Rambling Thoughts on AP, VC, PP & Choice/Depreciation
Rambling Thoughts on AP, VC, PP & Choice/Depreciation
Author
Discussion

jshell

Original Poster:

12,116 posts

236 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
I've looked at getting a high end watch for some time, so here's some rambling thoughts that may be of interest...or not.

VC overseas chrono or dual time in SS or Deep Stream formats - stunning, simply stunning. Size, weight, looks, finishing and that gorgeous bracelet. fk me they are nice. I seriously want one, BUT - depreciation is heart-stopping and there is no discount to be had from the UK based AD's, and I put up a fight. I wil not buy a watch without getting some cash back, somehow! So, for the moment the VC overseas is out, unless I visit the US and bring one back at £1 = $1, which they seem to be.

Patek Nautilus - Nice, amazing finish, display back and THAT name. I tried the chrono which is strange looking with that single sub-dial, but the weight was 'right'. I tried the 3700, the plain one with no second hand it I simply couldn't feel the weight on my wrist. I also looked at getting the 'halfway', to me, model with moonphase and date, the 5712. So, the Chrono with it's strange look was £34k, no, I cannot justify that if I don't LOVE it and the weight of the 3700 felt too lady-like. Also, lack of a second hand is a killer for me. I think that despite liking the 5712, perhaps I'm not really a Patek kinda guy as it is a feminine looking piece. Also, like it or not, the Nautilus is looked down on by owners of the more traditional PP pieces as 'entry level'.

AP then. Always liked them, but slightly put off on principle by the endless limited editions of the Offshore model. I tried on the T3 which I like, I even like the butt-ugly, christmas cracker prize Arnold Legacy, but at £34k, ah'm oot. So, I've pestered AD's up and down the country trying on various models from the dual time to the Safari, the Blue scuba boutique - very nice - to the panda and the chrono with silver face/red detail and the Navy. I was even close to a deal with DomH on a watch. I looked into depreciation too, and that is pretty bad on AP's if you get the wrong model, combo or no discount.

So, depreciation on high end pieces then, why? I think it's the Rolex effect, quite frankly. Every fecker wants a Rolex as it's a marketing success like few others. They make good watches, but let's be honest, not fantastic watches. The name is everywhere though, the boutiques are everwhere and the prices sustain due to massive demand and endless price rises - a little like the housing bubble, perhaps..? I think Rolex has spoiled people with relatively depreciation free time-keeping, so we expeect more of others. On the other hand they make watches that look better with wear and tear, the detailing still glints even if they've been bashed about and are true 'tools'. The Rolex success is probably akin to the M3/RS4/evo/insert mid-price great car here and the VC,PP & AP are Ferrari/Lambo/etc where cost of ownership is a SERIOUS factor in choice, simply not for everyone. However, if you're in the market for a 'high end' watch, you should be someone who really doesn't have to care about depreciation, I suppose.


Where did I end up? Well, trying that AP ROO blue boutique edition certainly sparked something, so I tried the Diver on a rubber strap. It's nice, really nice and unlike the scuba it has batons for hour markers rather than huge fk-off numbers, that on chrono's are cut to ribbons. The diver is low key and simple, it is a good weight and thanks to a thread on TZ-UK I saw shots of one on a bracelet. So, that's where I ended up, AP ROO Diver on a bracelet and it looks GOOD! I ordered the bracelet at the time of purchase and got 20% off from the AD and living out of the UK I got my tax back on depature... Just for info, the RRP of the bracelet is £1,340, they seem to sell for near that 2nd had too. The watch weighs 240+ grams which is a bit greater than the DSSD but much, much more comfortable... Oh, and unlike the PP's or AP RO Jumbo, it's got a second hand, Yay!

longone

252 posts

271 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
When I bought myself a watch for my 50th I chose Rolex. I think it's about what matters most to you in the buying experience. Cost, reliability, rarity, resale value, appearance, ease of parts and servicing or even the general feedback from the odd informed opinion you might meet.
For me it was appearance and an impression that nobody makes a tougher watch. So I bought a ceramic Sub.
Colin.

Not Ideal

3,060 posts

219 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
Many congratulations - the Diver is a superb choice. My buddy has one and I love the non-fussyness of the face as none of the numbers or hands are interuppted by the secondary dials.

I have the ROO Panda and find it loses about a minute a week in time - let me know how you get on with yours. The steel is also very soft but scratches do polish out well.

Enjoy yours and many congrats.

Mine:


CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
jshell said:
Also, like it or not, the Nautilus is looked down on by owners of the more traditional PP pieces as 'entry level'.

I have no time for people like this mad So because it's at the lower end of the £ scale and lacking in the complication department that means that the Nautilus range is the proverbial runt of the litter, does it? What a load of pompous bks.

Anyway, it sounds like you enjoyed the experience of choosing which watch to own and it also comes across as though you bought with your heart - that's always got to be the best reason to buy anything, surely? You found that X factor and that's what you went with.

Personally I would have gone for an "entry level" 5711 (I would consider it to be my grail) if I ever had that kind of budget, and those that would look down their noses at it could sod the Hell off.


Edited by CardShark on Tuesday 28th August 21:41

jshell

Original Poster:

12,116 posts

236 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
CardShark said:
jshell said:
Also, like it or not, the Nautilus is looked down on by owners of the more traditional PP pieces as 'entry level'.

I have no time for people like this mad So because it's at the lower end of the £ scale and lacking in the complication department that means that the Nautilus range is the proverbial runt of the litter, does it? What a load of pompous bks.

Anyway, it sounds like you enjoyed the experience of choosing which watch to own and it also comes across as though you bought with your heart - that's always got to be the best reason to buy anything, surely? You found that X factor and that's what you went with.

Personally I would have gone for an "entry level" 5711 (I would consider it to be my grail) if I ever had that kind of budget, and those that would look down their noses at it could sod the Hell off.
No, I didn't like that either and it's certainly not the reason I didn't buy the Nautilus. The Nautilus to me is the better looking end of the PP range, but perhaps I'm a heathen! I'm sure my ROO Diver is looked down on by AP aficionados, but hey, I was looking at the Legacy too... smile




JOETHETOE

548 posts

248 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Not Ideal said:
Many congratulations - the Diver is a superb choice. My buddy has one and I love the non-fussyness of the face as none of the numbers or hands are interuppted by the secondary dials.

I have the ROO Panda and find it loses about a minute a week in time - let me know how you get on with yours. The steel is also very soft but scratches do polish out well.

Enjoy yours and many congrats.

Mine:

I love that Panda and the Diver especially on bracelet.

I think the Divers value will hold ok too. Incidentally i wear an ROC which i bought second hand, i know some people are not into this but high end watches are a bit like cars in that the first hit is the biggest! Had my AP a year and could sell for same price i purchased easily.

I appreciate that some people muct have new though.

Have to say bezel does mark easily though! Thinking about a top gun ceramic to rotate it with, apparemtly pretty tough!

Cheers


Not Ideal

3,060 posts

219 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
That's a lovely piece - one of the boys at work has that on the bracelet.

Absolutely nothing wrong with 2nd hand watches. Most of them are immaculately looked after.

bobbybee

889 posts

185 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Luckily I've own all three
AP ROC
VC OSC
PP N

Loved all three for different reasons, all made to similar high standards.
They are a bit like "do I get a Rolls or a Bentley?" (i'm thinking the mid 09's four door versions) both basically the same car, but one had opulence & one had speed, you simply picked the one that suited you better, not that it was a better car as such.


JOETHETOE

548 posts

248 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Not Ideal said:
That's a lovely piece - one of the boys at work has that on the bracelet.

Absolutely nothing wrong with 2nd hand watches. Most of them are immaculately looked after.
Thanks, often wear this on the bracelet it came with. you have to buy a conversion kit to wear it on leather but its nice to have the option to.

Cheers


Adam B

29,762 posts

285 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
jshell said:
The Rolex success is probably akin to the M3/RS4/evo/insert mid-price great car here and the VC,PP & AP are Ferrari/Lambo/etc where cost of ownership is a SERIOUS factor in choice, simply not for everyone. However, if you're in the market for a 'high end' watch, you should be someone who really doesn't have to care about I suppose
Interesting post. Let's see a picture then!

Where the analogy falls down though is a second hand lambo might have been badly looked after and cost a fortune to put right.

Watches tend to be looked after and any misuse is obvious and on the surface, a polish and a £500 service and it's good as new. Which is why I would buy second hand if I was fortunate to have a 10k+ budget

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Does anyone ever pay full RRP for an AP, or rather - do they get discounted in the UK much? I've had some pretty aggressive discounts offered on them in the US.

Not Ideal

3,060 posts

219 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
^ I got a healthy discount but am sure that something similar is quite easily obtained from most AD's with a decent relationship.

jshell

Original Poster:

12,116 posts

236 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Adam B said:
jshell said:
The Rolex success is probably akin to the M3/RS4/evo/insert mid-price great car here and the VC,PP & AP are Ferrari/Lambo/etc where cost of ownership is a SERIOUS factor in choice, simply not for everyone. However, if you're in the market for a 'high end' watch, you should be someone who really doesn't have to care about I suppose
Interesting post. Let's see a picture then!

Where the analogy falls down though is a second hand lambo might have been badly looked after and cost a fortune to put right.

Watches tend to be looked after and any misuse is obvious and on the surface, a polish and a £500 service and it's good as new. Which is why I would buy second hand if I was fortunate to have a 10k+ budget
I agree with 2nd hand if you cannot get a discount on new.

I'm afraid £500 wouldn't even look at a service for an AP!!!! There are a heap of terrifying stories out there. eek Looked after, or not.


Piccie here, but I hadn't removed all of the plastic protective layer yet - and it shows! Damn!



jshell

Original Poster:

12,116 posts

236 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Stu R said:
Does anyone ever pay full RRP for an AP, or rather - do they get discounted in the UK much? I've had some pretty aggressive discounts offered on them in the US.
I found easy 20% outside of London, but possible to push for more if you're aggresive and out to buy.

raptor600

1,356 posts

177 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
jshell said:
I'm afraid £500 wouldn't even look at a service for an AP!!!! There are a heap of terrifying stories out there. eek Looked after, or not.
How much are we talking? I am currently looking at an AP Scuba and would appreciate any further info! smile

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
raptor600 said:
jshell said:
I'm afraid £500 wouldn't even look at a service for an AP!!!! There are a heap of terrifying stories out there. eek Looked after, or not.
How much are we talking? I am currently looking at an AP Scuba and would appreciate any further info! smile
Servicing is pretty much menu priced for them. For the Scuba I believe it'll be the same as the Volcano, so 700 or thereabouts (if memory serves and they haven't ramped up prices), plus another couple of hundred for any refinishing and polishing (optional). Any parts that need replacing warrant a sit down with a stiff drink before enquiring by all accounts.

You can find the prices on their website, or you could last time I checked smile


jshell

Original Poster:

12,116 posts

236 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Wurls said:
Stu R said:
raptor600 said:
jshell said:
I'm afraid £500 wouldn't even look at a service for an AP!!!! There are a heap of terrifying stories out there. eek Looked after, or not.
How much are we talking? I am currently looking at an AP Scuba and would appreciate any further info! smile
Servicing is pretty much menu priced for them. For the Scuba I believe it'll be the same as the Volcano, so 700 or thereabouts (if memory serves and they haven't ramped up prices), plus another couple of hundred for any refinishing and polishing (optional). Any parts that need replacing warrant a sit down with a stiff drink before enquiring by all accounts.

You can find the prices on their website, or you could last time I checked smile
Yes there is a full price list on the AP site. AP RO full service is approx £1000 inc. refurb from memory. Chrono's a little more.
£1k+ is my understanding too.