Omega Speedmaster : Moonwatch vs other [?]
Omega Speedmaster : Moonwatch vs other [?]
Author
Discussion

alfaman

Original Poster:

6,416 posts

265 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Hi all,

would welcome a bit of advice - what is the difference between the 'moonwatch' speedmasters and the other speedmasters ? just cosmetic or any real differences ?

Also curious if the 'moonwatch' comes in a reduced size or not.

thanks smile

AndrewWF

280 posts

173 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
The original 1957 Speedmaster underwent some changes at NASA's request (bezel colour and hand shape for example) and when it became flight qualified by NASA in 1966 it gained the 'Professional' moniker. This iteration of the Speedmaster was then used for the moon landings, earning it the name moonwatch.

There are some variations of the moonwatch; special editions, clear caseback versions, ones with a slightly updated movement etc (in fact the new moonwatch is entirely different, has a twin dial chrono and a coaxial automatic movement), and there are also Speedmasters that dont carry the moonwatch tag, like broadarrow versions and most automatic versions. When it comes to general day to day performance though, the moonwatch wont outperform any other Speedmaster, but its heritage, particularly in the plain and simple original form, is unbeatable.

alfaman

Original Poster:

6,416 posts

265 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for that! .. when did the new series of moonwatches come in / what date would I need to buy before for a 2nd hand one to get the earlier style [manual ?] movement.

GCH

4,142 posts

233 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Real moonwatches have (and always have had) plexiglass crystal and are manual wind....some other speedmasters have sapphire and some are automatic:0

Edited by GCH on Thursday 4th October 12:13

AndrewWF

280 posts

173 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
alfaman said:
Thanks for that! .. when did the new series of moonwatches come in / what date would I need to buy before for a 2nd hand one to get the earlier style [manual ?] movement.
Omega still list the manual 3570.50.00 alongside the newer co-axial version (which was released late last year I believe, although it hasn't received the 'Professional' label even though it is still called a moonwatch!) so you can buy it new.

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
GCH said:
Real moonwatches have (and always have had) plexiglass crystal and are manual wind....

Edited by GCH on Thursday 4th October 12:13
This is what I thought. Not much point in having an auto in space with so little gravity to get the rotor spinning.

Were the original watches fitted with plexi crystals because alternatives weren't available at the time or because they were deemed to be safer due to the lower risk of shattering and the subsequent small part contamination issues that could be caused?

beanbag

7,346 posts

272 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Safety.....

I'm actually searching for a good 2nd hand Speedmaster Co-axial myself at the moment. Let me know if you know of a source! smile

alfaman

Original Poster:

6,416 posts

265 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
CardShark said:
This is what I thought. Not much point in having an auto in space with so little gravity to get the rotor spinning.

Were the original watches fitted with plexi crystals because alternatives weren't available at the time or because they were deemed to be safer due to the lower risk of shattering and the subsequent small part contamination issues that could be caused?
Intersting - does plexiglass scratch more than sapphire?

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
alfaman said:
ntersting - does plexiglass scratch more than sapphire?
Plexi will scratch a lot easier than something like a sapphire crystal but these scratches can easily be polished out, it's a bit like comparing plastic to glass. The trade off with having a scratch resistant sapphire is that they can shatter or chip with a hard knock, something that plexi won't do.

AndrewWF

280 posts

173 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
CardShark said:
This is what I thought. Not much point in having an auto in space with so little gravity to get the rotor spinning.

Were the original watches fitted with plexi crystals because alternatives weren't available at the time or because they were deemed to be safer due to the lower risk of shattering and the subsequent small part contamination issues that could be caused?
Rotors still work in space - there may be no gravity, but momentum still works! NASA didn't think they would work, but it has since been discovered that they do, and rather efficiently too, because once the rotor starts spinning, gravity doesn't stop it.

The plexiglass was chosen because it doesn't shatter, but it is a lot easier to scratch. The scratches in turn are easier to polish out though.

GCH

4,142 posts

233 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
CardShark said:
Were the original watches fitted with plexi crystals because alternatives weren't available at the time or because they were deemed to be safer due to the lower risk of shattering and the subsequent small part contamination issues that could be caused?
That was the done thing back then- I think sapphire glass for watches started appearing in the mid-70s, and obviously the speedmaster pre-dates that.

All of my vintage pieces are plexi, apart from a few WW2 ones with celluloid - (note: dont EVER use polywatch on celluloid eek ). Never had any issues polishing scratches out, and on the odd occasion where one has broken its normally a small crack, as opposed to shattering like sapphire does. The last crystal I replaced on one of my breitlings cost me a whopping £3.

CardShark

4,264 posts

210 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
AndrewWF said:
Rotors still work in space - there may be no gravity, but momentum still works! NASA didn't think they would work, but it has since been discovered that they do, and rather efficiently too, because once the rotor starts spinning, gravity doesn't stop it.
I guess that makes sense thumbup

andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
The 1045 I mentioned earlier was an auto movement; it was tested by NASA in '78 and passed (along with a Speedsonic), although NASA stuck with the hand-wound version. A 1045 powered Speed 125 was worn by cosmonaut Djanibekov and Reinholkd Furrer wore a Sinn 141 powered by the same, but differently named, movement, a 5012. I think the first auto-chrono in space was a Seiko, although I can't remember which one exactly.

AndrewWF

280 posts

173 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
andy_s said:
The 1045 I mentioned earlier was an auto movement; it was tested by NASA in '78 and passed (along with a Speedsonic), although NASA stuck with the hand-wound version. A 1045 powered Speed 125 was worn by cosmonaut Djanibekov and Reinholkd Furrer wore a Sinn 141 powered by the same, but differently named, movement, a 5012. I think the first auto-chrono in space was a Seiko, although I can't remember which one exactly.
Fortis still supply automatic watches to the RSFA cosmonauts too.

Chicane-UK

3,861 posts

216 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
A replacement plexiglass crystal is not an enormous expense though, when you're getting it serviced (if you're concerned about scratches / damage).

I got my Speedmaster Professional serviced in around February and whilst I don't wear it every day, and whilst I do work in an office, it does get worn a lot and I have accidentally clouted it into doors and so forth - and so far the crystal is still unmarked so far as I can see!

It really is the watch that I wanted to own for years and now I have it, I like it more and more each time I wear it. A new one is now a shade under £2,900 but speak to Dom H for some slightly more sensible pricing if you do decide to buy new. You can pick up a good used one for something in the region of £1,500 - I've now bought two at this price (a standard Speedmaster Professional, and a Sapphire Sandwich - both from the 1990's) and they've all come with boxes, history, original receipts etc.

alfaman said:
Hi all,

Also curious if the 'moonwatch' comes in a reduced size or not.

thanks smile
Only if you want an automatic. The moonwatch (i.e. The manual wind, "Professional") is one size - but don't be put off. I have tiny wrists (approx 6.5" around) and can carry off the Speedmaster no problem. It seems to wear a lot smaller than the measurements suggest.

Edited by Chicane-UK on Thursday 4th October 16:49

andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
AndrewWF said:
Fortis still supply automatic watches to the RSFA cosmonauts too.
Yes they do; the early Cosmonaut also ran with a 1045/5100, although now they are 7750s iirc. The Seiko is the 'Pogue'.

mft

1,752 posts

253 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
alfaman said:
Hi all,

would welcome a bit of advice - what is the difference between the 'moonwatch' speedmasters and the other speedmasters ? just cosmetic or any real differences ?

Also curious if the 'moonwatch' comes in a reduced size or not.

thanks smile
Funnily enough, this week's Watch Snob column covered the differences between the different movements:

The Watch Snob said:
The Speedmaster Professional is a case in which the evolution of a watch diverges from the admiration of its devotees yet remains a fine timepiece. In the canon of required knowledge for anyone calling himself a watch aficionado, the story of the Speedmaster Professional’s movement variations is well known. But, judging from some of the emails I receive, I can see it bears repeating.

The original Speedmaster used a Lemania-based hand-wound chronograph movement with a column wheel actuation mechanism. This movement, known as the calibre 321, was produced until the late 1960s and was in the watches that were worn on the moon. OMEGA proceeded to completely change this calibre, opting instead for a simpler cam-actuated chronograph movement that was cheaper to produce and easier to build and adjust. This was the caliber 861, and, despite OMEGA’s proud pronouncements, this movement never made it to the moon. Finally, the current calibre 1861 added another jewel to the movement and replaced a metal brake with a plastic one, and though probably more 1861-equipped Speedmasters have been sold than any of its predecessors, it is the least desirable of the lineage.

Make no mistake, the calibre 1861 is a fine movement, and one can understand why OMEGA made the changes it did for a watch that was purpose-built. But from a collector's perspective, the calibre 321 is the one to have. Column wheel chronographs on their own are finely tuned crafted mechanisms, and for those who don’t think the moon landing was staged by the CIA, there is no better watch.
From here: http://uk.askmen.com/fashion/mens-watches/vostok-w...

andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
...quite, if you're going for complete authenticity (don't forget they were procured well before '69) then a 321 is the one to go for, but it does cost a little more to service and will be a forty year old watch.

One of my favourite Speeds are the pre-moon ones, without the bombe lugs of the 'moonwatch' and with dauphin hands, or if you are lucky, a 'lollipop', but these are delicate and expensive beasts to run as a practical watch, same 321 movement though.

Here's an old 2998-1 lollipop for interest:

http://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&...


andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
Lots of non "Moonwatch" Speedmasters to choose from for example






GingerWizard

4,721 posts

229 months

Thursday 4th October 2012
quotequote all
andy tims said:
Lots of non "Moonwatch" Speedmasters to choose from for example



two beautiful watches! I love the retroness of the first and the second ones braclet looks uber slick! very tactile thing i imagine!