Alternative to ladies Cartier tank?
Alternative to ladies Cartier tank?
Author
Discussion

crashS2K

Original Poster:

107 posts

285 months

Monday 5th November 2012
quotequote all
Would like to mark the birth of our second child with a present to wife. Personally would love to get a Cartier ladies tank but budgets aren't going to stretch that far.

Any suggestions for cheaper alternatives?

jonny70

1,280 posts

189 months

Monday 5th November 2012
quotequote all
Look at Longines & Raymond weil. Thy both make very elegant ladies watches.

This is about a grand;

http://www.raymond-weil.com/EN/Ladies-Watches/Jasm...

Arrive Alive

282 posts

202 months

Monday 5th November 2012
quotequote all
Its difficult without knowing the budget.
If the budget is a few hundred I'd recommend a 'nearly new' Baume et Mercier Hampton or Hampton Milleis.
Here is my wife's:



Also available on a bracelet, with diamonds etc

P.S. Brand new they are 1-3K. B&M are owned by Cartier.

Edited by Arrive Alive on Tuesday 6th November 09:36

AlexWF

127 posts

173 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Like someone else said, depends on the budget but I'd agree with the Longines recommendation. They make a great watch for the money, and in reality it's no lesser quality than the Cartier Tank Francaise.....(although I'm sure there is plenty of people who would disagree!) They're both going to be quartz after all so there's no justification of better quality movements in the Cartier. Plus Cartier are extremely expensive to have serviced - even the quartz models.

What about something like this:



New it's only £750 ish, can be picked up pre-owned for a few hundred pounds. Or you could even get one with a diamond case for less than the price of a pre-owned steel Cartier TF:


crashS2K

Original Poster:

107 posts

285 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the recommendations chaps. That longings is nice - what model is it and where would you recommend second hand purchase?

ism123

373 posts

241 months

Saturday 10th November 2012
quotequote all
Have you considered 2nd hand models? Or maybe a vintage Rolex eg 34mm air king?

Rushmore

1,223 posts

173 months

Sunday 11th November 2012
quotequote all
The Tank - just like the Lady Datejust - is a very classic design. You are paying for that, rather than for what is inside (like a painting or drawing).

I would either wait a bit until times a better and then go for the Tank (if that is what she wants) rather than make a compromise on something which doesnt win your/her heart.


SimonMaidenhead

2,655 posts

234 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
Just spotted this:-


SimonMaidenhead

2,655 posts

234 months

Fitz666

692 posts

173 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
AlexWF said:
Like someone else said, depends on the budget but I'd agree with the Longines recommendation. They make a great watch for the money, and in reality it's no lesser quality than the Cartier Tank Francaise.....(although I'm sure there is plenty of people who would disagree!) They're both going to be quartz after all so there's no justification of better quality movements in the Cartier. Plus Cartier are extremely expensive to have serviced - even the quartz models.

What about something like this:



New it's only £750 ish, can be picked up pre-owned for a few hundred pounds. Or you could even get one with a diamond case for less than the price of a pre-owned steel Cartier TF:

Ha, that's the very watch I was going to post up after reading the OP's post. Bought one for my better half for her 40th and managed to get the very limited copper faced one, but that was 10 years ago...

62GRANTIII

199 posts

224 months

Saturday 17th November 2012
quotequote all
Have you considered a Roy King in solid silver.
I have bought ten differant styles of these for my wife.
Roy King designed classic tank watches & other classy styles for Cartier & others prior to bringing out his own brand.
Worn in period by the good & the famous Still look bob on !!
Cheers Ian B