The Watch Reputation and Appreciation Ladder
Discussion
Reading through a few threads last night and it seems that there is a lot of watch manufacturers that are held in high esteem by the PH faithful and a certain respect and reputation which varies depending on the manufacturer. Obviously the quality, finish and reliability dictates how good a watch is and gives it the holding it deserves in this 'league table'. Sometimes it's all in the name! Some times it may just be brand snobbery.
This came about at dinner last night as I glanced around to see how the desserts were, I looked over to another table to notice a chap wearing a nice Omega Speedmaster and immediately appreciated the time piece as it caught my eye. Now my thoughts would have been very different, if say, he was wearing an 'Armani'. I wouldn't have judged the wearer, just the watch passing it off as an okay watch which looks alright, not paying much attention. On the other hand, I would have a higher appreciation for the wearer of a Parnis - this is only my thoughts though! I'd also throw in a few Pistonhead related subjects on my conversation (Red Bull, Director, 335D, Wheelchair Girl etc) as the guy sporting it would probably be a PH'er if he was wearing a Parnis and immediately comment on my conversation from across the room
I appreciate the Parnis more than the Armani even though it may be of a lesser build and reliability quality.
So really what manufacturers do you hold in high regards from the most respected to the lowest in terms of personal appreciation and respect? The list can be as long as you want with as many manufacturers. Obviously most appreciated at the top.
As above for example, mines goes like:
Omega
Parnis
Armani
This came about at dinner last night as I glanced around to see how the desserts were, I looked over to another table to notice a chap wearing a nice Omega Speedmaster and immediately appreciated the time piece as it caught my eye. Now my thoughts would have been very different, if say, he was wearing an 'Armani'. I wouldn't have judged the wearer, just the watch passing it off as an okay watch which looks alright, not paying much attention. On the other hand, I would have a higher appreciation for the wearer of a Parnis - this is only my thoughts though! I'd also throw in a few Pistonhead related subjects on my conversation (Red Bull, Director, 335D, Wheelchair Girl etc) as the guy sporting it would probably be a PH'er if he was wearing a Parnis and immediately comment on my conversation from across the room
I appreciate the Parnis more than the Armani even though it may be of a lesser build and reliability quality.So really what manufacturers do you hold in high regards from the most respected to the lowest in terms of personal appreciation and respect? The list can be as long as you want with as many manufacturers. Obviously most appreciated at the top.
As above for example, mines goes like:
Omega
Parnis
Armani
Edited by PD9 on Friday 12th October 13:45
Soovy said:
Harry Winston
Patek
Mille
Audemars
Hublot
Rolex
TAG
Timex
Off the top of my head.
I sense this could go badly...Patek
Mille
Audemars
Hublot
Rolex
TAG
Timex
Off the top of my head.
One thing the lists don't show is the relative level.
Is TAG only slightly better than Timex or nearly as good as all the ones above it, in the lister's view?
Is Timex terrible or a perfectly good way of telling the time for a limited amount of money?
M.
marcosgt said:
Soovy said:
Harry Winston
Patek
Mille
Audemars
Hublot
Rolex
TAG
Timex
Off the top of my head.
I sense this could go badly...Patek
Mille
Audemars
Hublot
Rolex
TAG
Timex
Off the top of my head.
One thing the lists don't show is the relative level.
Is TAG only slightly better than Timex or nearly as good as all the ones above it, in the lister's view?
Is Timex terrible or a perfectly good way of telling the time for a limited amount of money?
M.
PD9 said:
marcosgt said:
Soovy said:
Harry Winston
Patek
Mille
Audemars
Hublot
Rolex
TAG
Timex
Off the top of my head.
I sense this could go badly...Patek
Mille
Audemars
Hublot
Rolex
TAG
Timex
Off the top of my head.
One thing the lists don't show is the relative level.
Is TAG only slightly better than Timex or nearly as good as all the ones above it, in the lister's view?
Is Timex terrible or a perfectly good way of telling the time for a limited amount of money?
M.
M.
I've been thinking about this too, funnily enough, and I think my list would look something like this:
Rolex - at the top for me, simply because I love the Datejust and Daytona models, and strive to own both one day. They hold their value quite well, are well made and engineered and, in Stainless, pull of that "tool" look nicely - and also look relatively timeless, so I could wear it daily for the rest of my life and it won't look dated.
Omega - I really like the Moon watch, and the 70s stuff - the tuning fork movements etc. Not a fan of the SMP or the Orange PO but the others I like.
Heuer - on a par with Omega. Modern TAG stuff I'm not too hot on, but the chronographs like the Autavia, Silverstone etc are tasty.
Then there's the others:
Christopher Ward - left-field, again the wearer will likely know their watches.
Seiko/Citizen
Rolex - at the top for me, simply because I love the Datejust and Daytona models, and strive to own both one day. They hold their value quite well, are well made and engineered and, in Stainless, pull of that "tool" look nicely - and also look relatively timeless, so I could wear it daily for the rest of my life and it won't look dated.
Omega - I really like the Moon watch, and the 70s stuff - the tuning fork movements etc. Not a fan of the SMP or the Orange PO but the others I like.
Heuer - on a par with Omega. Modern TAG stuff I'm not too hot on, but the chronographs like the Autavia, Silverstone etc are tasty.
Then there's the others:
Christopher Ward - left-field, again the wearer will likely know their watches.
Seiko/Citizen
marcosgt said:
So the bottom end should be "I wouldn't be seen dead?", the middle is "I wear one quite a lot" and the top is "I've got one for best/might really buy one one day"?
M.
Well the bottom be would be what would you wear? Or what you would see as a decent respectably named watch. Like the poster above good to see Seiko etc in at the lower end. I fear a lot of the watch guys wouldn't be too keen to list what they see as a decent and respectable watch in the lower end of the list.M.
Here is my list of the top 20 manufactures. taken from this thread from a couple of years ago:
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...
From other thread:
Apologies in advance this is a long post.
What follows is my attempt to produce a ranked listing of the top 20 watch manufactures. It is wholly my opinion and not meant to be definitive in any way.
How I went about it:
1. I have deliberately not considered the boutique and very small manufactures like Urwerk, Richard Mille, Greubel Forsey, etc. as I feel these are in a class of their own
2. In coming to a ranking I have considered various characteristics that are important to me, such as in-house movement manufacture; innovation; variety of design; history and so on
3. I have tried to summarise in a few words the KEY points that have led me to a particular ranking
4. I have drawn the line at 20 simply to make it manageable
...
As I looked again and again at the list I came to the conclusion that it was almost impossible to have a completely reliable ordered list, and that there were actually four groups – and placing a particular maker within the group is probably quite fluid. Nevertheless they do appear *in order*.
Finally I'm sure there are some errors of fact in here, I'll accept responsibility for those now.
Group 1:
1. Jaeger-LeCoultre - variety, unparalleled movement innovation, the Reverso a standout iconic design; the only manufacture to have supplied movements to all the "big three" (my 3. 4. and 5.)
2. A.Lange & Sohn - fantastic quality and attention to detail; finishing is out of this world; innovative styles; would be 1. except only for limiting case materials to precious metals only
3. Vacheron Constantin – extraordinary range and history, beautiful designs, not exclusively in-house, but checkout the VC ultrathin 1003 movement
4. Patek Philippe - fabulous range, a true "name", quality, history, but are they just a bit dull?
5. Audemars Piguet – I’ve found it hard to get to grips with AP, however, the Royal Oak is undoubtedly an absolutely iconic design, and I have really grown to appreciate it; high quality finishing and a great range beyond the RO, including some wonderful complications
Group 2:
6. Breguet - interesting maker with a great history, rather let down by their designs; mainly but not entirely in-house
7. Blancpain – just fantastic history, any maker that can produce the Fifty Fathoms has be high on the list; in-house movements
8. Seiko - the complete manufacture; produce every component imaginable; the widest range (by just about every conceivable measure)
9. Glashutte Original - great range, relatively affordable, some very interesting designs, in-house movements, beautifully finished
10. Girard-Perregaux - extraordinary, inventive designs, now almost fully in-house
Group 3:
11. IWC – great historic maker; almost more German than Swiss; some fabulous classical designs (Portuguese, Big Pilot); some extremely fine complications; some use of bought in ebauches
12. Ulysse Nardin – great name, but some rather “challenging” designs and rather too much use of bought in movements
13. Rolex - universally known, and to the non-WIS often the "best"; however, too few styles, and limited complications to rank higher
14. Zenith - maker of probably the greatest chrono movement of them all, but not very innovative (only two movements the El Primero and the Elite), finding their way again but some of the recent designs are a bit in your face
15. Chopard - most closely associated with motor racing; a great history; mixture of bought in and in-house movements but many fascinating in-house developments
Group 4:
16. Nomos - in-house; very affordable; interesting elegant designs with some unusual complications;
17. Omega - fabulous history; great range; let down by near ubiquitous use of bought in movements
18. Panerai - very clear house style; but rather limited variety in my view; trades heavily on a slightly tenuous history; mainly basic bought-in movements; new in-house movements disproportionately expensive
19. Breitling – almost entirely bought in movements; clear (limiting?) association with aviation
20. Frederique Constant – rather under-rated in my view; some in house movements; rather “classical” range of styles, with little or nothing in the sports line (as an aside they have a lot of detail on their movements on their website – worth a look)
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...
From other thread:
Apologies in advance this is a long post.
What follows is my attempt to produce a ranked listing of the top 20 watch manufactures. It is wholly my opinion and not meant to be definitive in any way.
How I went about it:
1. I have deliberately not considered the boutique and very small manufactures like Urwerk, Richard Mille, Greubel Forsey, etc. as I feel these are in a class of their own
2. In coming to a ranking I have considered various characteristics that are important to me, such as in-house movement manufacture; innovation; variety of design; history and so on
3. I have tried to summarise in a few words the KEY points that have led me to a particular ranking
4. I have drawn the line at 20 simply to make it manageable
...
As I looked again and again at the list I came to the conclusion that it was almost impossible to have a completely reliable ordered list, and that there were actually four groups – and placing a particular maker within the group is probably quite fluid. Nevertheless they do appear *in order*.
Finally I'm sure there are some errors of fact in here, I'll accept responsibility for those now.
Group 1:
1. Jaeger-LeCoultre - variety, unparalleled movement innovation, the Reverso a standout iconic design; the only manufacture to have supplied movements to all the "big three" (my 3. 4. and 5.)
2. A.Lange & Sohn - fantastic quality and attention to detail; finishing is out of this world; innovative styles; would be 1. except only for limiting case materials to precious metals only
3. Vacheron Constantin – extraordinary range and history, beautiful designs, not exclusively in-house, but checkout the VC ultrathin 1003 movement
4. Patek Philippe - fabulous range, a true "name", quality, history, but are they just a bit dull?
5. Audemars Piguet – I’ve found it hard to get to grips with AP, however, the Royal Oak is undoubtedly an absolutely iconic design, and I have really grown to appreciate it; high quality finishing and a great range beyond the RO, including some wonderful complications
Group 2:
6. Breguet - interesting maker with a great history, rather let down by their designs; mainly but not entirely in-house
7. Blancpain – just fantastic history, any maker that can produce the Fifty Fathoms has be high on the list; in-house movements
8. Seiko - the complete manufacture; produce every component imaginable; the widest range (by just about every conceivable measure)
9. Glashutte Original - great range, relatively affordable, some very interesting designs, in-house movements, beautifully finished
10. Girard-Perregaux - extraordinary, inventive designs, now almost fully in-house
Group 3:
11. IWC – great historic maker; almost more German than Swiss; some fabulous classical designs (Portuguese, Big Pilot); some extremely fine complications; some use of bought in ebauches
12. Ulysse Nardin – great name, but some rather “challenging” designs and rather too much use of bought in movements
13. Rolex - universally known, and to the non-WIS often the "best"; however, too few styles, and limited complications to rank higher
14. Zenith - maker of probably the greatest chrono movement of them all, but not very innovative (only two movements the El Primero and the Elite), finding their way again but some of the recent designs are a bit in your face
15. Chopard - most closely associated with motor racing; a great history; mixture of bought in and in-house movements but many fascinating in-house developments
Group 4:
16. Nomos - in-house; very affordable; interesting elegant designs with some unusual complications;
17. Omega - fabulous history; great range; let down by near ubiquitous use of bought in movements
18. Panerai - very clear house style; but rather limited variety in my view; trades heavily on a slightly tenuous history; mainly basic bought-in movements; new in-house movements disproportionately expensive
19. Breitling – almost entirely bought in movements; clear (limiting?) association with aviation
20. Frederique Constant – rather under-rated in my view; some in house movements; rather “classical” range of styles, with little or nothing in the sports line (as an aside they have a lot of detail on their movements on their website – worth a look)
I think that the late George Daniels and his protégé, Roger Smith, have to be excluded from lists like these on the basis that they're in a different league from the (relatively) massed produced watches from all of the others - they're entirely hand crafted, hand assembled bespoke pieces.
I read somewhere that George Daniels was a master 32 of the 34 skills required to make the components of his watches (wiki says that he could make an entire watch), including forming and grinding the crystals. How many of J-LC's or L&S's employees could say the same? That's not to say that the latter don't deserve to be at the top, within context their positions can be justified.
I'm not aware of anyone else that works like Roger Smith. The closest is Robert Loomes whose Robin watch can claim to be built up from components made in England and then finished of in RB's workshop.
ETA competely forgot about Dornblüth....
I read somewhere that George Daniels was a master 32 of the 34 skills required to make the components of his watches (wiki says that he could make an entire watch), including forming and grinding the crystals. How many of J-LC's or L&S's employees could say the same? That's not to say that the latter don't deserve to be at the top, within context their positions can be justified.
I'm not aware of anyone else that works like Roger Smith. The closest is Robert Loomes whose Robin watch can claim to be built up from components made in England and then finished of in RB's workshop.
ETA competely forgot about Dornblüth....
Edited by CardShark on Friday 12th October 23:32
CardShark said:
I think that the late George Daniels and his protégé, Roger Smith, have to be excluded from lists like these on the basis that they're in a different league from the (relatively) massed produced watches from all of the others - they're entirely hand crafted, hand assembled bespoke pieces.
I read somewhere that George Daniels was a master 32 of the 34 skills required to make the components of his watches (wiki says that he could make an entire watch), including forming and grinding the crystals. How many of J-LC's or L&S's employees could say the same? That's not to say that the latter don't deserve to be at the top, within context their positions can be justified.
I'm not aware of anyone else that works like Roger Smith. The closest is Robert Loomes whose Robin watch can claim to be built up from components made in England and then finished of in RB's workshop.
ETA competely forgot about Dornblüth....
Same here. In the original vein of the OP I tend to exclude these high-end, boutique watchmakers - not because I don't appreciate them, but because I know, realistically, I'm never likely to see one, let alone covet it myself. I read somewhere that George Daniels was a master 32 of the 34 skills required to make the components of his watches (wiki says that he could make an entire watch), including forming and grinding the crystals. How many of J-LC's or L&S's employees could say the same? That's not to say that the latter don't deserve to be at the top, within context their positions can be justified.
I'm not aware of anyone else that works like Roger Smith. The closest is Robert Loomes whose Robin watch can claim to be built up from components made in England and then finished of in RB's workshop.
ETA competely forgot about Dornblüth....
Edited by CardShark on Friday 12th October 23:32
In my aspiration category I have Patek and Vacheron. I find myself liking alot of their models and they have a timeless look about them I find hard to fault. Just falling out of this category I place Audemars and possibly Hublot. Mainly because I like one or two in each range but IMO like Panerai they tend to release lots of variations to the same watch.
Slightly lower in the affordable if I save up for the year range Rolex are top. Lots of reasons. Classic timeless designs, quality, in house movements and as I'm not supidly sickeningly rich its nice to if I need to liquidate my assets I've got some "instant" cash sat there should the poo hit the fan. The last reason is why I have them as top in my books for this category. Others in this category, Glashute, JLC, Omega, Zenith. I'd have to go with Glashute and Zenith being my faves along with Rolex. I've got a thing for the Ralph Lauren watches that JLC have been making as well. I keep meaning to take a trip to London to try one on.
Same category but I can't see me owning. Panerai and IWC. Nice looking but they just don't suit me.
In the I could buy one and not tell the missus why we're eating super noodles again for the 5th time this week providing I scrimp elsewhere range. Longines and Tag. I've had a couple of Tags and see nothing wrong with them. I've only chopped them into move myself up the ladder. If money was no option I'd have kept them. Longines I can't fault. Lovely looking watches great history and that air of class. I'd throw Sinn in this range as well. I've seen one in the flesh and it was a lovely watch.
Bottom range and this is price based. Tissot mainly for the dressier watches in their collection. Seiko I'd put in this range but there is something again like Panerai and IWC about them that stops me from adding them to the want list.
I'd like my collection to be PP, Audemars, Rolex, Glashute, Zenith and Longines with some G Shocks thrown in.
Slightly lower in the affordable if I save up for the year range Rolex are top. Lots of reasons. Classic timeless designs, quality, in house movements and as I'm not supidly sickeningly rich its nice to if I need to liquidate my assets I've got some "instant" cash sat there should the poo hit the fan. The last reason is why I have them as top in my books for this category. Others in this category, Glashute, JLC, Omega, Zenith. I'd have to go with Glashute and Zenith being my faves along with Rolex. I've got a thing for the Ralph Lauren watches that JLC have been making as well. I keep meaning to take a trip to London to try one on.
Same category but I can't see me owning. Panerai and IWC. Nice looking but they just don't suit me.
In the I could buy one and not tell the missus why we're eating super noodles again for the 5th time this week providing I scrimp elsewhere range. Longines and Tag. I've had a couple of Tags and see nothing wrong with them. I've only chopped them into move myself up the ladder. If money was no option I'd have kept them. Longines I can't fault. Lovely looking watches great history and that air of class. I'd throw Sinn in this range as well. I've seen one in the flesh and it was a lovely watch.
Bottom range and this is price based. Tissot mainly for the dressier watches in their collection. Seiko I'd put in this range but there is something again like Panerai and IWC about them that stops me from adding them to the want list.
I'd like my collection to be PP, Audemars, Rolex, Glashute, Zenith and Longines with some G Shocks thrown in.
The only watches that have been genuinely shown to hold (some) value (forget appreciate) are Patek Philippe and Rolex.
PP's are still the only brand to own come auction time, and they're still the only brand that can service/repair/restore every single model of every single watch they've ever made since the start (as well as holding a record of each model/first customer/case number/movement number in a factory database.
Add to the fact that PP are independently owned so they're not under pressure to increase production/dilute quality/meet the latest commercial trend etc AND that their designs still resemble watches from which you can *tell the bloody time** (which means you're not likely to be wearing something cringeworthy a few years from now (will anyone other than schoolkids really be wearing an AP ROO "bumblee" 10 years from now?) and you've got a unique manufacturer that even the likes of Lange/VC/Breguet and certainly AP cannot compete with.
Beyond that, I've got massive respect for Rolex. The quality of watches given how many they make is actually incredible. And, for those that aren't quite in the know, they're still the very best brand to own as shown by pretty good residuals compared to the rest.
JLC make some fantastic watches as well - great movements and a nice brand - not quite the quality of VC/PP though I think. Breguet too. Great name in there also.
I wouldn't touch RM and the boutique brands like Gruebel Forsey with a barge pole. They may well have fabulously made pieces etc but IMO the designs look like something out of playschool and lack any tactile beauty to my eyes. Starting to look like Lego watches.. In fact, I'll go further, and say that these are brands "of the moment" and though they may be around for decades to come, it'll take a braver (or perhaps richer) man than me to buy one. Beyond £25k and especially above £50k, I won't risk buying what I see as a "fashion victims watch" and more specifically I won't buy something something which doesn't have PP on the dial. I want something which looks gorgeous today and 20 years from now and I'm not in the business of spooning money.....
My ranking:
1. PP
2. (something resembling the rest of the watch "holy trinity" VC/Lange/Breguet - not AP though - I think they make terrible watches personally).
5. JLC
6. Rolex
Just my 2p.
PP's are still the only brand to own come auction time, and they're still the only brand that can service/repair/restore every single model of every single watch they've ever made since the start (as well as holding a record of each model/first customer/case number/movement number in a factory database.
Add to the fact that PP are independently owned so they're not under pressure to increase production/dilute quality/meet the latest commercial trend etc AND that their designs still resemble watches from which you can *tell the bloody time** (which means you're not likely to be wearing something cringeworthy a few years from now (will anyone other than schoolkids really be wearing an AP ROO "bumblee" 10 years from now?) and you've got a unique manufacturer that even the likes of Lange/VC/Breguet and certainly AP cannot compete with.
Beyond that, I've got massive respect for Rolex. The quality of watches given how many they make is actually incredible. And, for those that aren't quite in the know, they're still the very best brand to own as shown by pretty good residuals compared to the rest.
JLC make some fantastic watches as well - great movements and a nice brand - not quite the quality of VC/PP though I think. Breguet too. Great name in there also.
I wouldn't touch RM and the boutique brands like Gruebel Forsey with a barge pole. They may well have fabulously made pieces etc but IMO the designs look like something out of playschool and lack any tactile beauty to my eyes. Starting to look like Lego watches.. In fact, I'll go further, and say that these are brands "of the moment" and though they may be around for decades to come, it'll take a braver (or perhaps richer) man than me to buy one. Beyond £25k and especially above £50k, I won't risk buying what I see as a "fashion victims watch" and more specifically I won't buy something something which doesn't have PP on the dial. I want something which looks gorgeous today and 20 years from now and I'm not in the business of spooning money.....
My ranking:
1. PP
2. (something resembling the rest of the watch "holy trinity" VC/Lange/Breguet - not AP though - I think they make terrible watches personally).
5. JLC
6. Rolex
Just my 2p.
Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


