seiko (had since my 18th and worn daily until a couple of years ago) and be done with it.
I don't really think I have a grail as such; even things I would really love (a JLC being 'it' for me) aren't really daily wearers, so an SMP or an Explorer II would do me just fine. Either of those are probably as close as I would get.
If I did, I'd probably just stick on my well worn Seiko (had since my 18th and worn daily until a couple of years ago) and be done with it.
I don't really think I have a grail as such; even things I would really love (a JLC being 'it' for me) aren't really daily wearers, so an SMP or an Explorer II would do me just fine. Either of those are probably as close as I would get.

I hear mention of 'grails' all the time as regards watches. Its a term that always slightly grates with me, maybe becuase its used too freely nowadays hence its significance is lost.
In summary I dont think it exists, you may think it does, you may sell 8 watches to buy one that is a stretch for you. But you will get used to it and move on at somepoint to another 'grail' and so on and so on
I know not of anyone that has purchased a 'grail' watch and not bought another one afterwards...the term grail really seems to just be used to express a high value item in relation to what you already have it seems.
Anyone involved with watches will keep adding to their collection along the way, maybe they will sell some to fund a new one, but whatever, dont ever think you will sell 'all' your watches currently owned to buy a 'grail' piece and then remain sated for the rest of your life..I no of no one thats done that, know plenty that thought that,or rather used it as an excuse to themselves to buy a high value item that was just that little bit out of reach.
In fact in summary I think it was Enzo ferrari said it best:- when asked what was his favourite ferrari, he replied ' the next one'
I think most watch enthusiasts would do well to remember that!
In summary I dont think it exists, you may think it does, you may sell 8 watches to buy one that is a stretch for you. But you will get used to it and move on at somepoint to another 'grail' and so on and so on
I know not of anyone that has purchased a 'grail' watch and not bought another one afterwards...the term grail really seems to just be used to express a high value item in relation to what you already have it seems.
Anyone involved with watches will keep adding to their collection along the way, maybe they will sell some to fund a new one, but whatever, dont ever think you will sell 'all' your watches currently owned to buy a 'grail' piece and then remain sated for the rest of your life..I no of no one thats done that, know plenty that thought that,or rather used it as an excuse to themselves to buy a high value item that was just that little bit out of reach.
In fact in summary I think it was Enzo ferrari said it best:- when asked what was his favourite ferrari, he replied ' the next one'
I think most watch enthusiasts would do well to remember that!
Edited by chris5150 on Wednesday 18th April 12:49
Just out of interest, the term 'grail' in relation to watches was first coined by a prolific collector, Chuck Maddox, in relation to a particular watch he'd wanted for a while but found hard to track down - something like two years. It had little to do with value as such, and much more to do with lengthy searching. The watch in question was also a bit a pinnacle for him as he was an avid Omega fan and also loved chronographs with a soft spot for the Lemania family in particular. The Speedmaster 376.0822 he eventually found was thus an intersection of two or three things he really liked.
It is a bit over-used and it's meaning has slipped I think, but like 'bi-compax', it's original meaning is lost, but popular culture has given it new meaning.
It is a bit over-used and it's meaning has slipped I think, but like 'bi-compax', it's original meaning is lost, but popular culture has given it new meaning.
Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




