Rolex sues US retailer for counterfeiting parts.......
Rolex sues US retailer for counterfeiting parts.......
Author
Discussion

RDMcG

Original Poster:

20,916 posts

238 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-rolex-lawsui...

An interesting variant on the usual Chinese tat.

Spice_Weasel

2,369 posts

284 months

Thursday 9th August 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for posting. It will be interesting to see the outcome on this. As an independent dealer, Melrose appears to be outsourcing its servicing to other firms so has little control on where replacement parts are sourced from.

I think as a buyer, I would be upset and angry if I bought a watch from them which contained non-manufacturer parts. If you are buying a Rolex then I think you are buying into the whole in-house movement story, assuming you are not just buying for the label and diamond-encrusted wrist bling. With a bought in movement (let's say a 7750) service parts are readily available, at least until Swatch Group totally halt production of ETA movements for non-group brands. Would any of us know if any of our watches, serviced by an independent, contained non-ETA parts? Would we worry, given we had used an independent?

This year, we decided not to renew the Porsche warranty on our Cayenne. The brakes needed replacing and we used an independent who fitted OEM parts as opposed to parts stamped with a Porsche part number. The cost saving was considerable, the servicer is reputable and the parts can be relied upon. Porsche, however, would invalidate their warranty (if it was still in place) if they discovered the non-Porsche parts fitted. I don't see Porsche GB suing the independents for selling cars with non-Porsche brake disks just yet, however!



I read your 991 review article recently. Very well written and a joy to read!

Dominic H

3,289 posts

263 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
It's not the use of pattern parts in a service that Rolex is taking issue with. It's Melrose use of non-original parts as a whole. For example look at this ladies steel & gold Rolex Datejust.

http://www.melrose.com/ladies2-tone-jubilee-slv--s...



The watch is a 6900 series, which is probably late 1960's/early 1970's. The bracelet is an 'Italian made' jubilee item, the dial is re-finished original custom set with diamonds, the bezel is custom made and an after market sapphire glass has been fitted. This leaves probably only the case middle, case back and the movement as original Rolex parts. This is the issue Rolex is taking with Melrose.

Spice_Weasel

2,369 posts

284 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Aah, thanks Dominic. So it's way more than I thought!

sneijder

5,231 posts

265 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
The fact they state they have counterfeited the crown logo is the kick in the peas.

Modifying with god ugly bling I can just about understand, but using an aftermarket dial (Like just about every vintage Seiko on eBay) with a home made crown logo is a bit of a no no.

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
I cant see how Rolex can win this, the company is flooging used watches that may or may not be 100% Rolex, it will come down to how these used watches are advertised, for Rolex to win the company would have to say something like 100% Rolex, Next they will be sueing indaviduals for selling their watches.

wildoliver

9,322 posts

247 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
I personally think it's a good thing companies like Rolex take issues like this so seriously.

I wouldn't be happy if I bought a submariner only to find it was a bitsa including a non original movement or dial. To take it a step further how many average consumers could tell the difference between a genuine movement, glass and strap with a very well made and totally correct pattern fake case? The case would almost certainly not be Rolex quality but if it conformed to the correct shape as almost all don't at the moment how would an average person ever tell. Of course then they may also be able to make a strap that doesn't feel like a 6 year old in a sweat shop has made it out of old bean tins, and may even be able to get the magnification right on the cyclops. You could quickly end up with serious devaluation of the brand. To take it to minutiae I wouldn't want a Rolex with a non standard crown or any mechanicals, at least with genuine parts you know there is a QC process and if any part does break you have someone to take the matter up with. With a cheap chinky part are you really going to ever pin down the maker? I think not.

But I'm not convinced many consumers me included would be up for a lengthy legal battle as to what a used watch should constitute, Rolex can afford the battle and in the meantime it will hopefully put some off messing about with the products.


AndrewWF

280 posts

173 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Adrian W said:
I cant see how Rolex can win this, the company is flooging used watches that may or may not be 100% Rolex, it will come down to how these used watches are advertised, for Rolex to win the company would have to say something like 100% Rolex, Next they will be sueing indaviduals for selling their watches.
I would imagine the issue is, understandably, with the use of the Rolex logo on the aftermarket parts, which is intellectual property theft.

I wonder how companies like Bamford and Son and Project X get around it? Perhaps modification is allowed, where duplication is not?

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
AndrewWF said:
I would imagine the issue is, understandably, with the use of the Rolex logo on the aftermarket parts, which is intellectual property theft.

I wonder how companies like Bamford and Son and Project X get around it? Perhaps modification is allowed, where duplication is not?
Would Rolex not have to prove IPR for every component, as you say if the part actually has their name on it that’s different, however if it’s a spare can they really control it, bit like car parts, the manufacturers are not allowed a monopoly as it is not in the customers best interest.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
AndrewWF said:
I would imagine the issue is, understandably, with the use of the Rolex logo on the aftermarket parts, which is intellectual property theft.
Are you sure it's not copyright infringement?

AndrewWF

280 posts

173 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
Are you sure it's not copyright infringement?
The logo is a trademark, which is intellectual property. Copyright is more to do with creative work, like a book or a photo for example, although the two concepts can merge in some cases.

AndrewWF

280 posts

173 months

Friday 10th August 2012
quotequote all
Adrian W said:
Would Rolex not have to prove IPR for every component, as you say if the part actually has their name on it that’s different, however if it’s a spare can they really control it, bit like car parts, the manufacturers are not allowed a monopoly as it is not in the customers best interest.
I would be surprised if this case is really about the non-branded pattern parts - Rolex can't restrict those as far as I'm aware unless there is a patent of some sort (although I would be livid if pattern parts were used in my watch without prior approval!).